Mixing Labor, Taking Possession, and Libertarianism: Response to Walter Block
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12775/szhf.2023.026Keywords
libertarianism,, homesteading,, original appropriation, labor-mixing, first possessionAbstract
In his recent rejoinder to my paper Walter Block argues that only the Lockean labor-mixing theory of first acquisition is compatible with libertarianism. Block’s claim is in turn directed against a position held by me in the said paper that it is the first possession theory of original appropriation that is a better fit for libertarianism. Upon reading Block’s rejoinder and thinking intensely about this issue, in the present paper I agree with Block and disagree with my former self, accepting the view that it is
indeed the Lockean labor-mixing theory that should be embraced by libertarians. This verdict is mainly motivated by the following arguments that I develop in detail in the paper: (1) no libertarian arguments against the labor-mixing theory seem to work, (2) the first possession theory is unable (contrary to the labor-mixing theory) to accommodate the idea of original appropriation tracking objective links between actors andthings; (3) the labor-mixing theory better fits our intuitions about justice in property acquisition. However, in order not to make things too easy for Block, I also argue that there are some surprising and problematic consequences of adopting the labor-mixing account. I am fully prepared to accept them. The question is whether so is Block.
References
Block Walter. 2008. “Homesteading, Ad Coelum, Owning Views and Forestalling”. The Social Sciences 3: 96‒103.
Block Walter. 2012. “Popsicle Sticks and Homesteading Land for Nature Preserves”. Romanian Economic and Business Review 7: 7‒13.
Block Walter. 2019. “Libertarian Punishment Theory and Unjust Enrichment”, Journal of Business Ethics 154: 103‒108.
Block Walter. 2023. “Libertarianism and Original Appropriation Homesteading: Response to Dominiak”. Studia z Historii Filozofii 14: 121‒142.
The Digest of Justinian. 1985. transl. edited by Alan Watson. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Dominiak Łukasz. 2017. “Libertarianism and Original Appropriation”. Historia i Polityka 22: 43‒56.
Dominiak Łukasz. 2017. “The Blockian Proviso and the Rationality of Property Rights”, Libertarian Papers 9: 114‒128.
Dominiak Łukasz. 2018. “Libertarianizm i teoria praw podmiotowych”. Athenaeum: Polish Political Science Studies 59: 7‒17.
Dominiak Łukasz. 2019. “Must Right-Libertarians Embrace Easements by Necessity?”. Diametros: An Online Journal of Philosophy 60: 34‒51.
Dominiak Łukasz. 2021. “Libertarian Easements Revisited”. Ekonomia – Wroclaw Economic Review 27: 27‒35.
Dominiak Łukasz, Tate Fegley. 2022. “Contract Theory, Title Transfer, and Libertarianism”. Diametros: A Journal of Philosophy 19: 1‒25.
Dominiak Łukasz. 2022. “Unjust Enrichment and Libertarianism”. Polish Political Science Review 10: 1‒13.
Dominiak Łukasz. 2023. “Proceeds of Crime, Punishment, and Libertarianism”. Archiwum Filozofii Prawa i Filozofii Społecznej 35: 20‒33.
Dominiak Łukasz. 2024. “Accession, Property Acquisition, and Libertarianism”. Diametros: A Journal of Philosophy, forthcoming, 2024.
Dominiak Łukasz. “Free Market, Blackmail, and Austro-Libertarianism”. Philosophical Problems in Science, forthcoming, 2024.
Dominiak Łukasz, Igor Wysocki. 2023. “Evictionism, Libertarianism, and Duties of the Fetus”. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 2023: 1‒14.
Epstein Richard. 1979. “Possession as the Root of Title”, Georgia Law Review 13: 1221-1243.
Fegley Tate, Łukasz Dominiak. 2021. “Property Rights and Gun Control: A Reply to Block and Block”. Journal of Libertarian Studies 25: 272‒280.
Filmer Robert. 1949. Patriarcha and Other Political Works, edited by Peter Laslett. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Hart Herbert L. A. 1955. “Are There Any Natural Rights?”. Philosophical Review 64: 175‒191.
Hart Herbert L. A. 1982. Essays on Bentham. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hoppe Hans-Hermann. 2001. Democracy – The God that Failed. New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers.
Hoppe Hans-Hermann. 2009. A Theory of Socialism and Capitalism. Auburn: Mises Institute.
Hoppe Hans-Hermann. 2014. From Aristocracy to Monarchy to Democracy: A Tale of Moral and Economic Folly and Decay. Auburn: Mises Institute.
Kinsella Stephan. 2008. Against Intellectual Property. Auburn: Mises Institute.
Kinsella Stephan. “How We Come to Own Ourselves”. Mises Daily. Access 07.06.2023. https://mises.org/library/how-we-come-own-ourselves
Kinsella Stephan. “The Essence of Libertarianism? ‘Finders Keepers,’ ‘Better Title,’ and Other Possibilities”. StephanKinsella.com. Access 07.06.2023. https://www.stephankinsella.com/2005/08/the-essence-of-libertarianism/
Kinsella Stephan. “Thoughts on Intellectual Property, Scarcity, Labor-ownership, Metaphors, and Lockean Homesteading”. Mises Wire. Access 07.06.2023. https://mises.org/wire/thoughts-intellectual-property-scarcity-labor-ownership-metaphors-and-lockean-homesteading
Kramer Matthew H. 2005. “Moral Rights and the Limits of the Ought-Implies-Can Principle: Why Impeccable Precautions are No Excuse”. Inquiry: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Philosophy 48: 307‒-355.
Locke John. 2003. Two Treatises of Government, ed. Peter Laslett. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Mack Eric. 2009. John Locke. New York: Continuum.
Moore Michael S. 2009. Causation and Responsibility: An Essay in Law, Morals, and Metaphysics. New York: Oxford University Press.
Nozick Robert. 1974. Anarchy, State, and Utopia. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.
Pierson v. Post. 1805. N.Y. 3 Caines R. 175, 2 Am. Dec 264.
Rothbard Murray. 1998. The Ethics of Liberty. New York: New York University Press.
Rothbard Murray. 2011. “Justice and Property Rights”. In: Murray Rothbard, Economic Controversies, 347‒366. Auburn: Mises Institute.
Rothbard Murray. 2011. “Law, Property Rights, and Air Pollution”. In: Murray Rothbard, Economic Controversies, 367‒418. Auburn: Mises Institute.
Slenzok Norbert. 2020. A priori wolności, a priori porządku. Filozofia społeczno-polityczna Hansa-Hermanna Hoppego a spory o podstawy libertarianizmu, PhD diss. Katowice.
Steiner Hillel. 1994. An Essay on Rights. Oxford: Blackwell Publishers.
Steiner Hillel. 1998. “Working Rights”, in: Matthew H. Kramer, Nigel E. Simmonds,
Hillel Steiner, A Debate over Rights. New York: Oxford University Press.
Steiner Hillel. 2009. “Asymmetric Information, Libertarianism, and Fraud”, Review of Social Economy 77: 94‒107.
Tuck Richard. 1979. Natural Rights Theories: Their Origin and Development. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Von Savigny Friedrich Carl. 1979. Treatise on Possession; Or the Jus Possessionis of the Civil Law, transl. Erskine Perry. Westport: Hyperion Press.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
![Creative Commons License](http://i.creativecommons.org/l/by-nd/4.0/88x31.png)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Stats
Number of views and downloads: 229
Number of citations: 0