Fatima pictures and testimonials: in-depth analysis

Philippe Dalleur

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.12775/SetF.2021.001

Abstract


Using photographs and testimonials, we will analyze details of the “miracle of the spinning sun” on October 13, 1917, at solar noon near Fatima. The phenomenon predicted ahead of time, occurred as the clouds cleared on what began as a rainy day. Various explanations have been presented but do not stand up to a comparative analysis of eyewitnesses (up to 35 km away), weather data, and photographs. This article aims to bring clarity to this event through the analysis of certified photographs and testimonies comparing them to official meteorological and astronomical data. Our study confirms key points of the testimonials while focusing on objective data. The shadows and reflections reveal two soft light sources emerging from a rather dark background: one seen as a “pale sun”, and another overhead, fuzzy and as softly bright. The latter, likely being caused by a clear cloud, blurred the shadows of the weak “sun”. Strangely, the portions of clothing exposed to this “sun” dried quickly. This warm source, uncannily moonlike, was also able to cast distinct shadows on sloping surfaces and under objects. Eventually, these shadows will help us to estimate the height of the “sun” at ~30°, lower than the expected 42°. Therefore, the directly observed source could not have been the sun, and most probably not any physiological, psychological, or meteorological effect.

Keywords


apparition; miracle; skepticism; illusion; photography; parhelia

Full Text:

PDF

References


Abdellah, Marwa M., Mostafa, Engy M., Anber, Mohamed A., El Saman, Islam S., and Eldawla, Mohammed E., 2019. “Solar maculopathy: prognosis over one year follow up” BMC Ophthalmol 19:201. DOI: 10.1186/s12886-019-1199-6

Aittala, Miika, 2010. “Inverse lighting and photorealistic rendering for augmented reality.” The Visual Computer, 26(6-8):669–678.

Archbold, Matthew, 2016. “Top 10 "Scientific" and Hilarious Explanations for the Miracle at Fatima”, National Catholic Register, https://www.ncregister.com/blog/top-10-scientific-and-hilarious-explanations-for-the-miracle-at-fatima

Barthas, Casimir, 1957. Fatima, merveille du XXe siècle, Fatima-éditions, Toulouse.

Barthas, Casimir, 1969. Fatima, 1917-1968. Histoire complète des apparitions et de leurs suites, Fatima-éditions, Toulouse.

Blom, Jan D., 2010. A Dictionary of Hallucinations, Springer Verlag, New-York.

Bunteong, Anusorn, and Chotikakamthorn, Nopporn, 2016. “Light source estimation using feature points from specular highlights and cast shadows.” International Journal of Physical Sciences, 11:168-177. DOI: 10.5897/IJPS2015.4274

Cambpell, Steuart, 1989. “The ‘Miracle’ of the Sun at Fatima.” Journal of Meteorology, 14(142):333-338, http://www.ijmet.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/142.pdf

Chalupsky, Mary, 2017. “Bishop at Mass recalls aunt's story of being at Fatima for miracle of sun.” The Pilot, https://thebostonpilot.com/article.asp?Source=Trending&ID=180544

Coelho Cristino, Luciano, and dos Santos Silva, Ana Teresa, 2013. Documentação crítica de Fátima: Seleção de documentos (1917-1930), Santuario de Fátima, accesible at http://www.fatima.pt/files/upload/fontes/F001_DCF_selecao.pdf

Cowley, Les, 2020. “Atmospheric Optics”, Website, https://www.atoptics.co.uk/halo/dogalt.htm, https://www.atoptics.co.uk/halo/dogfm.htm, https://www.atoptics.co.uk/halo/parhelia.htm, accessed 12 Nov. 2020.

de Montmollin, Germaine, 1956. “L'effet autocinétique comme phénomène et comme instrument.” L'année psychologique, 56(2):461-474, DOI:10.3406/psy.1956.8887

Gomes, João Fr., 2017. “Fátima. 13 testemunhos de quem esteve no dia do ‘milagre do Sol’”, Observador, https://observador.pt/especiais/fatima-13-testemunhos-de-quem-esteve-no-dia-do-milagre-do-sol.

Haffert, John M., 2006. Meet the witnesses of the miracle of the Sun, TFP, Spring Grove, Penn.

Hope-Ross, Monique, Travers, Stephen, and Mooney, David, 1988. “Solar retinopathy following religious rituals” British Journal of Ophthalmology, 72:931-934

Jacobson, Reginald E., Ray Sidney F., Attridge Geoffrey G., and Axford Norman R., 2000. The Manual of Photography. Photographic and digital imaging, 9th ed., Focal Press.

Jaki, Stanley L., 1999. God and the Sun at Fatima, Real View Books.

Jaki, Stanley L., 2000. The Sun's Miracle, or of Something Else? Real View Books.

Jenkins, Rob, and Kerr, Christine, 2013. “Identifiable Images of Bystanders Extracted from Corneal Reflections.” PLOS ONE. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0083325

Källmark, Fredrik P., and Ygge, Jan, 2005. “Photo-induced foveal injury after viewing a solar eclipse.” Acta Ophthalmol. Scand.,: 83:586–589. DOI: 10.1111/j.1600-0420.2005.00511.x

Kán, Peter, and Kafumann Hannes, 2019. “DeepLight: light source estimation for augmented reality using deep learning”, Visual Computer, 35:873–883. DOI: 10.1007/s00371-019-01666-x

Kinkaid, James C., 1936. Press Photography, Boston, American Photographic Publishing Co.

Kolivand, Hoshang, Sunar, Mohd Sh., Ismail, Ismahafezi, and Kolivand, Mahyar, 2015. “Fuzzy Soft Shadow in Augmented Reality Systems” Borneo Science, 36(2):8-18. http://borneoscience.ums.edu.my/?p=1795

Können, Gunther P., 1985. Polarized Light in Nature. CUP, Cambridge.

Lalonde Jean Fr., Efros Alexei A., and Narasimhan Srinivasa G., 2009. “Estimating natural illumination from a single outdoor image” 2009 IEEE 12th International Conference on Computer Vision, Kyoto, 183-190, DOI: 10.1109/ICCV.2009.5459163.

Li, Dan, Xiao, Bin, Hu, Yingsong, and Yang, Ruizhang, 2014. “Multiple linear parameters algorithm in illumination consistency.” Proceeding of the 11th World Congress on Intelligent Control and Automation, 5384-5388, DOI: 10.1109/WCICA.2014.7053633

Malawski, Filip, 2018. "Driver Assistance System Using Augmented Reality Headset," 2018 41st International Conference on Telecommunications and Signal Processing (TSP), Athens, 1-4, DOI: 10.1109/TSP.2018.8441298.

Meessen, August, 2005. “Apparitions and Miracles of the Sun”, Actas do Forum International, Centro Transdisciplinar de Estudos da Consciência, Consciências 2, Eds. J. Fernandes, N.L. Santos, 199-222.

Meinel, Aden, and Meinel, Marjorie, 1983. Sunsets, Twilights and Evening Skies, CUP, Cambridge.

Morujão, Isabel, 2017. “As Aparições de Fátima relatadas por carta: redes sociais e familiares da espiritualidade mariana.”, Via Spiritus, 24:5-49.

Mwanza, Jean-Claude K., Kayembe, D.L., Kaimbo, Dieudonné K., Kabasele, Paul M., and Ngoy, D. K., 2000. “Rétinopathie solaire acquise durant des séances de prière.” Bull. Soc. Belge Ophtalmol., 275:41-45.

Nickel, Joe, 1993. Looking for a Miracle. Weeping Icons, Relics, Stigmata, Visions and Healing Cures. Prometheus Book.

Peres, Michael R., 2007. The Focal Encyclopedia of Photography, 4th ed., Elsevier.

Pires, Catarina, 2016. “A surpreendente história da família Ruah.” Noticias Magazine, Lisboa, 11 apr., https://www.noticiasmagazine.pt/topico/samuel-ruah/

Radford, Benjamin, 2013. “The Lady of Fatima & the Miracle of the Sun.” Live Science, May 02, https://www.livescience.com/29290-fatima-miracle.html

Radford, Benjamin, 2019. “Fatima Miracle Claims All Wet.” Skeptical Inquirer, 43(3) May/June, https://skepticalinquirer.org/2019/05/fatima-miracle-claims-all-wet/

Reis, Bruno Cardoso, 2001. "Fátima: A Recepção Nos Diários Católicos (1917-1930)." Análise Social 36(158/159):249-299. http://www.jstor.org/stable/41011505.

Seo, Sanghyun, Kang, Dongwann, and Park, Sangoh, 2018. “Real-time adaptable and coherent rendering for outdoor augmented reality.” J. Image Video Proc., 1-8. DOI: 10.1186/s13640-018-0357-8

Sheemar, Abhishek, Takkar, Brijesh, Temkar, Shreyas, and Venkatesh, Pradeep, 2017. “Solar retinopathy: the yellow dot and the rising sun.” BMJ Case Reports, DOI: 10.1136/bcr-2017-222690.

Simons, Paul, 2005. "Weather Secrets of Miracle at Fátima" The Times, 17 February.

Tape, Walter, 1994. Atmospheric Halos, American Geophysical Union, Antarctic Research Series, 64.

Tape, Walter, and Moilanen Jarmo, 2006. Atmospheric Halos and the Search for Angle x, American Geophysical Union.

Thornton, Donal, 2009. “Irish Catholic pilgrims 'blinded' by the light at Knock shrine to Virgin Mary.” Irish Central News, https://www.irishcentral.com/news/pilgrims-may-be-blinded-by-the-light-at-marys-shrine-in-ireland-78307647-237673041

Transancos, Stacy, 2013. “Skeptic Benjamin Radford on the Fátima Miracle” StrangeNotions.com, https://strangenotions.com/skeptic-benjamin-radford-on-the-fatima-miracle/

van den Aardweg, Gerard J.M, 1988. Fatima, 1917, de grootste paranormale gebeurtenis uit de moderne geschiedenis, Tabor, Brugge.

Wade, Nicholas J., and Heller, Dieter, 2003. “Visual Motion Illusions, Eye Movements, and the Search for Objectivity.” Journal of the History of the Neurosciences: Basic and Clinical Perspectives, 12:4, 376-395. DOI: 10.1076/jhin.12.4.376.27911

Weng, Christina Y., Lim, Jennifer, Larrazabal, Luis Ignacio, and Chod, Ross Bronson, 2020. “Solar Retinopathy” Eyewiki Encyclopedia, American Academy of Ophtalmology, https://eyewiki.aao.org/Solar_Retinopathy

Whelan, Thomas, Salas-Moreno, Renato F., Glocker, Ben, Davison, Andrew J., and Leutenegger, Stefan, 2016. “Elasticfusion: real-time dense slam and light source estimation” Int. J. Robot Res. 35(14), 1697–1716.

Wirowski Artur, 2012. "Modelling of the Phenomenon Known as “the Miracle of the Sun” as the Reflection of Light from Ice Crystals Oscillating Synchronously," Journal of Modern Physics, 3(3):282-289. DOI: 10.4236/jmp.2012.33040.

Wirowski, Artur, and Szczerba, Paweł, 2019. “Derivation of equations of the model of the dynamic behaviour of the three-dimensional atmospheric cloud of electrically charged ice crystals under the influence of electrostatic forces.” Meccanica, 54:1703–1715, DOI: 10.1007/s11012-019-01044-w








ISSN 2300-7648 (print)
ISSN 2353-5636 (online)

Partnerzy platformy czasopism