Obecność emocji w polityce zagranicznej państwa. Studium komparatystyczne wilhelmińskich Niemiec oraz Stanów Zjednoczonych w okresie prezydentury Donalda J. Trumpa
DOI :
https://doi.org/10.12775/DN.2024.2.08Mots-clés
Niemcy, Stany Zjednoczone, Donald J. Trump, Wilhelm II, emocje, stosunki międzynarodowe, historia międzynarodowaRésumé
Artykuł zwraca uwagę, iż obecność emocji w polityce zagranicznej państwa nie jest zjawiskiem nowym, lecz miała miejsce także w przeszłości. Wskazano, iż emocje towarzyszyły kreowaniu polityki zagranicznej wilhelmińskich Niemiec i USA doby prezydentury Donalda J. Trumpa na płaszczyźnie wewnątrzrządowej i międzynarodowej. Były one przejawem indywidualnych ludzkich preferencji, jak i świadomym narzędziem politycznym. Ekspresja emocjonalna pozostawała jednak zależna od ram kulturowych czasu i miejsca, w których funkcjonowały.
Références
Źródła drukowane
Bolton J.R., Trump w Białym Domu. Tajemnice Gabinetu Owalnego, tłum. T. Woźniak, Warszawa 2020.
Bülow B. von, Memoirs of Prince von Bulow, t. I: From Secretary of State to Imperial Chancellor, 1897–1903, Boston 1931.
Federal Elections 2016. Election Results for the U.S. President, the U.S. Senate and the U.S. House of Representative, Washington 2017.
Federal Elections 2020. Election Results for the U.S. President the U.S. Senate and the U.S. House of Representatives, Washington 2022.
Grey E., Twenty-Five Years, 1892–1916, t. II, London 1925.
Grisham S., I’ll Take Your Questions Now. What I Saw at the Trump White House, New York 2021.
Hill F., There is Nothing for You Here. Finding Opportunity in the Twenty-First Century, Boston–New York 2021.
Manigault Newman O., Unhinged. An Insiders Account Trump White House, London 2018.
Müller K.A. von, Denkwürdigkeiten der Reichskanzlerzeit, Stuttgart–Berlin 1931.
Official 2020 Presidential General Election Results, Washington 2021.
Płomiński K., Arabia Incognita. Raport polskiego ambasadora, Warszawa 2019.
The German Emperor as Shown in His Public Utterances, red. C. Gauss, New York 1915.
The Holstein Papers. The Memoirs, Diaries and Correspondence of Friedrich von Holstein, 1837–1909, t. I–II, IV, red. N. Rich, M.H. Fisher, Cambridge 1963.
The Letters of Empress Frederick, red. F. Ponsonby, London 1928.
Tirpitz A. von, Wspomnienia, Warszawa 1997.
Volk, Reich und Nation. Texte zur Einheit Deutschlands in Staat, Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft, 1806–1918, red. G. Krebs, B. Poloni, Paris–Asnières 1994.
Wilhelm II, Kaiser’s Memoirs, New York–London 1922.
Woodward B., Costa R., Peril. Trump, Biden and a Nation on the Brink, New York 2021.
Woodward B., Rage, New York 2020.
Woodward B., Strach. Trump w Białym Domu, tłum. H. Jankowska et al., Warszawa 2018.
Zedlitz-Trützschler R., Twelve Years at the Imperial German Court, London 1951.
Opracowania
Anderson Ch., The Emperor’s New Expressionism. Wilhelm II and the Modern Crisis, „Liminalities. A Journal of Performance Studies” 2013, t. IX, nr 1, s. 1–15.
Baldessarelli G., Emotions and Routine Dynamics, w: Cambridge Handbook of Routine Dynamics, red. M.S. Feldman et al., Cambridge 2021, s. 357–369.
Barrett L.F., Jak powstają emocje. Sekretne życie mózgu, tłum. A. Jarosz, Warszawa 2020.
Barrett L.F., The Theory of Constructed Emotion: an Active Inference Account of Interoception and Categorization, „Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience” 2017, t. XII, nr 1, s. 1–23.
Benitez J., U.S. NATO Policy in the Age of Trump: Controversy and Consistency, „The Fletcher Forum of World Affairs” 2019, t. XLIII, nr 1, s. 179–200.
Bew J., Realpolitik. A History, Oxford–New York 2016.
Bleiker R., Hutchison E., Introduction: Emotions and world politics, „International Theory” 2014, t. VI, nr 3, s. 490–491.
Borutta M., Enemies at the Gate: The Moabit Klostersturm and the Kulturkampf: Germany, w: Culture Wars. Secular-Catholic Conflict in Nineteenth-Century Europe, red. C.M. Clark, W. Kaiser, Cambridge–New York 2003, s. 227–255.
Buzan B., Little R., Systemy międzynarodowe w historii świata, tłum. E. Brzozowska, Warszawa 2011.
Castle J., New Fronts in the Culture Wars? Religion, Partisanship, and Polarization on Religious Liberty and Transgender Rights in the United States, „American Politics Research” 2019, t. XLVII, nr 3, s. 650–679.
Cecil L., The German Diplomatic Service, 1871–1914, Princeton 1976.
Cecil L., Wilhelm II. Emperor and Exile, 1900–1941, Urbana 1996.
Clément M., Sangar E., Introduction. Methodological Challenges and Opportunities for the Study of Emotions, w: Researching Emotions in International Relations. Methodological Perspectives on the Emotional Turn, red. M. Clément, E. Sangar, Cham 2018, s. 1–30.
Coetzee M.S., German Army League. Popular Nationalism in Wilhelmine Germany, Oxford 1990.
Damski P.P., Klio czuje. Rozważania nad historią międzynarodową na przykładzie emocji, „Historyka. Studia Metodologiczne” 2022, t. LII, s. 409–434.
Doing Emotions History, red. S.J. Matt, P.N. Stearns, Urbana 2014.
Duroselle J.B., The Statesman, w: Introduction to the History of International Relations, red. P. Renouvin, J.B. Duroselle, London 1968, s. 237–376.
Eley G., Reshaping the German Right. Radical Nationalism and Political Change After Bismarck, Ann Arbor 1991.
Emotions in International Politics. Beyond Mainstream International Relations, red. Y. Ariffin, J.M. Coicaud, V. Popovski, Cambridge 2016.
Engel J.A., No More Mullingans. Donald Trump and International Alliances, w: The Presidency of Donald J. Trump. A First Historical Assessment, red. J.E. Zelizer, Princeton–Oxford 2022, s. 238–258.
Entous A., The Political Scene. A Devil’s Bargain, „The New Yorker”, 29 VI 2020.
Epkenhans M., Wilhelm II and ‘his’ navy, 1888-1918, w: The Kaiser. New Research on Wilhelm II’s Role in Imperial Germany, red. W. Deist, A. Mombauer, Edinburgh–New York 2004, s. 12–36.
Ettinger A., Principled realism and populist sovereignty in Trump’s foreign policy, „Cambridge Review of International Affairs” 2020, t. XXXIII, nr 3, s. 410–431.
Eyal G., The Crisis of Expertise, Cambridge 2019.
Feldman D.C., Morris J.A., Managing Emotions in the Workplace, „Journal of Managerial Issues” 1997, t. IX, nr 3, s. 257–274.
Fierke K.M., Emotions in IR: The ‘Dog That Did Not Bark’, „E-International Relations”, 20 II 2015, https://www.e-ir.info/2015/02/20/emotions-in-ir-the-dog-that-did-not-bark/ (dostęp: 11 VIII 2020).
Fout J.C., Sexual Politics in Wilhelmine Germany: The Male Gender Crisis, Moral Purity, and Homophobia, „Journal of the History of Sexuality” 1992, t. II, nr 3, s. 388–421.
Fraley J.D., Government by Procrastination. Chancellor Hohenlohe and Kaiser William II, 1894–1900, „Central European History” 1974, t. VII, nr 2, s. 159–183.
Frevert U., Emotions in History. Lost and Found, Budapest–New York 2011.
Gabriel A.H., Grief and rage: Collective emotions in the politics of peace and the politics of gender in Israel, „Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry” 1992, t. XVI, nr 3, s. 311–335.
Gasiul H., Wprowadzenie do sposobu pojmowania emocji i możliwości ich pomiaru, w: Metody badania emocji i motywacji, red. H. Gasiul, Warszawa 2018, s. 17–49.
Gause III F.G., Donald Trump and the Middle East, w: Chaos in the Liberal Order. The Trump Presidency and International Politics in the Twenty-First Century, red. F.J. Gavin et al., New York 2018, s. 273–286.
Gefühl und Kalkül. Der Einfluss von Emotionen auf die Politik des 19. und 20. Jahrhunderts, Steiner, red. B. Aschmann, Stuttgart 2005.
Hitzer B., Scheer M., Unholy Feelings. Questioning Evangelical Emotions in Wilhelmine Germany, „German History” 2014, t. XXXII, nr 3, s. 371–392.
Horlick-Jones T., Marchi B. de, The Crisis of Scientific Expertise in Fin de Siècle Europe, „Science and Public Policy” 1995, t. XXII, nr 3, s. 139–145.
Hughes J.M., Emotion and High Politics. Personal Relations at the Summit in Late Nineteenth-Century Britain and Germany, Berkeley 1983.
Hull I.V., Kaiser Wilhelm II and the Liebenberg Circle, w: Kaiser Wilhelm II. New Interpretations: The Corfu Papers, red. J.C.G. Röhl, N. Sombart, Cambridge 1982, s. 193–220.
Hunter J.D., Wolfe A., Dionne E.J., Cromartie M., Is There a Culture War? A Dialogue on Values and American Public Life, Washington 2006.
Hutchison E., Trauma and the Politics of Emotions: Constituting Identity, Security and Community after the Bali Bombing, „International Relations” 2010, t. XXIV, nr 1, s. 65–86.
Hymans J.E.C., The Psychology of Nuclear Proliferation. Identity, Emotions, and Foreign Policy, Cambridge 2006.
Immerman R., Psychology, w: Explaining the history of American foreign relations, red. M.J. Hogan, T.G. Paterson, Cambridge 2004, s. 103–122.
Jarymowicz M., Imbir K., O dynamice emocji wzbudzanych dynamicznie bądź refleksyjnie, w: Dynamika emocji. Teoria i praktyka, red. D. Doliński, W. Błaszczak, Warszawa 2019, s. 13–30.
Kazin M., The Path of Most Resistance: How Democrats Battled Trump and Moved Left, w: The Presidency of Donald J. Trump. A First Historical Assessment, red. J.E. Zelizer, Princeton–Oxford 2022, s. 335–350.
Kennedy P., Mocarstwa świata: narodziny, rozkwit, upadek. Przemiany gospodarcze i konflikty zbrojne w latach 1500–2000, tłum. M. Kluźniak, Warszawa 1984.
Kennedy P., The Kaiser and German Weltpolitik. Reflexions on Wilhelm II’s place in the making of German foreign policy, w: Kaiser Wilhelm II. New Interpretations: The Corfu Papers, red. J.C.G. Röhl, N. Sombart, Cambridge 1982, s. 143–168.
Lerman K.A., The Decisive Relationship. Kaiser Wilhelm II and Chancellor Bernhard von Bülow, 1900–1909, w: Kaiser Wilhelm II. New Interpretations: The Corfu Papers, red. J.C.G. Röhl, N. Sombart, Cambridge 1982, s. 221–248.
Lerman K.A., The Kaiser’s Elite? Wilhelm II and the Berlin Administration, 1890–1914, w: The Kaiser. New research on Wilhelm II’s role in Imperial Germany, red. W. Deist, A. Mombauer, Edinburgh–New York 2004, s. 63–90.
Linklater A., Racjonalizm, w: Teorie stosunków międzynarodowych, red. S. Burchill et al., tłum. P. Frankowski, Warszawa 2006, s. 139–170.
Loth W., Angst und Vertrauensbildung, w: Dimensionen internationaler Geschichte, red. J. Dülffer, W. Loth, München 2012, s. 29–46.
Massie R.K., Dreadnought. Brytania, Niemcy i nadejście Wielkiej Wojny, tłum. W. Chrzanowski, t. I, Gdańsk 2004.
Menon S., Nobody Wants the Current World Order: How All the Major Powers-Even the United States-Became Revisionists, „Foreign Affairs Magazine”, 3 VIII 2022, https:// www.foreignaffairs.com/world/nobody-wants-current-world-order (dostęp: 19 VIII 2022).
McLean R.R., Dreams of a German Europe. Wilhelm II and the Treaty of Björkö of 1905, w: The Kaiser. New research on Wilhelm II’s role in imperial Germany, red. A. Mombauer, W. Deist, Cambridge 2004, s. 119–142.
McLean R.R., Kaiser Wilhelm II and the British Royal Family. Anglo-German Dynastic Relations in Political Context, 1890–1914, „History” 2001, t. LXXXVI, nr 284, s. 478–502.
Mitchell N., Is Donald Trump Jimmy Carter, or is he Wilhelm II?, w: Chaos in the Iiberal Order. The Trump Presidency and International Politics in the Twenty-First Century, red. F.J. Gavin et al., New York 2018.
Morawiec J., Wielkie namiętności i ich społeczno-polityczne reperkusje na przykładzie „Hallfredar saga” i „Bjarnar saga Hitdaelakappa”, w: Cor hominis. Wielkie namiętności w dziejach, źródłach i studiach nad przeszłością, red. S. Rosik, P. Wiszewski, Wrocław 2007, s. 151–168.
Mylonas H., Kuo K., Nationalism and Foreign Policy, w: Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics, 26 IX 2017, https://oxfordre.com/politics/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.001.0001/acrefore-9780190228637-e-452 (dostęp: 3 VIII 2022).
Nichols J., Germany after Bismarck. The Caprivi Era, 1890–1894, Cambridge 1958.
Norris P., Inglehart R., Cultural Backlash. Trump, Brexit, and Authoritarian Populism, Cambridge 2018.
Osterhammel J., Historia XIX wieku. Przeobrażenie świata, tłum. I. Drozdowska-Broering et al., Poznań 2013.
Oztig L.I., The Transatlantic Alliance in the Age of Trump, „Global Change, Peace & Security” 2020, t. XXXII, nr 3, s. 297–315.
Poast P., A World of Power and Fear: What Critics of Realism Get Wrong, „Foreign Affairs Magazine”, 15 VI 2022, https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/ukraine/2022-06-15/world-power-and-fear (dostęp: 3 VIII 2022).
Reddy W., Emotional Liberty: Politics and History in the Anthropology of Emotions, „Cultural Anthropology” 1992, t. XIV, nr 2, s. 256–258.
Reddy W., The Navigation of Feeling. A Framework for the History of Emotions, Cambridge 2001.
Röhl J.C.G., The Kaiser and His Court. Wilhelm II and the Government of Germany, Cambridge–New York 1994.
Röhl J.C.G., Wilhelm II. Into the Abyss of War and Exile 1900–1941, Cambridge–New York 2014.
Rosenwein B., Generations of Feeling. A History of Emotions, Cambridge 2016.
Rosenwein B., Worrying About Emotions in History, „American Historical Review” 2002, t. CVII, nr 3, s. 821–845.
Salmi H., Europa XIX wieku. Historia kulturowa, tłum. A. Szurek, Kraków 2010.
Schwalbe M., The Crisis of Expertise, „Contemporary Sociology” 2021, t. L, nr 1, s. 45–47.
Smith J.R., The Monarchy versus the Nation: The „Festive Year” 1913 in Wilhelmine Germany, „German Studies Review” 2000, t. XXIII, nr 2, s. 257–274.
Sombart N., The Kaiser in his epoch. Some reflections on Wilhelmine society, sexuality and culture, w: Kaiser Wilhelm II. New Interpretations: The Corfu Papers, red. J.C.G. Röhl, N. Sombart, Cambridge 1982, s. 287–311.
Sösemann B., Die sog. Hunnenrede Wilhelms II. Textrichtische und interpretatorische Bemerkungen zur Ansprache des Kaisers vom 27. Juli 1900 in Bremerhaven, „Historische Zeitschrift” 1976, t. CCXXII, nr 1, s. 342–358.
Sösemann B., Hollow-Sounding Jubilees. Forms and Effects of Public Self-Display in Wilhelmine Germany, w: The Kaiser. New Research on Wilhelm II’s Role in Imperial Germany, red. W. Deist, A. Mombauer, Edinburgh–New York 2004, s. 37–62.
Stearns P.N., Stearns C.Z., Emotionology: Clarifying the history of emotions and emotional standards, „American Historical Review” 1985, t. XC, nr 4, s. 813–836.
Steinberg J., Bismarck. A Life, New York 2011.
Taylor T., Images of Youth and the Family in Wilhelmine Germany: Toward a Reconsideration of the German Sonderweg, „German Studies Review” 1992, t. XV, s. 55–73.
Toye R., Churchill’s Empire. The World That Made Him and the World He Made, London 2011.
Wallerstein I., World-Systems Analysis. Introduction, Durham–London 2004.
Wigura K., Wina narodów. Przebaczenie jako strategia prowadzenia polityki, Gdańsk–Warszawa 2011.
Wróbel S., Logos, Ethos, Pathos. Classical Rhetoric Revisited, „Polish Sociological Review” 2015, t. CXCI, nr 3, s. 401–422.
Netografia
Bayerische Staatsbibliothek, 100(0) Schlüsseldokumente zur deutschen Geschichte im 20. Jahrhundert, https://www.1000dokumente.de/
Bundeswehr.de, https://www.bundeswehr.de
Lebendiges Museum Online, https://www.dhm.de/lemo
The American Presidency Project, https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu
Media
Bandow D., What Trump Has in Common with the Last German Emperor, „The National Interest”, 31 I 2017, https://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-skeptics/what-trump-has-common-the-last-german-emperor-19265 (dostęp: 6 IX 2022).
Brownstein R., Trump Is Escalating His War on Blue America, „The Atlantic”, 14 V 2020, https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/05/trump-escalating-his-war-blue-america/611653/ (dostęp: 5 IX 2022).
Goldberg J., Why Did James Mattis Resign as Defense Secretary?, „The Atlantic”, 29 VIII 2019, https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2019/10/james-mattis-trump/596665/ (dostęp: 16 VII 2022).
House Impeachment Inquiry Hearing. Hill & Holmes Testimony, „C-SPAN”, 21 XI 2019, https://www.c-span.org/video/?466380-1/impeachment-inquiry-hearing-fiona-hill-david-holmes (dostęp: 11 VIII 2022)
Parker A., Dawsey J., Rucker P., Leonnig C.D., Trump decides to remove national security adviser, and others may follow, „The Washington Post”, 16 III 2018, https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-decides-to-remove-national-security-adviser-and-others-may-follow/2018/03/15/fea2ebae-285c-11e8-bc72-077aa4dab9ef_story.html (dostęp: 6 IX 2022).
Sheth S., McConnell joked that Trump’s ex-secretary of state could deny calling Trump a ‘moron’ because he actually called him a ‘fucking moron’, „Business Insider”, 16 IX 2021, https://www.businessinsider.com/mcconnell-joked-about-tillerson-calling-trump-fucking-moron-book-2021-9?IR=T (dostęp: 12 IX 2022).
Taylor D., Class, sexism and surviving Trump’s White House. A ThinkIn with Fiona Hill, „tortoismedia.com”, 21 X 2021, https://www.tortoisemedia.com/thinkin/class-sexism-and-surviving-trumps-white-house-a-thinkin-with-fiona-hill/ (dostęp: 13 IX 2022).
Transcript: Donald Trump’s Foreign Policy Speech, „The New York Times”, 27 IV 2016, https://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/28/us/politics/transcript-trump-foreign-policy.html (dostęp 21 IX 2021).
Komentarze
Zaharna Rh.S., Trumping Traditional Public Diplomacy, USC Center on Public Diplomacy, https://uscpublicdiplomacy.org/blog/trumping-traditional-public-diplomacy (dostęp: 27 I 2021).
Raporty
Badger E., Americans Are Afraid. Not for Themselves, but for the Country, „The New York Times”, 1 XI 2020, https://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/01/upshot/election-democracy-fear-americans.html (dostęp: 17 I 2023).
Few Americans Express Positive Views of Trump’s Conduct in Office, „Pew Research Center”, 5 III 2020, https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2020/03/05/few-americans-express-positive-views-of-trumps-conduct-in-office/ (dostęp: 31 VIII 2022).
Funding NATO, North Atlantic Treaty Organization, NATO, 17 VIII 2022, https://www.nato. int/cps/en/natohq/topics_67655.htm (dostęp: 17 VIII 2022).
Karkoutli M., Fear Over the Outcome of the 2020 Election, https://www.chapman.edu/wilkinson/ research-centers/babbie-center/_files/fear-of-2020-election-blog-updated.pdf (dostęp: 17 I 2023).
Parker K., Morin R., Horowitz J.M., Looking to the Future, Public Sees an America in Decline on Many Fronts, „Pew Research Center’s Social & Demographic Trends Project”, 21 III 2019, https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2019/03/21/public-sees-an-america-in-decline-on-many-fronts/ (dostęp: 3 VIII 2022).
Public Highly Critical of State of Political Discourse in the U.S.: Reactions to Trump’s rhetoric: Concern, confusion, embarrassment, „Pew Research Center”, 19 VI 2019, https://www. pewresearch.org/politics/2019/06/19/public-highly-critical-of-state-of-political-discourse--in-the-u-s/#large-shares-have-negative-reactions-to-what-trump-says (dostęp: 17 I 2023).
Wike R., Poushter J., Fetterolf J., Schumacher Sh., Trump Ratings Remain Low Around Globe, While Views of U.S. Stay Mostly Favorable, „Pew Research Center’s Global Attitudes Project”, 8 I 2020, https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2020/01/08/trump-ratings-remain-low-around-globe-while-views-of-u-s-stay-mostly-favorable/ (dostęp: 22 VIII 2022).
Téléchargements
Publiée
Comment citer
Numéro
Rubrique
Licence
Ce travail est disponible sous licence Creative Commons Attribution - Pas de Modification 4.0 International.
Stats
Number of views and downloads: 22
Number of citations: 0
