Information flow between the Templar brothers during their trial in France (1309-1311)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12775/OM.2020.004Keywords
history, the Middle Ages, military orders, Templars, France, communication, Templars’ trial, papacyAbstract
After the arrest of the Templars in France in October 1307, they were held in various prisons throughout the kingdom for almost three years. They did not have the opportunity to exchange information with each other and, above all, to get instructions from the leaders of the Order. This changed in the beginning of 1310, when more than 650 brothers came to Paris to participate in the inquiry led the papal commission against the Order as a whole. In the beginning of the Paris proceedings, French Templars were offered a chance to defend the Order together. They tried to make use of this opportunity, but in May of 1310, after fifty-four brothers were condemned as relapsed heretics by the Council of Sens and burned at stake, they abandoned it.
The paper focuses mainly on the first phase of the Paris proceedings (before the Council of Sens). The information flow between the Templar brothers and its influence on their situation at that time will be analysed. It will address the following questions: Was the possibility to exchange the information enough for the Templars to defend the Order in an effective manner? Could they do this without the involvement of the Grand Master and other dignitaries of the Order? The answers to these questions will then allow to show that, contrary to the opinion of the vast majority of historians working on this topic, the Templars lost their chance to defend the Order long before the tragic events of May 1310.
The paper focuses mainly on the first phase of the Paris proceedings (before the Council of Sens). The information flow between the Templar brothers and its influence on their situation at that time will be analyzed. It will allow to answer the following questions: Was the possibility to exchange the information enough for the Templars to defend effectively the Order? Could they do it without the involvement of the grand master and other dignitaries of the Order? The answers to those questions will then allow to show that the Templars lost their chance to defend the Order long before the tragic events of May 1310.
References
Primary sources:
Les actes pontificaux originaux des Archives nationales de Paris. Vol. 3. Edited by Bernard Barbiche. Vatican: Biblioteca Apostolica Vaticana, 1982.
Le procés des Templiers. Vol. 1‒2. Edited by Jules Michelet. Paris: Imprimerie Royale, 1841‒1851 (repr. Paris: Editions du C.T.H.S., 1987).
Processus contra Templarios in Francia. Procès-verbaux de la procedure menée par la commission pontificale à Paris (1309‒1311). Vol. 1. Edited by Magdalena Satora. Leiden: Brill, 2020.
Secondary sources:
Barber, Malcolm. “James of Molay, the Last Grand Master of the Order of the Temple”. Studia Monastica 14 (1972): 110‒120.
Barber, Malcolm. The Trial of the Templars. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006, 2nd edition.
Demurger, Alain. “Éléments pour une prosopographie du ʻpeuple templierʼ. La comparution des templiers devant la commission pontificale de Paris (février‒mai 1310)”. In Élites et ordres militaires au Moyen Âge. Rencontre autour d’Alain Demurger, edited by Philippe Josserand, Luis Filipe Oliveira, and Damien Carraz, 17‒36. Madrid: Casa de Velázquez, 2015.
Demurger, Alain. Jacques de Molay. Le crépuscule des Templiers. Paris: Payot, 2007, 2nd edition.
Demurger, Alain. La persécution des templiers. Journal (1305‒1314). Paris: Payot, 2015.
Lecler, Joseph. Vienne 1311‒1312. Histoire des conciles oecuméniques 8. Paris: Editions de l’Orante, 1964.
Lizerand, Georges. Clément V et Philippe le Bel. Paris: Hachette, 1910.
Lizerand, Georges. “Les dépositions du grand maître Jacques de Molay au procès des templiers (1307‒1314).” Le Moyen Âge 26 (1913): 81‒106.
Satora, Magdalena. “Przyczyny zmiany zeznań wielkiego mistrza zakonu templariuszy, Jakuba de Molay w latach 1307‒1314.” In Kaci, święci, templariusze, edited by Błażej Śliwiński, 265‒284. Malbork: Muzeum Zamkowe, 2008.
Satora, Magdalena. Sprawa templariuszy w dyplomacji zachodnioeuropejskiej 1307‒1312. Poznań: Wydawnictwo Poznańskie, 2011.
Viollet, Paul. “Les interrogatoires de Jacques de Molay, grand maître du Temple. Conjectures.” Mémoires de l’Institut national de France 38 (1911): 121‒136.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
CC BY ND 4.0. The Creator/Contributor is the Licensor, who grants the Licensee a non-exclusive license to use the Work on the fields indicated in the License Agreement.
Stats
Number of views and downloads: 554
Number of citations: 0
