Catholicism and Evolution: Polygenism and Original Sin Part II

James R. Hofmann

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.12775/SetF.2021.003

Abstract


As documented in Part I, monogenism, the descent of all human beings from Adam and Eve, was closely linked to the Catholic doctrine of original sin throughout the first half of the twentieth century. Theological reservations about polygenism, the more scientifically supported account of human origins through a transitional population, was brought to a head by Pius XII’s 1950 encyclical Humani generis. Although the encyclical allowed discussion of human evolution, polygenism was prohibited because “It does not appear how such a view can be reconciled with the doctrine of original sin.” Nevertheless, during and after Vatican II de facto theological acceptance of polygenism became commonplace even though the prohibition was not withdrawn. While some modern conceptions of original sin make a reliance upon monogenism unnecessary, another school of thought emphasizes a spiritual rather than a biological understanding of the concept. It remains to be seen whether polygenism can be unanimously accepted as a scientific phenomenon that is not theologically threatening. Reflection on the Vatican’s long period of ambivalence about the motion of the earth suggests that a similar prospect can be foreseen for polygenism even though it is subject to development in a manner that geostasis was not.


Keywords


anthropogenesis; Humani generis; monogenism

Full Text:

PDF

References


A New Catechism. Catholic Faith for Adults. 1967. Hoger Katechetisch Instituut. Translated by Kevin Smyth. New York: Herder and Herder.

Alexander, Andrew. 1964. “Human Origins and Genetics.” The Clergy Review 49: 344–353.

Alszeghy, Zoltán, and Maurice Flick. 1965. “Il peccato originale in prospettiva personalistica.” Gregorianum 46: 705–732.

Alszeghy, Zoltán, and Maurice Flick. 1966. “Il peccato originale in prospettiva evoluzionistica.” Gregorianum 47: 201–225.

Amann, Émile. 1935. “Préadamites.” Dictionnaire de théologie catholique 12(2): col. 2793–2800.

Ayala, Francisco. 1967. “Man in Evolution: A Scientific Statement and Some Theological and Ethical Implications.” The Thomist 31(1): 1–20.

Ayala, Francisco et al. 1994. “Molecular genetics of speciation and human origins.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 91: 6787–6794.

Baum, Gregory. 1967. “Vatican II's constitution on revelation: history and interpretation.” Theological Studies 28(1): 51–75.

Baumgartner, Charles. 1969. Le Péché Originel. Paris: Desclée & Cie.

Bea, Augustin. 1951. “Die Enzyklika ‘Humani generis’ Ihre Grundgedanken und ihre Bedeutung.” Scholastik 26: 36–56.

Blandino, Giovanni. 1962. Deux hypotheses sur l’origine de l’homme, Observations theologiquese et scientifiques. Bologna: Assoguidi.

Blandino, Giovanni. 1967. Peccato originale e poligenismo: le recenti ipotesi teologiche e un nuovo tentativo di soluzione. Ethica: Forlì.

Blandino, Giovanni. 1968. “Tre recenti ipotesi sul peccato originale.” Rassegna di Teologia 2: 81–95.

Blandino, Giovanni. 1977a. Questioni dibattute di teologia vol. 1. Rome: Pontificia Università Lateranense, Città Nuova Editrice.

Blandino, Giovanni. 1977b. “Peccato originale e poligenismo: le recenti ipotesi teologiche.” In Questioni dibattute di teologia, vol 1, 45–77.

Blandino, Giovanni. 1977c. “Discussioni sul peccato originale.” In Questioni dibattute di teologia, vol 1, 87–105.

Blandino, Giovanni. 1989. “The Problem of Suffering. The Original Sin.” Teresianum 40: 149–173.

Boné, Edouard 1955. “La solution de l’énigme de Piltdown.” Nouvelle Revue Théologique 77 (2): 163–183.

Boné, Edouard. 1956. “Pierre Teilhard de Chardin.” Revue des questions scientifiques 127(1): 90–104.

Boné, Edouard. 1960.“Polygénisme et polyphylétisme, orientation présente de la pensée scientifique en matière de l'apparition de l'homme.” Archives de philosophie 23(1): 99–141.

Boné, Edouard. 1962. “Un siècle d'Anthropologie préhistorique. Compatibilité ou incompatibilité scientifique du Monogénisme?” Nouvelle Revue Théologique 84(7): 709–734.

Boyer, Charles. 1950. “Les leçons de l'Encyclique ‘Humani Generis’.” Gregorianum 31(4): 526–539.

Cagin, Michel. 2009. “Le Credo du people de Dieu.” Nova & Vetera Revue Trimestrielle 84(1): 7–43.

Catechism of the Catholic Church. 1993. https://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/_INDEX.HTM

Congregation of the Holy Office. 1962. “Monitum.” Acta Apostolicae Sedis 54: 526. https://www.catholicculture.org/culture/library/view.cfm?recnum=3160

Conner, James. 1968. “Original Sin: Contemporary Approaches.” Theological Studies 29(2): 215–240.

Coogan, Robert. 1986. “The Pharisee Against the Hellenist: Edward Lee Versus Erasmus.” Renaissance Quarterly 39(3): 476–506.

Cotter, Anthony. 1951. The Encyclical “Humani Generis” with a Commentary. Weston: Weston College Press.

De Fraine, Jean. 1962. The Bible and the Origin of Man. New York: Desclee Company.

De Nieuwe Katechismus: Geloofsverkondigning Voor Volwassenen. 1966. Hoger Katechetisch Instituut. Hilversum: Paul Brand.

De Sinéty, Robert. 1906. “L’Haeckélianisme et les idées du P. Wasmann sur l’évolution.” Revue des Questions Scientifiques 9: 226–242.

De Sinéty, Robert. 1928. “Transformisme.” Dictionnaire Apologétique de la Foi Catholique. 4: col. 1793–1848.

Dhanis, Edouard, and Jan Visser. 1969. The Supplement to A New Catechism. Translated by Kevin Smyth. London: Burns & Oates.

Dobzhansky, Theodosius. 1937. Genetics and the Origin of Species. New York: Columbia University Press.

Dubarle, André-Marie. 1964. The Biblical Doctrine of Original Sin. Translated by E. M. Stewart. New York: Herder and Herder.

Dubarle, André-Marie. 1966. “Évolution et Péché Originel.” Le Monde: August 6.

Dubarle, André-Marie. 1969. “Bulletin de Théologie. Le Péché Originel: Recherches Récentes et Orientations Nouvelles.” Revue des Sciences philosophiques et théologiques 53(1): 81–113.

Dubarle, Dominique. 1957. “Évolution et Évolutionnisme.” Lumière et Vie 34: 75–90.

Duffy, Stephen. 1988. “Our Hearts of Darkness: Original Sin Revisited.” Theological Studies 49: 597–622.

Feiner, Johannes. 1965. “Man’s Origin and Contemporary Anthropology.” In Theology Today (vol. 1): Renewal in Dogma, edited by Johannes Feiner, Josef Trütsch and Franz Böckle, translated by Peter White and Raymond Kelly, 27–65. Milwaukee: Bruce Publishing Company.

Finocchiaro, Maurice. 2005. Retrying Galileo: 1633–1992. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Flick, Maurice. 1947. “Il poligenismo e il dogma del peccato originale.” Gregorianum 28(4): 555–563.

Frings, Joseph, Joseph Lefebvre, Lorenz Jaeger, Ermenegildo Florit, Michael Browne, Charles Journet. 1968. “Declaration of the Commission of Cardinals on the ‘New Catechism’."

https://www.ewtn.com/catholicism/library/declaration-of-the-commission-of-cardinals-on-the-new-catechism-2060

Garrigou-Lagrange, Réginald. 1948. “Le Monogénisme n’est-il nullement révélé, pas même implicitement?” Doctor Communis 2: 191–202.

Geiselmann, Josef. 1958. “Scripture and Tradition in Catholic Theology.” Theology Digest 6:73–78.

Greenstock, David. 1950. “Thomism and the New Theology.” The Thomist 13(4): 567–596.

Grelot, Pierre. 1968. Réflexions sur le Problème du Péché Originel. Tournai: Casterman.

Guindon, Henri-Marie. 1979. “Review of Blandino, Giovanni, Questioni dibattute.” Laval théologique et philosophique 35(1): 107.

Gutwender, Engelbert. 1967. “Die Erbsünde und Das Konzil von Trient.” Zeitschrift für katholische Theologie 89(4): 433–446.

Haag, Herbert. 1966. Biblische Schöpfungslehre und kirchliche Erbsündenlehre. Stuttgart: Katholisches Bibelwerk.

Haag, Herbert. 1969. Is Original Sin in Scripture? Translated by Dorothy Thompson. New York: Sheed and Ward.

Haag, Herbert. 1970. “Die hartnäckige Erbsünde: Überlegungen zu einigen Neuerscheinungen II.” Theologische Quartalschrift 150(3): 436–456.

Haag, Herbert. 1973a. “The Original Sin Discussion 1966–1971.” Journal of Ecumenical Studies 10: 259–289.

Haag, Herbert. 1973b. “Ein Verfahren der Glaubenskongregation.” Theologische Quartalschrift 153(2): 184–192.

Haag, Herbert. 1991. Mein Weg mit der Kirche. Zurich: Benziger.

Harrison, Brian. 2012. “Paul VI’s Ambivalence Toward Critical Biblical Scholarship. B. Indications of Approval: Administrative Decisions.” Living Tradition 157: 1–10. http://www.rtforum.org/lt/lt157.pdf

Hofmann, James. 2020a. “Erich Wasmann, S.J.: Natural Species and Catholic Polyphyletic Evolution during the Modernist Crisis.” Journal of Jesuit Studies 7(2): 244–262.

Hofmann, James. 2020b. “Catholicism and Evolution: Polygenism and Original Sin.” Scientia et Fides 8(2): 95–138.

International Theological Commission. 2004. “Communion and Stewardship: Human Persons Created in the Image of God.”

http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/cti_documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20040723_communion-stewardship_en.html

Jackson, John, and David Depew. 2017. Darwinism, Democracy, and Race. American Anthropology and Evolutionary Biology in the Twentieth Century. London and New York: Routledge.

John Paul II. 1996. “Truth Cannot Contradict Truth: Address of Pope John Paul II to the Pontifical Academy of Sciences.” https://www.vofoundation.org/faith-and-science/truth-cannot-contradict-truth-1996/

Journet, Charles. 1951. Petit Catéchisme sur les Origines du Monde. Saint-Maurice: Éditions de L'œuvre St-Augustin.

Kapusta, Pawel. 2009. “Darwinism from Humani Generis to the Present.” In Darwinism and Catholicism: The Past and Present Dynamics of a Cultural Encounter, edited by Louis Caruana, 27–42. London: T&T Clark.

Kemp, Kenneth. 2011. “Science, Theology, and Monogenesis.” American Catholic Philosophical Quarterly 85(2): 217–236.

Knox, Ronald. 1950. “The Encyclical ‘Humani Generis’ Specially Translated for the Tablet by Monsignor R. A. Knox.” The Tablet (Sept. 2) 196: 187–190.

Küng, Hans. 2008. Disputed Truth. Translated by John Bowden. New York: Continuum.

Labourdette, Marie-Michel. 1953. Le Péché Originel et les Origines de l’homme. Paris: Alsatia.

Lavocat, René. 1967a. “Réflexions d'un paléontologiste sur l'état originel de l'humanité et le péché original.” Nouvelle revue théologique 89: 582–600.

Lavocat, René. 1967b. “Polygénisme. Le point de vue scientifique.” Supplément au Dictionnaire de la Bible 8: col. 92–102.

Levie, Jean. 1950. “L'Encyclique ‘Humani Generis’.” Nouvelle Revue Théologique 72(8): 785–793.

Lyonnet, Stanislaus. 1955. “Le Sens de ἐφ’ ᾧ en Rom 5:12 et l'Exégèse des Pères Grecs.” Biblica 36(4): 436–456.

Lyonnet, Stanislaus. 1956. “Le péché originel et l’exégèse de Rom., 5, 12.” Recherches de Science Religieuse 44: 63–84.

Maas, Anthony. 1911. “Preadamites.” The Catholic Encyclopedia 12. New York: Robert Appleton Company. http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12370a.htm

Mackey, James. 1967. “Original Sin and Polygenism: The State of the Question.” Irish Theological Quarterly 34(2): 99–114.

McDermott, Brian. 1977. “The Theology of Original Sin: Recent Developments.” Theological Studies 38(3): 478–512.

McMahon, Kevin. 2002a. “Karl Rahner and the Theology of Human Origins.” The Thomist 66: 499–517.

McMahon, Kevin. 2002b. “The Christological Turn in Recent Literature on Original Sin.” The Thomist 66: 201–229.

Messenger, Ernst. 1951. Theology and Evolution. London: Sands & Co.

Messenger, Ernst. 1953. “The Origin of Man in the Book of Genesis.” In God, Man and the Universe, edited by Jacques de Bivort de La Saudée, 147–167. London: P. J. Kenedy and Sons.

Michel, Albert. 1941. “Surnaturel.” Dictionnaire de théologie catholique 14(2): col. 2849–2859.

Muller, Camille. 1951a. “L'Encyclique ‘Humani Generis’.” Synthèses; Revue mensuelle international 5(57): 296–312.

Muller, Camille. 1951b. L'encyclique "humani generis" et les problèmes scientifiques. Louvain: Editions Nauwelaerts.

Muller, Camille. 1962. Science and Faith: Co-existence or Synthesis? Louvain: Editions Nauwelaerts.

North, Robert. 1963. “Teilhard and the Many Adams.” Continuum 1(3): 329–342.

North, Robert. 1967. Teilhard and the Creation of the Soul. Milwaukee: Bruce Publishing Company.

O'Rourke, John. 1965. “Some Considerations About Polygenism.” Theological Studies 26: 407–417.

Padovano, Anthony. 1967. “Original Sin and Christian Anthropology.” Proceedings of the Catholic Theological Society of America 22: 93–132.

Paul VI. 1964. Lumen Gentium: “Dogmatic Constitution on the Church Solemnly Promulgated by HisHolinessPope Paul VI on November 21, 1964.”

http://www.vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/documents/vat-ii_const_19641121_lumen-gentium_en.html

Paul VI. 1965. Dei Verbum: “Dogmatic Constitution on Divine Revelation Solemnly Promulgated by Pope Paul VI, November 18, 1965.”

https://www.vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/documents/vat-ii_const_19651118_dei-verbum_en.html

Paul VI. 1966. “The Mystery of Original Sin: Address of Pope Paul VI to a special audience for theologians participating in a symposium on the Mystery of Original Sin July 11, 1966.” Translated in William G. Heidt, 1967, The Book of Genesis Chapters 1–11, 76–82. Collegeville: Liturgical Press. Original Italian:

http://www.vatican.va/content/paul-vi/it/speeches/1966/documents/hf_p-vi_spe_19660711_peccato-originale.html

Paul VI. 1968. “Solemni Hac Liturgia (Credo of the People of God) of the Supreme Pontiff Paul VI.” http://www.vatican.va/content/paul-vi/en/motu_proprio/documents/hf_p-vi_motu-proprio_19680630_credo.html

Picard, Guy. 1951. “La Science expérimentale est-elle favorable au polygénisme?” Sciences ecclésiastiques 4: 65–89.

Pius XII. 1950. Humani generis: “Encyclical of the Holy Father Pius XII to Our Venerable Brethren, Patriarchs, Primates, Archbishops, Bishops, and other Local Ordinaries Enjoying Peace and Communion with the Holy See Concerning Some False Opinions Threatening to Undermine the Foundations of Catholic Doctrine.”

http://www.vatican.va/content/pius-xii/la/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-xii_enc_12081950_humani-generis.html

http://www.vatican.va/content/pius-xii/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-xii_enc_12081950_humani-generis.html

Pius XII. 1953. “Discours du Pape Pie XII aux Participants au ‘Primum Symposium Internationale Geneticae Medicae’.” https://www.vatican.va/content/pius-xii/fr/speeches/1953/documents/hf_p-xii_spe_19530907_genetica.html

Rahner, Karl. 1954. “Theologisches zum Monogenismus.” Schriften zur Theologie 1: 253–322.

Rahner, Karl. 1961. “Theological Reflexions on Monogenism.” Theological Investigations 1: 229–296. London: Darton, Longman & Todd.

Rahner, Karl. 1962. “Monogenismus.” Lexicon für Theologie und Kirche, 2nd ed., 7: col. 561–562.

Rahner, Karl. 1965. Hominisation: The Evolutionary Origin of Man as a Theological Problem. Translated by W. T. O’Hara. New York: Herder and Herder.

Rahner, Karl. 1967a. “Introduction.” In Teilhard and the Creation of the Soul, by Robert North, ix–xii. Milwaukee: Bruce Publishing Company.

Rahner, Karl. 1967b. “Evolution and Original Sin.” Concilium 26: 61–73.

Rahner, Karl. 1969. “Monogenism.” Sacramentum Mundi. An Encyclopedia of Theology 4: 105–107.

Rahner, Karl. 1970. “Exkurs: Erbsünde und Monogenismus.” In Theologie der Erbsünde, edited by Karl-Heinz Weger, 176–223. Freiburg: Herder.

Rahner, Karl. 1974. “The Sin of Adam.” Theological Investigations 11: 247–262.

Rahner, Karl. 1988. “Natural Science and Reasonable Faith.” Theological investigations Vol. 21: Science and Christian Faith, edited by Hugh Riley, 16–55.

Ratzinger, Josef. 1971. “The Dutch Catechism: A Theological Appreciation.” The Furrow 22(12): 739–754.

Rogerson, John. 1970. “The Hebrew Conception of Corporate Personality: A Re-examination.” The Journal of Theological Studies 21(1): 1–16.

Rondet, Henri. 1967. Le Péché Originel dans la Tradition Patristique et Théologique. Paris: Libraire Fayard.

Rondet, Henri. 1972. Original Sin: The Patristic and Theological Background. Translated by Cajetan Finegan. New York: Alba House.

Rouquette, Robert. 1950. “L’Encyclique ‘Humani generis’.” Études 83(267): 108–116.

Roquette, Robert. 1966. “De Rome et de la chrétienté.” Études 325(10): 372–391.

Schelkens, Karim. 2010. Catholic Theology of Revelation on the Eve of Vatican II: A Redaction History of the Schema de Fontibus Revelationis (1960–1962). Boston: Brill.

Schoonenberg, Piet. 1962. “Erbsünde und ‘Sünde der Welt’.” Orientierung: Katholische Blätter für weltanschauliche Information 6: 65–69.

Schoonenberg, Piet. 1965. Man and Sin. A Theological View. Translated by Joseph Donceel. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.

Smulders, Piet. 1967. The Design of Teilhard de Chardin. Translated by Arthur Gibson. Westminster, Maryland: Newman Press.

Sullivan, Francis. 1996. “The Ordinary Universal Magisterium.” Jurist 56: 338–360.

Swamidass, Joshua. 2019. The Genealogical Adam & Eve: The Surprising Science of Universal Ancestry. Downers Grove: InterVarsity Press.

Teilhard de Chardin. 1971. “Monogenism and Monophyletism: an essential distinction.” In Christianity and Evolution, translated by René Hague, 209–211. New York: Harcourt.

Thiel, John. 2020. “Dei Verbum: Scripture, Tradition, and Historical Criticism.” Horizons 47(2): 207–231.

Vandebroek, Georges, and Léon Renwart. 1951. “L'encyclique ‘Humani Generis’ et les sciences naturelles.” Nouvelle Revue Théologique 73(4): 337–351.

Vandebroek, Georges. 1953. “The Origin of Man and the Recent Discoveries of the Natural Sciences.” In God, Man and the Universe, edited by Jacques de Bivort de La Saudée, 93–143. New York: P. J. Kenedy and Sons.

Vandervelde, George. 1981. Original Sin: Two Major Trends in Contemporary Roman Catholic Reinterpretation. Washington D.C: University Press of America.

Vanneste, Alfred. 1967. “Toward a Theology of Original Sin.” Theology Digest 15: 209–214.

Vanneste, Alfred. 1975. The Dogma of Original Sin. Translated by Edward Callens. Louvain: Vander.

Vollert, Cyril. 1959. “Evolution and the Bible.” In Symposium on Evolution, held at Duquesne University, April 4, 1959, in commemoration of the centenary of Charles Darwin’s The Origin of Species, edited by Bernard Boelen, 81–119. Pittsburgh: Duquesne University Press.

Vorgrimler, Herbert. 1986. Understanding Karl Rahner An Introduction to His Life and Thought. Translated by John Bowden. New York: Crossroad.

Wallace, William. 1968. “Thomism and Modern Science: Relationships Past, Present, and Future.” The Thomist 32(1): 67–83.

Weigel, Gustave. 1951. “Gleanings from the Commentaries on Humani Generis.” Theological Studies 12(4): 519–549.

Wicks, Jared. 2001. “Pieter Smulders and Dei Verbum: 1. A Consultation on the Eve of Vatican II.” Gregorianum 81: 241–297.

Wicks, Jared. 2008. “Six Texts by Prof. Joseph Ratzinger as Peritus Before and During Vatican Council II.” Gregorianum 89: 233–311.

Wicks, Jared. 2018. Investigating Vatican II. Its Theologians, Ecumenical Turn, and Biblical Commitment. Washington, D.C.: The Catholic University of America Press.

Yarnold, Edward. 1971. The Theology of Original Sin. Notre Dame: Fides.








ISSN 2300-7648 (print)
ISSN 2353-5636 (online)

Partnerzy platformy czasopism