Anthropogenesis and the Soul
Keywordsevolution, language, hylomorphism, David Braine, Aquinas
The science of evolution acutely raises the perennial question of humankind’s place in the world. How does the theological anthropology of humans as imago Dei relate to an evolutionary anthropology with human beings derived from ancestral hominid species? Evolutionary biologists disclose ever greater similarities and continuity between animals and humans. Is human distinctiveness simply continuous with other ancestral forms of life or is there any kind of discontinuity? The answers to these questions depend not only on zoological considerations but also on one’s philosophy of nature. The standard anthropology within the Catholic Church is the dual-origin model: the human body originates through evolution, but the human soul is directly created by God. This formulation, however, is not without difficulties, primarily for its seeming Cartesian dualism of a body and soul as distinct substances. This paper develops the anthropology of David Braine who, drawing upon Aristotle, Thomas Aquinas, and Ludwig Wittgenstein, clearly situates humans as animals in great continuity with them. However, as linguistic animals who think in a medium of words, humans have a form of life—a soul—that transcends bodily processes. Braine’s anthropology provides a more coherent anthropology to understand the continuity and discontinuity of the human person in phylogenetic relationship to other species within an evolutionary perspective.
Aquinas, Thomas. 1956. Summa Contra Gentiles. Book Three: Providence Part I. Translated by Vernon J. Bourke. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
Aquinas, Thomas. 1948. Summa Theologica. Translated by Fathers of the English Dominican Province. New York: Benzinger Brothers, Inc.
Aquinas, Thomas. 1876. Epistolam I ad Corinthios. In Thomas Aquinas, Opera Omnia, vol. 21, edited by Stanislai Eduardi Fretté. Paris: P. Larousse.
Benton, Ted. 2009. “Race, Sex and the ‘Earthly Paradise’: Wallace Versus Darwin on Human Evolution and Prospects.” Sociological Review 57 Supplemental 2: 23-46.
Barbour, Ian. 1997. Religion and Science: Historical and Contemporary Issues. San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco.
Braine, David. 2014. Language and Human Understanding. Washington, D.C.: The Catholic University of America Press.
Braine, David. 2013. “Life and Human Life: Their Nature and Emergence.” In The Missing Link, edited by Roy Abraham Varghese, 132-160. Landam: University Press of America.
Braine, David. 1992. The Human Person: Animal and Spirit. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
Brüntrup, Godehard. 2008. Das Leib-Seele-Problem. 3. Auflage. Stuttgart: W. Kohlhammer.
Burrell, C.S.C., David. 2008. Aquinas: God and Action. Scranton: University of Scranton Press.
Burrell, C.S.C., David B. 2000. “Freedom and Creation in the Abrahamic Traditions.” International Philosophical Quarterly XL.2: 161-71.
Cohen, S. Marc. 1992. “Hylomorphism and Functionalism.” In Essays on Aristotle’s De Anima, edited by Martha C. Nussbaum and Amélie Oksenberg Rorty, 57-73. Oxford: Clarendon.
Crick, Francis and Christof Koch. 2003. “A Framework for Consciousness.” Nature Neuroscience 6: 119-26.
Darwin, Charles. 1936. The Origin of Species and the Descent of Man. New York: The Modern Library.
Davies, Brian. 2005. Introduction to The Good Life: Ethics and the Pursuit of Happiness by Herbert McCabe, vii-xiii. London: Continuum.
Donald, Merlin. 1991. Origins of the Modern Mind: Three Stages in the Evolution of Culture and Cognition. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Fuentes, Agustin. 2014. “Human Evolution, Niche Complexity, and the Emergence of a Distinctively Human Imagination.” Time and Mind 7: 241-57.
Glickman, Stephen. 2009. “Charles Darwin, Alfred Russell Wallace, and the Evolution/Creation of the Human Brain and Mind.” Gayana 73 (Supplemental): 32-41.
Gregory of Nyssa. 1994. De hominis opificio. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers. Vol. 5. Gregory of Nyssa: Dogmatic Treatises, etc. 2nd Series, edited by Philip Schaff and H. Wace. Peabody: Hendrickson Publishers.
Hart, David Bentley. 2013. Experience of God: Being, Consciousness, Bliss. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Hutchinson, G. E. 1965. The Ecological Theater and the Evolutionary Play. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Huxley, Thomas H. 1863. Evidence of Man’s Place in Nature. New York: D. Appleton and Co.
Huxley, Thomas H. 1869. An Introduction to the Classification of Animals. London: John Churchill.
International Theological Commission (ITC). 2004. Communion and Stewardship: Human Persons Created in the Image of God. http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/cti_documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20040723_communion-stewardship_en.html (accessed March 30, 2020).
John Paul II. 1996. “Message to the Pontifical Academy of Sciences: On Evolution.” http://www.ewtn.com/library/PAPALCOC/JP961022.HTM (accessed March 30, 2020).
Koons, Robert C. and George Bealer, eds. 2010. The Waning of Materialism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
McCabe, O.P., Herbert. 2008. On Aquinas. London: Continuum.
McCabe, O.P., Herbert. 2005. The Good Life: Ethics and the Pursuit of Happiness. London: Continuum.
Mivart, St. George. 1898. The Groundwork of Science: A Study of Epistemology. London: John Murray.
Mivart, St. George. 1876. Lessons from Nature as Manifested in Mind and Matter. London: John Murray.
Mivart, St. George. 1871. On the Genesis of Species. London: Macmillan and Co.
Mivart, St. George. 1864. “Notes on the Crania and Dentition of the Lemuridae.” Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London. 32: 611-48.
Morris, Simon Conway. 2013. “Darwin, Mind and God.” In The Missing Link, edited by Roy Abraham Varghese, 129-31. Landam: University Press of America.
Nagel, Thomas. 2012. Mind and Cosmos: Why the Materialist Neo-Darwinian Conception of Nature is Almost Certainly False. New York: Oxford University Press.
O’Callaghan, John. 2015. “Evolution and Catholic Faith.” In Darwin in the Twenty-First Century: Nature, Humanity, and God, edited by P. R. Sloan, G. McKenny, and K. Eggleson, 269-98. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
Perelman, Polina, W. E Johnson, C. Roos, H. N. Seuánez, J. E. Horvath, M. A. M. Moreira, B. Kessing, J. Pontius, M. Roelke, Y. Rumpler, M. P. C. Schneider, A. Silva, S. J. O’Brien, and J. Pecon-Slattery. 2011. “A Molecular Phylogeny of Living Primates.” PLoS Genetics 7: 1-16.
Peters, Ted and Martin Hewlett. 2008. Can You Believe in God and Evolution? Nashville: Abingdon Press.
Pius XII. 1950. Humani generis. http://www.vatican.va/content/pius-xii/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-xii_enc_12081950_humani-generis.html (accessed March 30, 2020).
Ratzinger, Joseph. 1995. In the Beginning: A Catholic Understanding of the Story of Creation and the Fall. Grand Rapids: W.B. Eerdmans Pub. Co.
Ratzinger, Joseph. 2005. “Zum Personverständnis in der Theologie.” In Dogma und Verkündigung, 201-19. Donauwörth: Erich Wewel.
Ratzinger, Joseph. 2005. “Belief in Creation and the Theory of Evolution.” In Dogma and Preaching: Applying Christian Doctrine to Daily Life, edited by Michael J. Miller, 131-42. Translated by Michael Miller. San Francisco: Ignatius Press.
Runggaldier, Edmund. 2006. “The Aristotelian Alternative to Functionalism and Dualism.” In Die Menschliche Seele: Brauchen Wir den Dualismus?, edited by Bruno Niederbacher and Edmund Runggaldier, 221-48. Frankfurt: Ontos.
Sloan, Phillip. 2015. “Questioning the Zoological Gaze.” In Darwin in the Twenty-First Century: Nature, Humanity, and God, edited by P. R. Sloan, G. McKenny, and K. Eggleson, 232-66. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
Sloan, Phillip. 2009. “Bringing Evolution to Notre Dame: Father John Zahm, C.S.C. and Theistic Evolution.” American Midland Naturalist 161:189–205.
Sokolowski, Robert. 1995. The God of Faith and Reason. Washington, D.C.: The Catholic University of America.
Soskice, Janet. 2010. “Creatio ex nihilo: its Jewish and Christian Foundations.” In Creation and the God of Abraham, edited by D. Burrell, C. Cogliati, J. Soskice, and W. Stoeger, 24–39. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Tabaczek, OP, Mariusz. 2019. “What Do God and Creatures Really Do in an Evolutionary Change? Divine Concurrence and Transformism from the Thomistic Perspective.” American Catholic Philosophical Quarterly 93: 445-82.
Tanner, Kathryn. 1988. God and Creation in Christian Theology: Tyranny or Empowerment? Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Vessey, David. 2014. “The Role of the Concept ‘Person’ in Gadamer’s Philosophical Hermeneutics.” American Catholic Philosophical Quarterly 88: 117-38.
Wallace, Alfred Russell. 1864. “The Origin of Human Races and the Antiquity of Man Deduced from the Theory of ‘Natural Selection.’” Journal of the Anthropological Society of London 2: clviii-clxxxvii.
Whiten, Andrew and David Erdal. 2012. “The Human Socio-Cognitive Niche and Its Evolutionary Origins.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B 367: 2119-29.
Wilkins, Adam. 2017. Making Faces: The Evolutionary Origins of the Human Face. Cambridge: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
Wilson, E. O. 1975. Sociobiology: The New Synthesis. Cambridge: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
Wittgenstein, Ludwig. 1953. Philosophical Investigations. Translated by G. E. M. Anscombe. New York: The Macmillan Company.
Wright, Robert. 1994. The Moral Animal. New York: Vintage Books.
Zahm, John A. 1978. Evolution and Dogma. New York: Arno Press. [Orig. pub. 1896. Chicago: D. H. McBride.]
How to Cite
Copyright (c) 2020 Scientia et Fides
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
CC BY ND 4.0. The Creator/Contributor is the Licensor, who grants the Licensee a non-exclusive license to use the Work on the fields indicated in the License Agreement.
- The Licensor grants the Licensee a non-exclusive license to use the Work/related rights item specified in § 1 within the following fields: a) recording of Work/related rights item; b) reproduction (multiplication) of Work/related rights item in print and digital technology (e-book, audiobook); c) placing the copies of the multiplied Work/related rights item on the market; d) entering the Work/related rights item to computer memory; e) distribution of the work in electronic version in the open access form on the basis of Creative Commons license (CC BY-ND 3.0) via the digital platform of the Nicolaus Copernicus University Press and file repository of the Nicolaus Copernicus University.
- Usage of the recorded Work by the Licensee within the above fields is not restricted by time, numbers or territory.
- The Licensor grants the license for the Work/related rights item to the Licensee free of charge and for an unspecified period of time.
FULL TEXT License Agreement
Number of views and downloads: 514
Number of citations: 1