Playing at history
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12775/KlioPL.2016.09Keywords
history, culture, play, scientific ideal, democratization of history, the past as seen through the prism of mass mediaAbstract
The phenomenon of a democratization of history lies not so much in the equal status of different narratives about the past as in the society’s willingness to regard them as equally acceptable. In this sense academic historiography is not the only source of the cultural visions of the past. Movies, games, the Internet and other digital media all serve as a platform for creating these visions which, being usually the work of history-loving amateurs rather than professional historians, emerge within the framework of the so called non-conventional history (representations of the past found in movies or literature) or the alternative history (representations of the past found in computer games, historical portals or produced by reconstruction groups). The pluralism of the visions of the past and of ways of representing it turns out to be as much the result of the process of the democratization of history as it does the consequence of the technological possibilities that have emerged in modern culture, the essence of which seems to lie in its audio-visual character. In order to make it possible for history to carry out its cognitive functions, it is necessary not only to reformulate research programmes, which after all is being done, but also to devise new ways of representing the past. This is dictated not only by some key aspects of research practice, which is informed by the post-modernist critique of the traditional forms of practising history, but also by the new cultural context the historiography of today is set in. It is within this context that we may observe both verbal and visual articulations of the view of the past that is alternative to the representations of it in academic historiography. These articulations can be found in a variety of history games. It should also be kept in mind that the benefits of ‘playing at history’ are usually thought of as lying in the realm of education and of the commercialization of history. However, its cognitive potential is usually neglected.
References
A.M.S. Barry, Visual Intelligence. Perception, Image, and Manipulation in Visual Communication, Albany 1997
R. Bomba, Historia w grach komputerowych, „Historyka” 37–38, 2007–2008, s. 129–138
A. Erjavec, Przygody oka, w: Intermedialność w kulturze końca XX wieku, red. A. Gwóźdź, S. Krzemień-Ojak, Białystok 1998, s. 9–22
E.H. Gombrich, Obraz wizualny, w: Symbole i symbolika, wybór i wstęp M. Głowiński, tłum.
G. Borkowska i in., Warszawa 1990, s. 312–338
E.H. Gombrich, The Visual Image. Its Place in Communication, w: The Essential Gombrich. Selected Writings on Art and Culture, red. R. Woodfield, London 1996, s. 41–64
A. Hoskins, New Memory. Mediating History, „Historical Journal of Film, Radio and Television” 21, 2001, nr 4, s. 333–346
J. Huizinga, Homo ludens. Zabawa jako źródło kultury, tłum. M. Kurecka, W. Wirpsza, Warszawa 1998
D. Hyerle, Visual Tools for Constructing Knowledge, Alexandria (VA) 1997
P. Kawecki, Zagadnienie statusu dzieła literackiego we współczesnym otoczeniu ikonicznym, w: Intermedialność w kulturze końca XX wieku, red. A. Gwóźdź, S. Krzemień-Ojak, Białystok 1998, s. 257–266
J. Pomorski, Punkt widzenia we współczesnej historiografii, w: Punkt widzenia w języku i kulturze, red. J. Bartmiński, S. Niebrzegowska-Bartmińska, R. Nycz, Lublin 2004, s. 11–23
J. Pomorski, Spór o ideał badania historycznego w metodologii historii, w: tenże, Historyk i metodologia, Lublin 1991, s. 53–77
P. Sabin, Simulating War. Studying Conflict through Simulation Games, London–New York 2012
Społeczna funkcja historii a współczesność, red. Z. Mańkowski, J. Pomorski, Lublin 1985
M. Stachura, Możliwe narzędzie badania możliwości. O rozrywkowych „grach wojennych” i pożytku, jaki mogą przynieść rozwojowi nauk historycznych, „Historyka” 43, 2013, s. 127–145
A. Suchoński, Wdrażanie uczniów do umiejętności analizy obrazu dynamicznego, w: Multimedia w edukacji historycznej i społecznej, red. J. Rulka, B. Tarnowska, Bydgoszcz 2002
Visual Culture, red. C. Jenks, London 1995
M. Woźniak, Przeszłość jako przedmiot konstrukcji. O roli wyobraźni w badaniach historycznych, Lublin 2010
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
Stats
Number of views and downloads: 375
Number of citations: 0