Unfair contract terms legislation as a tool for striking out excessive price clauses? Practice of the Court of Justice of the European Union and Polish courts
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12775/SIT.2019.012Keywords
prices of services and goods, unfair clauses, consumer contracts, Council Directive 93/13/EEC of 5 April 1993 on unfair terms in consumer contractsAbstract
Under Article 4(2) of Council Directive 93/13/EEC of 5 April 1993 on unfair terms in consumer contracts assessment of the unfair nature of the terms shall relate neither to the definition of the main subject matter of the contract nor to the adequacy of the price and remuneration, on the one hand, as against the services or goods supplies in exchange, on the other, in so far as these terms are in plain intelligible language. This paper aims at offering an insight into the judicial approach of the Court of Justice of the European Union towards the price term exemption, preceded by a topical summary of the axiological underpinnings of the unfair terms legislation. This is then followed by an analysis of the Polish judicial approach as an example of a practical transposition into an EU national legal system of the price term exemption. Crucially, it appears that scrutiny is centred around the ways in which a price may be altered and consumer economic interests are protected under the guise of purely legal and not equitable (economic) mechanisms.
References
Atiyah P.S., Contract and Fair Exchange, “University of Toronto Law Journal” 1985, vol. 35, issue 1.
Alvarez Lata N., The Impact of the Terminology of the European Directives on Consumer Rights on the Spanish Law: The Construction of a New Legal Language, “European Review of Private Law” 2012, vol. 20, issues 5–6.
Becher S.I., Asymmetric Information in Consumer Contracts: The Challenge That Is Yet to Be Met, “American Business Law Journal” 2008, vol. 45, issue 4.
Council of Bars and Societies of Europe, CCBE Proposal for a Revision of Directive 93/13/EC on Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts, 16 September 2016.
Chen-Wishart M., Transparency and fairness in bank charges, “Law Quarterly Review” 2010, issue 126.
Dharmananda K., Firios L., Penalties arising without breach: the Australian apogee of orthodoxy, “Lloyd’s Maritime and Commercial Law Quarterly” 2013, issue 2.
Ejmont A., Analiza orzecznictwa Sądu Okręgowego – Sądu Ochrony Konkurencji i Konsumentów w zakresie klauzul dopuszczających zmianę ceny, „Transformacje Prawa Prywatnego” 2008, issue 3–4.
Howells G.G., The European Union’s Influence on English Consumer Contract Law, “George Washington Law Review” 2017, issue 85.
Macdonald E., Bank Charges and the Core Exemption: Office of Fair Trading v Abbey National Plc, “Modern Law Review” 2008, vol. 71, issue 6.
Macdonald E., Inequality of Bargaining Power and “Cure” by Information Requirement, in: Comparative Contract Law: British and American Perspectives, ed. by L. DiMatteo, M. Hogg, Oxford 2015.
McKendrick E., Contract Law, Basingstoke 2015.
Micklitz H.-W., The Proposal on Consumer Rights and the Opportunity for a Reform of European Unfair Terms Legislation in Consumer Contracts, “EUI LAW Working Paper” No. 2010/12.
Micklitz H.-W., Reisch L.A., Hagen K., An Introduction to the Special Issue on “Behavioural Economics, Consumer Policy, and Consumer Law”, “Journal of Consumer Policy” 2011, vol. 34, issue 3.
Mikłaszewicz P., Art. 3851, in: Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz. Zobowiązania. Część ogólna, ed. by K. Osajda, Legalis.
Morgan P., Bank charges and the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations 1999: the end of the road for consumers?, “Lloyd’s Maritime and Commercial Law Quarterly” 2010, issue 2.
Naude T., The Use of Black and Grey Lists in Unfair Contract Terms Legislation in Comparative Perspective, “South African Law Journal” 2007, issue 124.
Oyer D.J., Cost-Based Pricing: A Guide for Government Contractors, Oakland, California 2012.
Peel E., The rule against penalties, “Law Quarterly Review” 2013, issue 129.
Riesenhuber K., Privatrechtsgesellschaft: Entwicklung, Stand und Verfassung des Privatrechts, Tubingen 2007.
Rott P., The Adjustment of Long-Term Supply Contracts: Experience from German Gas Price Case Law, “European Review of Private Law” 2013, vol. 21, issue 3.
Schillig M., Inequality of Bargaining Power Versus Market for Lemons: Legal Paradigm Change and the Court of Justice’s Jurisprudence on Directive 93/13 on Unfair Contract Terms, “European Law Review” 2008, vol. 33.
Story W.W., A Treatise on the Law of Contracts, Clark, New Jersey 2006.
Straetmans G., Misleading Practices, the Consumer Information Model and Consumer Protection, “Journal of European Consumer and Market Law” 2016, issue 5.
Stuyck J., Unfair terms, in: Modernising and Harmonising Consumer Contract Law, ed. G.G. Howells, R. Schulze, Munich 2009.
Šmejkal V., Competition law and the social market economy goal of the EU, “International Comparative Jurisprudence” 2015, vol. 1, issue 1.
Taylor D., Taylor R., Contract Law Directions, Oxford 2017.
Tenreiro M., Community Directive on Unfair Terms and National Legal Systems, “European Review of Private Law” 1995, vol. 3, issue 2.
Whittaker S., Unfair Contract Terms, Unfair Prices and Bank Charges, “Modern Law Review” 2011, vol. 74, issue 1.
Willett C., Transparency and Fairness in Australian and UK Regulation of Standard Terms, “University of Western Australia Law Review” 2013, vol. 37, issue 1.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
Stats
Number of views and downloads: 1875
Number of citations: 0
