Crusade or Christianization? The polemic against the Teutonic Knights in light of French travelers’ accounts of the late Middle Ages
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12775/OM.2015.008Keywords
Later crusades, conversion of unbelievers, council of Constance, Teutonic Order, Lithuania, French participation in the Baltic crusadesAbstract
As a continuation of the political unrest opposing the Kingdom of Poland and the Grand-Duchy of Lithuania to the Order of the Teutonic Knights, the conversion of the last Baltic pagans was among the cases debated by the council of Constance (1414–1418). While the Teutonic Knights used to storm Lithuania twice a year, with the help of knights coming from all over Europe, Polish spokesmen intended to prove that no baptism could be achieved this way. The aim of this paper is to use narratives relating the experiences of some French travelers (crusaders or diplomats) who had the opportunity to encounter the Baltic reality. A comparative study of the texts read during the council of Constance with the writings of Guillaume de Machaut, Philippe de Mézières or Guillebert de Lannoy enable the researcher to see this quarrel in a new light. Looking at these foreign sources leads us to understand that some of the facts used by the Polish and Lithuanian spokesmen in Constance to darken the Teutonic Order’s image were already known by a few people in Western Europe. In particular, Cracovian rector Paulus Vladimiri (Paweł Włodkowic)’s characterization of the Teutonic raids as worldly and disconnected from Christian ideals match the critics formulated by Philippe de Mézières on the noblemen’s crusades. Vladimiri’s questioning of the effectiveness of the Order’s methods to bring baptism to Baltic pagans was also raised in at least two French travelers’ testimonies. However, if the remnant of paganism within the territory held by the Teutonic brothers was noted by some visitors, it was not explicitly disapproved of; for these Frenchmen mostly interested in chivalric activities and honorable deeds, the conversion of unbelievers was far less important than it was for the Polish and Lithuanian diplomats at Constance. Whilst the same facts were observed by both, their interpretation differed heavily.References
Antoine de la Salle, “Saintré.” Edited by Mario Eusebi, 2 vols., Paris: Champion, 1993-1994.
Baltų religijos ir mitologijos šaltiniai, éd. Norbertas Vėlius, vol. 1, Vilnius: Mokslo ir enciklopedijų leidybos centras, 1996.
Bormans, Stanislas., edit. Li Myreur des Histors. Chronique et geste de Jean des Preis dit d’Outremeuse. vol. 6, Bruxelles: Hayez, 1880.
Brown, Muriel J. A., edit. Philippe de Mézières’ Order of the Passion: an annotated edition, thèse non publiée, University of Nebraska, 1971.
“Die Chronik Wigands von Marburg.” Edited by Theodor Hirsch. In Scriptores rerum Prussicarum, edited by Theodor Hirsch, Max Töppen, Ernst Strehlke. vol. II, 429-662. Leipzig: Hirzel, 1863.
Ehrlich, Ludwik., edit. Pisma wybrane Pawła Włodkowica (= Works of Paul Wladimiri (a selection)). 3 vols., Warszawa: Pax, 1968-1969.
Finke, Heinrich. Hollnsteiner, Johannes. Heimpel, Hermann, edit. Acta Concilii Constanciensis. 4 vols. Münster: Regensbergsche Buchhandlung, 1896-1928.
Gąsiorowski, Antoni. Walczak, Ryszard., edit. Kodeks dyplomatyczny Wielkopolski. vol. 7, Warszawa, Poznań: Państwowe Wydawnictwo Naukowe, 1985.
Gravier, Gabriel., edit. Le Canarien: livre de la conquête et conversion des Canaries (1402-1422). Rouen: C. Métérie, 1874.
Hamy, Ernest-Théodor., edit. Le Livre de la description des pays de Gilles le Bouvier, dit Berry. Paris: E. Leroux, 1908.
Hoepffner, Ernest., edit. Œuvres de Guillaume de Machaut. vol. 3, Paris: Firmin-Didot, 1921.
Jatulis, Paulius., edit. Codex Mednicensis seu Samogitae Diocensis. part 1, Rome: Academia Lituana Catholica Scientiarum, 1984.
[Jean Cabaret d’Orville], “Chronique du bon duc Loys de Bourbon.” Edited by Alphonse-Martial Chazaud, Paris: Librairie Renouard, 1876.
von Kraus, Carl., edit. Deutsche Liederdichter des 13. Jahrhunderts. vol. 1, Tübingen: Niemeyer, 1952 (reprint: 1978).
Lalande, Denis., edit. Le Livre des Fais du bon messire Jehan le Meingre dit Boucicquaut, mareschal de France et gouverneur de Jennes. Genève, Paris: Droz, 1985.
Loomis, Louise R. Mundy, John H. Moody, Kennerly M., edit. a. trad. The Council of Constance: the Unification of the Church. New York: Columbia University Press, 1961.
Michael, Maurice., edit. a. trad. The Annals of Jan Dlugosz. Chichester: IM Publications LLP, 1997.
“Petri de Dusburg Chronicon terrae Prussiae.” Edited by Max Toeppen. In Scriptores rerum Prussicarum, edited by Theodor Hirsch, Max Töppen, Ernst Strehlke. vol. 1, 21-219. Leipzig: Hirzel, 1860.
Philippe de Mézières, “Le Songe du Viel Pelerin.” Edited by Joël Blanchard, 2 vols., Genève, Paris: Droz, 2015.
Philippe de Mézières, Chancellor of Cyprus, “Le Songe du Vieil Pelerin.” Edited by George W. Coopland, 2 vols., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1969.
Philippi, Rudolf. Seraphim, August. a. o., prep. Preußisches Urkundenbuch. vol. 1,1, Königsberg/Pr.: Hartungsche Verlagsdruckerei, 1882.
Potvin, Charles., edit. Œuvres de Ghillebert de Lannoy, voyageur, diplomate et moraliste. Louvain: Imprimerie de P. et J. Lefever: 1878.
Prochaska, Antoni., edit. Codex epistolaris Vitoldi. part 1-2, Cracoviae: Academiae Literarum Cracoviensis, 1882.
Raczyński, Edward., edit. Codex diplomaticus Lithuaniae. Wrocław: Zygmunt Schletter, 1845.
Voigt, Johannes., edit. Codex diplomaticus Prussicus. Codex Diplomaticus Prussicus. Urkunden-Sammlung zur ältern Geschichte Preusens aus dem Königl. Geheimen Archiv zu Königsberg nebst Regesten. vol. VI, Königsberg: Bei den Gebrüder Bornträger, 1861.
Bertrand, Anne. “Un seigneur bourguignon en Europe de l’Est: Guillebert de Lannoy (1386-1462).” Le Moyen-Age 95 (1989): 293-309.
Belch, Stanislaus F. Paulus Vladimiri and his doctrine concerning international law and politics. 2 vols., Londres, La Haye, Paris: Mouton, 1965.
Błaszczyk, Grzegorz. Dzieje stosunków polskich-litewskich. vol. II, part 1: Od Krewa do Lublina. Poznań: Wydawnictwo Poznańskie, 2007.
Boockmann, Hartmut. Johannes Falkenberg, der Deutsche Orden und die polnische Politik. Untersuchungen zur politischen Theorie des späteren Mittelalters. Mit einem Anhang: Die Satira des Johannes Falkenberg. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1975.
Brennan, Timothy M. Just war, sovereignty, and canon law. Legal arguments over the Lithuanian Crusade and the rights of unbelievers at the Council of Constance (1414-1418), thèse non publiée, University of Kansas, 2006.
Buschinger, Danielle. Olivier, Mathieu. Les Chevaliers Teutoniques. Paris: Ellipses, 2007.
Chollet, Loïc. “Ecrire l’histoire de la conquête: l’utilisation de l’histoire dans la polémique contre l’Ordre Teutonique au sujet des droits des infidèles (1386-1418).” Hereditas Monasteriorum 4 (2014): 17-47.
Christiansen, Eric. Northern Crusades. The Baltic and the catholic frontier 1100-1525. London, New York: Macmillan, 1980 (reprint: 1997).
Contamine, Philippe. “„Les princes, barons et chevaliers qui a la chevalerie au service de Dieu se sont ja vouez”. Recherches prosopographiques sur l’ordre de la Passion de Jésus-Christ (1385-1395).” In La noblesse et la croisade à la fin du Moyen-Âge (France, Bourgogne, Bohême), edited by Martin Nejedlý, Jaroslav Svátek, 43-67. Toulouse: Presses universitaires du Midi, 2009.
Contamine, Philippe. La Guerre au Moyen Âge. Paris: Presses universitaires de France, 1980.
Dembowski, Peter. “Reflets chevaleresques du Nord-Est dans l’œuvre de Jean Froissart.” Roczniki Humanistyczne 34 (1986), 2: 137-143.
Dzieje chrześcijaństwa na Litwie, edited by Vytautas Ališauskas, Warszawa: Państwowy Instytut Wydawniczy, 2014.
Ehlers, Axel. “The crusade against Lithuania reconsidered.” In Crusade and Conversion on the Baltic Frontier, 1150-1500, edited by Alan V. Murray, 21-44. Aldershot: Ashgate 2001.
Ehlers, Axel. “The Use of Indulgences by the Teutonic Order in the Middle Ages.” In The Military Orders. vol. 3: History and Heritage, edited by Victor Mallia-Milanes, 139-146. Aldershot: Ashgate, 2008.
Fonnesberg-Schmidt, Iben. Popes and the Baltic Crusades, 1147-1254. Leiden, Boston: Brill, 2007.
Gimbutas, Marija. “The Pre-Christian Religion of Lithuania.” In La cristianizzazione della Lituania. Atti del Colloquio internazionale di storia ecclesiastica in occasione del 6 centenario della Lituania cristiana (1387-1987). Roma, 24–26 giugno 1987, editd by Paulius Rabikauskas, 13-25. Città del Vaticano: Libreria editrice vaticana, 1989.
Gładysz, Mikołaj. The Forgotten Crusaders. Poland and the Crusader Movement in the Twelfth and Thirteenth Centuries, trans. by Paul Barford, Leiden, Boston: Brill, 2012.
Głodek, Marzena. Utopia Europy zjednoczonej. Życia i idee Filipa de Mézières (1327-1405). Słupsk: Wyższa Szkoła Pedagogiczna, 1997.
Gouguenheim, Sylvain. Les Chevaliers Teutoniques. Paris: Tallandier, 2007.
Gouguenheim, Sylvain. “Les Guerres des ordres militaires furent-elles des guerres chevaleresques?” In Chevalerie et christianisme aux XIIe et XIIIe siècles, edited by Martin Aurell, Catalina Girbea, 291-313. Rennes: Presses universitaires de Rennes, 2011.
Gouguenheim, Sylvain. “L’Ordre Teutonique en Prusse au XIIIe siècle. Expansion de la chrétienté latine et souveraineté politique.” In L’expansion occidentale (XIe-XVe siècles) Formes et conséquences (Actes des congrès de la Société des historiens médiévistes de l'enseignement supérieur public. 33e congrès, Madrid, 2002), edited by Michel Balard, 97-113. Paris: Publications de la Sorbonne 2003.
Gouguenheim, Sylvain. Tannenberg 1410. Paris: Tallandier, 2012.
Grewe, Wilhelm. The Epochs of International Law, trans. by Michael Byers, Berlin, New York: De Gruyters, 2000.
von Güttner-Sporzynski, Darius. “Memorialisation and Historical Awareness – Witness Testimonies in Trials between Poland and the Teutonic Order in the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Centuries.” In Arguments and Counter-Arguments. The Political Thought of the 14th-and 15th Centuries during the Polish-Teutonic Order Trials and Disputes, edited by Wiesław Sieradzan, 55-67. Toruń: Wydawnictwo Naukowe UMK, 2012.
von Güttner-Sporzynski, Darius. “Constructing memory: holy war in the Chronicle of the Poles by Bishop Vincentius of Cracow.” Journal of Medieval History 40 (2014), 3: 276-291.
Halecki, Oskar. “Gilbert de Lannoy and his Discovery of East Central Europe.” Bulletin of the Polish Institute of Arts and Sciences in America 2 (1944): 314-331.
Hanly Michael. “Philippe de Mézières and the Peace Movement.” In Philippe de Mézières and his Age. Piety and Politics in the Fourteenth Century, edited by Renate Blumenfeld-Kosinski, Kiril Petkov, 61-82. Leiden, Boston: Brill 2012.
Housley Norman. The Later Crusades, 1274-1580. From Lyon to Alcazar. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1992.
Jakštas, Juozas. Das Baltikum in der Kreuzzugsbewegung des 14. Jhs. Die Nachrichten Philipps de Mézières über die baltischen Gebiete. Bonn: Baltisches Forschungsinstitut, 1959.
Jóźwiak, Sławomir. Trupinda, Janusz. Organizacja życia na zamku krzyżackim w Malborku w czasach wielkich mistrzów 1309-1457. Malbork: Muzeum Zamkowe 22011.
Kiaupa, Zigmantas. Kiaupienė, Jūratė. Kuncevičius, Albinas. History of Lithuania before 1795. Vilnius: Arlila Press, 2000.
Kiparsky, Valentin. “Philippe de Mézières sur les rives de la Baltique.” Neuphilologische Mitteilungen 41 (1940), 3/4: 61-67.
Kļaviņš, Kaspars. “The Ideology of Christianity and Pagan Practices among the Teutonic Knights.” Journal of Baltic Studies 37 (2006), 3: 260-276.
Lalande, Denis. Jean II le Meingre, dit Boucicaut (1366-1421). Étude d’une biographie héroïque. Genève: Droz, 1988.
Lenartowicz, Aleksandra. “Paweł Włodkowic and Andreas Laskary as the Authors of the Polish Revindication Programme against the State of the Teutonic Order in 1412-1418.” In Arguments and Counter-Arguments. The Political Thought of the 14th-and 15th Centuries during the Polish-Teutonic Order Trials and Disputes, edited by Wiesław Sieradzan, 111-122. Toruń: Wydawnictwo Naukowe UMK, 2012.
Mažeika, Rasa. “An Amicable Enmity. Some Peculiarities in Teutonic-Balt Relations in the Chronicles of the Baltic Crusades.” In The Germans and the East, edited by Charles W. Ingrao, Franz A. J. Szabo, 49-58. West Lafayette: Purdue University Press, 2008.
Mažeika, Rasa. “Granting Power to the Enemy Gods in the Chronicles of the Baltic Crusades.” In Medieval Frontiers: Concepts and Practices, edited by David Abulafia, Nora Berend, 153-171. Aldershot: Ashgate, 2002.
Mažeika, Rasa. “Pagans, Saints, and War Criminals: Direct Speech as a Sign of Liminal Interchanges in Latin Chronicles of the Baltic Crusades.” Viator 45 (2014), 2: 271-288.
Meuvret, Jean. Histoire des pays baltiques. Lituanie – Lettonie – Estonie – Finlande. Paris: A. Colin, 1934.
Murray, Alan V. “Saracens of the Baltic: Pagan and Christian Lithuanians in the Perception of English and French Crusaders to Late Medieval Prussia.” Journal of Baltic Studies 41 (2010), 4: 413-429.
Ożóg, Krzysztof. Uczeni w monarchii Jadwigi Andegaweńskiej i Władysława Jagiełły (1384-1434). Kraków: PAU, 2004.
Ożóg, Krzysztof. The Role of Poland in the Intellectual Development of Europe in the Middle Ages. Kraków: Societas Vistulana, 2009.
Paravicini, Werner. “Hennuyers sur les chemins du monde: Jean de Werchin et ses amis autour de 1400.” In Noblesse. Studien zum adeligen Leben im spätmittelalterlichen Europa. Gesammelte Aufsätze, edited by Ulf Christian Ewert, Andreas Ranft, Stephan Selzer, 273-320. Ostfildern: J. Thorbecke, 2012.
Paravicini, Werner. “Jean de Werchin, sénéchal de Hainaut, chevalier errant.” In Noblesse. Studien zum adeligen Leben im spätmittelalterlichen Europa. Gesammelte Aufsätze, edited by Ulf Christian Ewert, Andreas Ranft, Stephan Selzer, 251-272. Ostfildern: J. Thorbecke, 2012.
Paravicini, Werner. “La Prusse et l’Europe occidentale.” Cahiers de recherches médiévales et humanistes 1 (1996): 176-191.
Paravicini, Werner. “Litauer: vom heidnischen Gegner zum adligen Standesgenossen.” In Tannenberg – Grunwald – Žalgiris 1410: Krieg und Frieden im späten Mittelalter, edited by Werner Paravicini, Rimwydas Petrauskas, Grischa Vercamer, 253-282. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz, 2012.
Paravicini, Werner. Die Preussenreisen des europäischen Adels. 2 vols. Sigmaringen: J. Thorbecke, 1989-1995.
Paravicini, Werner. “Vom Kreuzzug zum Soldzug. Die Schlacht bei Tannenberg und das Ende der Preussenfahrten des europäischen Adels.” In Conflictus Magnus apud Grunwald 1410. Między historią a tradycją, edited by Krzysztof Ożóg, Janusz Trupinda, 119-126. Malbork: Muzeum Zamkowe, 2013.
Paviot, Jacques. “Boucicaut et la croisade.” In La noblesse et la croisade à la fin du Moyen-Âge (France, Bourgogne, Bohême), edited by Martin Nejedlý, Jaroslav Svátek, 69-83. Toulouse: Presses universitaires du Midi, 2009.
Paviot, Jacques. “Noblesse et croisade à la fin du Moyen Âge.” Cahiers de recherches médiévales et humanistiques 13 (2006): 69-84.
Petrauskas, Rimvydas. “Litauen und der Deutsche Orden: Vom Feind zum Verbündeten.” In Tannenberg – Grunwald – Žalgiris 1410: Krieg und Frieden im späten Mittelalter, edited by Werner Paravicini, Rimvydas Petrauskas, Grischa Vercamer, 237-252. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz, 2012.
Prioult, Albert. “Un poète voyageur: Guillaume de Machaut et la “Reise” de Jean l’Aveugle, roi de Bohême en 1328-1329.” Les Lettres Romanes 4 (1950), 1: 3-29.
Rabikauskas Paulius. “La Cristianizzazione della Samogizia.” In La cristianizzazione della Lituania. Atti del Colloquio internazionale di storia ecclesiastica in occasione del 6 centenario della Lituania cristiana (1387-1987). Roma, 24–26 giugno 1987, editd by Paulius Rabikauskas, 219-233. Città del Vaticano: Libreria editrice vaticana, 1989
Rowell, Stephen C. Lithuania Ascending: A Pagan Empire within East-Central Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994.
Rowell, Stephen C. “Of Men and Monsters: Sources for the History of Lithuania in the Time of Gediminas.” Journal of Baltic Studies 24 (1993): 73-112.
Russell, Frederick H. “Paulus Vladimiri’s attack on the Just War: A Case Study in Legal Polemics.” In Authority and Power. Studies on Medieval Law and Government presented to Walter Ullmann on his Seventieth Birthday, edited by Brian Tierney, Peter Linehan, 237-254. Cambridge, New York: Cambridge University Press, 1980.
Sikorski, Dariusz. Przywilej kruszwicki. Studium z wczesnych dziejów zakonu niemieckiego w Prusach. Warszawa: TRIO, 2001.
Svátek, Jaroslav. Discours et récit de noble voyageur à la fin du Moyen Âge (Ogier d’Anglure, Nompar de Caumont, Guillebert de Lannoy, Bertrandon de la Broquière), thèse non publiée, Lille, Prague, 2012.
Szweda, Adam. “Polish and Teutonic diplomatic activity in Europe during the conflict of 1409–1411.” History.pth.net.pl 1 (2011) (Lien internet: http://www.history.pth.net.pl/article,1)
Tamm, Marek. “How to justify a crusade? The conquest of Livonia and new crusade rhetoric in the early thirteenth century.” Journal of Medieval History 39 (2013), 4: 431-455.
Tamm, Marek. “A New World into Old Words: The Eastern Baltic Region and the Cultural Geography of Medieval Europe.” In The Clash of Culture on the Baltic Frontier, edited by Alan V. Murray, 11-35. Farnham, Burlington: Ashgate, 2009.
Tolan, John V. Les Sarrasins: l’islam dans l’imagination européenne au Moyen Âge, trans. by Pierre-Emmanuel Dauzat, Paris: Aubier, 2003.
Urban, William. “Roger Bacon and the Teutonic Knights.” Journal of Baltic Studies 19 (1988), 4: 363-370.
Urban, William. The Samogitian Crusade. Chicago: Lithuanian Research and Studies Center, 1989.
Urban, William. “The Teutonic Knights at the Council of Constance.” In Estudios de Historia de la Iglesia y de las instituciones ecclesiasticas en Europa: Trabajos en homenaje a Ferran Valls i Taberner, edited by Manuel Pelaez, 4043-4063. Barcelona, 1990.
Williams, Robert A. The American Indian in Western Legal Thought. The Discourses of Conquest. New York, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1990 (reprint: 2005).
Wróbel, Dariusz. “The Ideological Foundations of the Polish Repossession Programme towards the State of the Teutonic Order in Prussia in the First Half of the 15th Century (1412-1422).” In Arguments and Counter-Arguments. The Political Thought of the 14th-and 15th Centuries during the Polish-Teutonic Order Trials and Disputes, edited by Wiesław Sieradzan, 169-200. Toruń: Wydawnictwo Naukowe UMK, 2012.
Wünsch, Thomas. “Paulus Wladimiri und die Genese des „realistischen Denkens“ in der Lehre von den internationalen Beziehungen: Der Krieg zwischen Polen und dem Deutschen Orden als Stimulus für ein neues politiktheoretisches Paradigma.” In Tannenberg – Grunwald – Žalgiris 1410. Krieg und Frieden im späten Mittelalter, edited by Werner Paravicini, Rimwydas Petrauskas, Grischa Vercamer, 27-42. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz, 2012.
Zdrenka, Joachim. Polityka zagraniczna książąt szczecińskich w latach 1295-1411. Słupsk: PTH – Oddział w Słupsku, 1985.
Žůrek, Václav. “Sur les traces des grands croisés. Le goût pour la croisade de Jean et Charles de Luxembourg et l’inspiration française.” In Histoires et mémoires des croisades à la fin du Moyen Âge, edited by Martin Nejedlý, Jaroslav Svátek, 273-291. Toulouse: Presses Universitaires du Mirail, 2012.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
CC BY ND 4.0. The Creator/Contributor is the Licensor, who grants the Licensee a non-exclusive license to use the Work on the fields indicated in the License Agreement.
Stats
Number of views and downloads: 903
Number of citations: 0
