Cues, Values and Conflict: Reassessing Evolution Wars Media Persuasion

Authors

  • Thomas Aechtner School of Historical and Philosophical Inquiry Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences University of Queensland https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0296-9339

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.12775/SetF.2020.021

Keywords

Antievolutionism, Intelligent Design, Cultural Cognition, Moral Foundations, New Atheism, Media Persuasion

Abstract

It has been posited that persuasive cues impart Evolution Wars communications with persuasive force extending beyond the merits of their communicated arguments.  Additionally, it has been observed that the array of cues displayed throughout proevolutionist materials is exceeded in both the number and nuance of Darwin-skeptic persuasion techniques.  This study reassesses these findings by exploring how persuasive cues in the Evolution Wars are being articulated with reference to the Cultural Cognition Thesis and Moral Foundations Theory.  Observations of Institute for Creation Research, Answers in Genesis, and the Center for Science and Culture media are reevaluated.  These findings are juxtaposed with data pertaining to Richard Dawkins Foundation for Reason and Science, National Center for Science Education, and BioLogos Foundation broadcasts.  The outcomes reveal how values claims and morally charged language are concentrated within the works of antievolutionists and New Atheist media makers, who collectively promote some manner of religion-science conflict.

Author Biography

Thomas Aechtner, School of Historical and Philosophical Inquiry Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences University of Queensland

Thomas Aechtner is the University of Queensland’s Senior Lecturer in Religion and Science.  He holds a doctorate from the University of Oxford, an MA in Religious Studies from the University of Calgary, and a BSc in Biological Sciences from the University of Alberta.  His primary work lies in contemporary science-and-religion discourse, with a focus on religiously motivated antievolutionism, vaccine hesitancies, mass persuasion, and public perceptions of science.

References

Aechtner, Thomas. 2014. "Darwin-Skeptic Mass Media: Examining Persuasion in the Evolution Wars." Journal of Media and Religion 13 (4):187-207. doi: 10.1080/15348423.2014.971559.

Aechtner, Thomas. 2016a. "Challenging the Darwin Skeptics: Examining Proevolutionist Media Persuasion." Journal of Media and Religion 15 (2):78-99. doi: 10.1080/15348423.2016.1177346.

Aechtner, Thomas. 2016b. "Terrorism in the Evolution Wars: Mass Media and Human Nature." Theology and Science 14 (4):495-517. doi: 10.1080/14746700.2016.1231983.

Ahluwalia, Rohini, and Robert E. Burnkrant. 2004. "Answering Questions about Questions: A Persuasion Knowledge Perspective for Understanding the Effects of Rhetorical Questions." The Journal of Consumer Research 31 (1):26-42.

AiG. 2010. "10 Basics Every Creationist Must Know." Answers 5 (2):85.

Allport, Floyd H., and Milton Lepkin. 1945. "Wartime Rumors of Waste and Special Privilege: Why Some People Believe Them." The Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 40 (1):3-36. doi: 10.1037/h0058110.

Bauchman, Voddie, Jr. 2009. "Life’s Toughest Questions." Answers 4 (2):58-65.

Bizer, George Y., and Richard E. Petty. 2005. "How We Conceptualize Our Attitudes Matters: The Effects of Valence Framing on the Resistance of Political Attitudes." Political Psychology 26 (4):553-568.

Boush, David M., Marian Friestad, and Peter Wright. 2009. Deception in the Marketplace: The Psychology of Deceptive Persuasion and Consumer Self Protection. New York: Routledge.

Burger, Jerry M., Nicole Messian, Shebani Patel, Alicia del Prado, and Carmen Anderson. 2004. "What a Coincidence! The Effects of Incidental Similarity on Compliance." Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 30 (1):35-43.

Cartwright, Dorwin. 1949. "Some Principles of Mass Persuasion: Selected Findings of Research on the Sale of United States War Bonds." Human Relations 2 (3):253-267.

Coyne, Jerry. 2009. "Must We Always Cater to the Faithful When Teaching Science?" Why Evolution is True, 24 March. https://whyevolutionistrue.wordpress.com/2009/03/24/must-we-always-cater-to-the-faithful-when-teaching-science/.

Dao, Christine. 2009. "Charles Darwin: The Man Behind the Monkey." Acts&Facts 38 (2):12.

Dao, Christine. 2011. "Texas Schools Seek Science Supplements." Acts&Facts 40 (2):19.

Dawkins, Richard. 2010. "The Pope Should Stand Trial." Richard Dawkins Foundation for Reason and Science, accessed February 11. https://richarddawkins.net/2010/04/the-pope-should-stand-trial/.

Day, Martin V., Susan T. Fiske, Emily L. Downing, and Thomas E. Trail. 2014. "Shifting Liberal and Conservative Attitudes Using Moral Foundations Theory." Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 40 (12):1559-1573. doi: 10.1177/0146167214551152.

Egnor, Michael. 2009a. "Dr. Jeffery Shallit on Eugenic Morality: "Why, exactly, would the world be better off with more Down's syndrome children?"." Center for Science and Culture, accessed October 14. http://www.evolutionnews.org/2009/05/dr_jeffery_shallit_why_is_euge020261.html.

Egnor, Michael. 2009b. "Ontology Recapitulates Philology." Center for Science and Culture, accessed October 25. http://www.evolutionnews.org/2009/08/ontology_recapitulates_philolo023851.html.

Egnor, Michael. 2009c. "Why Is Censorship of Scrutiny so Much a Part of Evolutionary Science?". Center for Science and Culture, accessed October 25. http://www.evolutionnews.org/2009/04/why_is_censorship_of_scrutiny019511.html.

Farris, Michael. 2011. "Showing Children the Way." Answers 6 (4):78.

Fleitas, Daniel W. 1971. "Bandwagon and Underdog Effects in Minimal-Information Elections." The American Political Science Review 65 (2):434-438.

Ford, Lawrence E. 2010a. "Celebrating with Gusto and Gratitude." Acts&Facts 39 (7):3.

Ford, Lawrence E. 2010b. "Stand Up! Stand Up for Jesus!" Acts&Facts 39 (12):3.

Forlow, Brad. 2011. "Genesis Under the Microscope." Acts&Facts 40 (10):4-5.

Guliuzza, Randy J. 2011. "Darwin's Sacred Imposter: Natural Selection's Idolatrous Trap." Acts&Facts 40 (11):12-15.

Hafer, Carolyn L., Kelly L. Reynolds, and Monika A. Obertynski. 1996. "Message Comprehensibility and Persuasion: Effects of Complex Language in Counterattitudinal Appeals to Laypeople." Social Cognition 14 (4):317-337.

Haidt, Jonathan, and Jesse Graham. 2007. "When Morality Opposes Justice: Conservatives Have Moral Intuitions that Liberals may not Recognize." Social Justice Research 20 (1):98-116. doi: 10.1007/s11211-007-0034-z.

Ham, Ken. 2011a. "Counterfeit Christian College." Answers 6 (3):54-57.

Ham, Steve. 2011b. "Unity . . . At What Cost?" Answers 6 (3):58-61.

Harris, Sam. 2009. "The Strange Case of Francis Collins." The Blog: Sam Harris, August 6. http://www.samharris.org/blog/item/the-strange-case-of-francis-collins.

Harris, Sam. 2010a. "Bringing the Vatican to Justice." The Huffington Post, accessed February 19. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/sam-harris/bringing-the-vatican-to-j_b_571088.html?ir=Australia.

Harris, Sam. 2010b. "What Obama Got Wrong About the Mosque." The Daily Beast, accessed 19 February. http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2010/08/13/ground-zero-mosque.html.

Hitchens, Christopher. 2009. "Assassins of the Mind." Vanity Fair, accessed February 12. https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2009/02/hitchens200902.

Hodge, Bodie. 2011. "Global Flood." Answers 6 (3):156.

James, Karen E., and Paul J. Hensel. 1991. "Negative Advertising: The Malicious Strain of Comparative Advertising." Journal of Advertising 20 (2):53-69.

Johnson, James J. S. 2010. "Tackling Charges of Biblical Inconsistency: Putting the Pieces Together to Form the Big Picture." Acts&Facts 39 (7):8-9.

Johnson, James J. S. 2011a. "Culpable Passivity: The Failure of Going with the Flow." Acts&Facts 40 (7):8-10.

Johnson, James J. S. 2011b. "Human Suffering: Why This Isn't the 'Best of All Possible Worlds'." Acts&Facts 40 (11):8-10.

Kahan, Dan. 2012. "Cultural Cognition as a Conception of the Cultural Theory of Risk." In Handbook of Risk Theory: Epistemology, Decision Theory, Ethics, and Social Implications of Risk, edited by Sabine Roeser, Rafaela Hillerbrand, Per Sandin and Martin Peterson, 725-759. Dordrecht: Springer.

Kahan, Dan, and Donald Braman. 2008. "The Self-Defensive Cognition of Self-Defense." The American Criminal Law Review 45 (1):1-65.

Kahan, Dan, Donald Braman, Geoffrey Cohen, John Gastil, and Paul Slovic. 2010. "Who Fears the HPV Vaccine, Who Doesn’t, and Why?: An Experimental Study of the Mechanisms of Cultural Cognition." Law and Human Behavior 34 (6):501-516. doi: 10.1007/s10979-009-9201-0.

Kahan, Dan, Hank Jenkins-Smith, Tor Tarantola, Carol Silva, and Donald Braman. 2015. "Geoengineering and Climate Change Polarization." The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 658 (1):192-222. doi: 10.1177/0002716214559002.

Kahan, Dan, Hank Jenkins‐Smith, and Donald Braman. 2011. "Cultural Cognition of Scientific Consensus." Journal of Risk Research 14 (2):147-174. doi: 10.1080/13669877.2010.511246.

Karmarkar, Uma R., and Zakary L. Tormala. 2010. "Believe Me, I Have No Idea What I’m Talking About: The Effects of Source Certainty on Consumer Involvement and Persuasion." The Journal of Consumer Research 36 (6):1033-1049.

Klinghoffer, David. 2009a. "At Bloggingheads, Fleeing the Ritual Contamination of 'Creationism'." Center for Science and Culture, accessed October 20. http://www.evolutionnews.org/2009/09/the_contamination_of_creationi024741.html.

Klinghoffer, David. 2009b. "Robert Wright's Bloggingheads.tv Censors Intelligent Design Interview." Center for Science and Culture, accessed October 20. http://www.evolutionnews.org/2009/08/robert_wrights_bloggingheadstv024581.html.

Klinghoffer, David. 2009c. "The Strange Case of Little Green Footballs II." Center for Science and Culture, accessed October 20. http://www.evolutionnews.org/2009/02/the_strange_case_of_little_gre_1016671.html.

Landis, Don. 2011. "2. Claims of Divine Authorship." Answers 6 (2):56-57.

Lawton, Graham. 2010. "Templeton Prizewinner: We Need science plus Morality." New Scientist, accessed April 10. http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20627546.800-templeton-prizewinner-we-need-science-plus-morality.html.

Levine, David K., and Thomas R. Palfrey. 2007. "The Paradox of Voter Participation? A Laboratory Study." The American Political Science Review 101 (1):143-158.

Levine, Robert. 2003. The Power of Persuasion: How We’re Bought and Sold. New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons.

Lun, Janetta, Stacey Sinclair, Erin R. Whitchurch, and Catherine Glenn. 2007. "(Why) Do I Think What You Think? Epistemic Social Tuning and Implicit Prejudice." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 93 (6):957–972.

Luskin, Casey. 2009a. "Barbara Forrest Exposes Her Intolerance, Misrepresents Darwin-Doubting Scientist." Center for Science and Culture, accessed October 19. http://www.evolutionnews.org/2009/10/barbara_forrest_exposes_her_int026261.html.

Luskin, Casey. 2009b. "Eugenie Scott Claims Evolution Is Threatening to Certain Christian Traditions." Center for Science and Culture, accessed October 19. http://www.evolutionnews.org/2009/06/eugenie_scott_claims_evolution022041.html.

Luskin, Casey. 2009c. "A Partisan Affair (Part 6): False Claims about Science Education Policy in Edward Humes' Pseudo-History of Kitzmiller, 'Monkey Girl'." Center for Science and Culture, accessed October 19. http://www.evolutionnews.org/2009/01/a_partisan_affair_part_6_false015161.html.

Luskin, Casey. 2010. "Documents Reveal Intolerance Towards Intelligent Design at the California Science Center." Center for Science and Culture, accessed October 19. http://www.evolutionnews.org/2010/08/documents_reveal_intolerance_t037441.html.

Luskin, Casey. 2011. "How the Science Teachers' Lobby Keeps Its Constituents in the Dark on Evolution." Center for Science and Culture, accessed January 25. http://www.evolutionnews.org/2011/03/how_the_science_teachers_lobby044471.html.

Lynn, Michael. 1991. "Scarcity Effects on Value: A Quantitative Review of the Commodity Theory Literature." Psychology & Marketing 8 (1):43-57.

Lynn, Michael, and Paulette Bogert. 1996. "The Effect of Scarcity on Anticipated Price Appreciation." 1978-1984 26 (22).

Matthews, Mike. 2010. "The Humility Factor: Understanding God’s Truth." Answers 5 (1):82.

Menton, David. 2010. "Uniqueness of Man." Answers 5 (2):54-55.

Morris, Henry M. 2009 [1988]. "Dangerous Turn Ahead: Traveling Down the Road to Compromise." Acts&Facts 38 (6):4.

Morris, Henry M. 2011 [1995]. "Global Flood, Global Impact: The Legacy of The Genesis Flood." Acts&Facts 40 (2):10-11.

Morris, John D. 2011a. "The Creation Movement's Firm Foundation." Acts&Facts 40 (2):8-9.

Morris, John D. 2011b. "Doubt Versus Unbelief." Acts&Facts 40 (8):15.

Mortenson, Terry. 2010. "Six Literal Days." Answers 5 (2):50.

Paharia, Neeru, Anat Keinan, Jill Avery, and Juliet B. Schor. 2011. "The Underdog Effect: The Marketing of Disadvantage and Determination through Brand Biography." Journal of Consumer Research 37 (5):775-790.

Pechmann, Cornelia, and Gabriel Esteban. 1993. "Persuasion Processes Associated with Direct Comparative and Noncomparative Advertising and Implications for Advertising Effectiveness." Journal of Consumer Psychology 2 (4):403-432.

Perse, Elizabeth M. 2001. Media Effects and Society. Mahwah: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

Petty, Richard E., and John T. Cacioppo. 1986. Communication and Persuasion: Central and Peripheral Routes to Attitude Change. New York: Springer-Verlag.

Priester, Joseph R., and Richard E. Petty. 2003. "The Influence of Spokesperson Trustworthiness on Message Elaboration, Attitude Strength, and Advertising Effectiveness." Journal of Consumer Psychology 13 (4):408-421.

Richards, Jay W. 2010. "Are Chimps and Humans Really All That Much Alike?". Center for Science and Culture, accessed October 14. http://www.evolutionnews.org/2010/02/are_chimps_and_humans_really_a031631.html.

Sechrist, Gretchen B., and Charles Stangor. 2007. "When are Intergroup Attitudes Based on Perceived Consensus Information?: The Role of Group Familiarity." Social Influence 2 (3):211-235.

Shumann, David W., Richard E. Petty, and D. Scott Clemons. 1990. "Predicting the Effectiveness of Different Strategies of Advertising Variation: A Test of the Repetition-Variation Hypotheses." The Journal of Consumer Research 17 (2):192-202.

Smith, Anika. 2011. "Playing "Science Says" Is a Political Game." Center for Science and Culture, accessed January 25. http://www.evolutionnews.org/2011/01/playing_science_says_is_a_poli042541.html.

Snelling, Andrew A. 2009. "Genesis: Real, Reliable, Historical." Acts&Facts 38 (9):12-14.

Thomas, Brian. 2011. "The Stones Cry Out: What Rocks and Fossils Say about the Age of the Earth." Acts&Facts 40 (1):17.

Tomkins, Jeffrey. 2009. "Human-Chimp Similarities: Common Ancestry or Flawed Research?" Acts&Facts 38 (6):12-13.

Tomkins, Jeffrey. 2011. "First Phase Complete in Human and Chimp Genome-Wide DNA Comparison." Acts&Facts 40 (12).

Upchurch, John. 2011. "The Danger of BioLogos: Blurring the Line Between Creation and Evolution." Answers 6 (4):38-41.

West, John G. 2009. "Slouching Toward Columbine: Darwin's Tree of Death." Center for Science and Culture, accessed October 18. http://www.evolutionnews.org/2009/04/slouching_toward_columbine_dar019691.html.

Wheeler, Christian S., Richard E. Petty, and George Y. Bizer. 2005. "Self-Schema Matching and Attitude Change: Situational and Dispositional Determinants of Message Elaboration." Journal of Consumer Research 31 (4):787. doi: 10.1086/426613.

Williams, Patti, Gavan J. Fitzsimons, and Lauren G. Block. 2004. "When Consumers Do Not Recognize “Benign” Intention Questions as Persuasion Attempts." The Journal of Consumer Research 31 (3):540-550.

Wolsko, Christopher, Hector Ariceaga, and Jesse Seiden. 2016. "Red, White, and Blue Enough to be Green: Effects of Moral Framing on Climate Change Attitudes and Conservation Behaviors." Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 65:7-19. doi: 10.1016/j.jesp.2016.02.005.

Scientia et Fides

Downloads

Published

2020-10-30

How to Cite

1.
AECHTNER, Thomas. Cues, Values and Conflict: Reassessing Evolution Wars Media Persuasion. Scientia et Fides. Online. 30 October 2020. Vol. 8, no. 2, pp. 249-284. [Accessed 10 December 2023]. DOI 10.12775/SetF.2020.021.

Issue

Vol. 8 No. 2 (2020): Philosophical and Theological Aspects of Evolution

Section

Articles

License

Copyright (c) 2020 Scientia et Fides

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

CC BY ND 4.0. The Creator/Contributor is the Licensor, who grants the Licensee a non-exclusive license to use the Work on the fields indicated in the License Agreement.

  • The Licensor grants the Licensee a non-exclusive license to use the Work/related rights item specified in § 1 within the following fields: a) recording of Work/related rights item; b) reproduction (multiplication) of Work/related rights item in print and digital technology (e-book, audiobook); c) placing the copies of the multiplied Work/related rights item on the market; d) entering the Work/related rights item to computer memory; e) distribution of the work in electronic version in the open access form on the basis of Creative Commons license (CC BY-ND 3.0) via the digital platform of the Nicolaus Copernicus University Press and file repository of the Nicolaus Copernicus University.
  • Usage of the recorded Work by the Licensee within the above fields is not restricted by time, numbers or territory.
  • The Licensor grants the license for the Work/related rights item to the Licensee free of charge and for an unspecified period of time.

FULL TEXT License Agreement

Stats

Number of views and downloads: 424
Number of citations: 0