Epistemic Contextualism and Positional Logic
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12775/szhf.2020.019Słowa kluczowe
epistemic contextualism, positional logic, Łoś’s realisation operator, relevant alternatives, epistemic logicAbstrakt
In the late 1940s, Jerzy Łoś published two works wherein he discussed logics with the realisation operator (later called positional logics). In these works, he investigated two interpretations of this operator: temporal and epistemic. In this article, we aim to develop and modify the epistemic interpretation so as to obtain a formalisation of epistemic contextualism, one of the most significant epistemological positions in contemporary times. According to this position, the logical value of epistemic sentences depends on contextually determined epistemic standards. We will demonstrate the advantage of such formalisation over previous attempts at the logical representation of epistemic contextualism.
Bibliografia
Baumann Peter. 2008. “Contextualism and the Factivity Problem”. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 76, 3: 580–602.
Brueckner Anthony, Christopher T. Buford. 2009. “Contextualism, SSI and the Factivity Problem”. Analysis 69, 3: 431–438.
Buckwalter Wesley. 2010. “Knowledge isn’t closed on Saturday: A study in ordinary language”. Review of Philosophy and Psychology 1, 3: 395–406.
Cappelen Herman, Ernie Lepore. 2003. “Context Shifting Arguments”. Philosophical Perspectives 17: 25–50.
Chellas Brian. 1975. “Basic conditional logic”. Journal of Philosophical Logic 4: 133–153.
Chemla Emmanuel, Nat Hansen. 2013. “Experimenting on contextualism”. Mind & Language 28, 3: 286–321.
Cohen Stewart. 1987. “Knowledge, context, and social standards”. Synthese 73, 1: 3–27.
Cohen Stewart. 1988. “How to be a fallibilist”. Philosophical Perspectives 2: 91–123.
Cohen Stewart. 2002. “Basic Knowledge and the Problem of Easy Knowledge”. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 65, 2: 309–329.
DeRose Keith. 1995. “Solving the sceptical problem”. The Philosophical Review 104, 1: 1–52.
DeRose Keith. 2009. The Case for Contextualism. Oxford: OUP.
DeRose Keith. 2017. The Appearance of Ignorance. Oxford: OUP.
Dretske Fred. 1970. “Epistemic operators”. The Journal of Philosophy 67, 24: 1007–1023.
Egan Andy, John Hawthorne, Brian Weatherson. 2005. “Epistemic modals in con-text”. In: Contextualism in Philosophy. Knowledge, Meaning, and Truth, eds. Gerhard Preyer, Peter Georg, 131–168. Oxford: OUP.
Goldman Alvin I. 1976. “Discrimination and Perceptual Knowledge”. The Journal of Philosophy 73, 20: 771–791.
Halliday Wesley H. 2012. “Epistemic logic, relevant alternatives, and the dynamics of context”. In: New Directions in Logic, Language and Computation, eds. Daniel Lassiter, Marija Slavkovik, 109–129. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer.
Hawthorne John. 2004. Knowledge and lotteries. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Hazlett Allan. 2010. “The Myth of Factive Verbs”. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 80, 3: 497–522.
Heller Mark. 1999. “The proper role for contextualism in an anti-luck epistemology”. Philosophical Perspectives 13: 115–129.
Hiż Henryk. 1951. “Review: J. Los, Foundations of the methodological analysis of Mill’s canons”. Journal of Symbolic Logic 16: 58–59.
Jarmużek Tomasz. 2007. “Minimal logical systems with R-operator: Their meta-logical properties and ways of extensions”. In: Perspectives on Universal Logic, eds. J. Bezieau, A. Costa-Leite, 319–333. Polimetrica Publisher.
Jarmużek Tomasz. 2018. On Sea Battle Tomorrow That May Not Happen. A Logical and Philosophical Analysis of the Master Argument. Berlin: Peter Lang.
Jarmużek Tomasz, Aleksander Parol. 2020. “On Some Language Extension of Logic MR: A Semantic and Tableau Approach”, Roczniki Filozoficzne 68: 345–366.
Jarmużek Tomasz, Andrzej Pietruszczak. 2004. “Completeness of minimal positional calculus”. Logic and Logical Philosophy 13: 147–162.
Jarmużek Tomasz, Marcin Tkaczyk. 2015. Normalne logiki pozycyjne (Normal Positional Logics). Lublin: Towarzystwo Naukowe KUL.
Jarmużek Tomasz, Marcin Tkaczyk. 2019. “Expressive power of positional operator R: A case study in modal logic and modal philosophy”. Ruch Filozoficzny LXXV, 2: 93–107.
Kallestrup Jesper. 2005. “Contextualism between Scepticism and Common-Sense”. Grazer Philosophische Studien 69: 247–253.
Klonowski Mateusz, Krzysztof A. Krawczyk. 2019. “Problem wszechwiedzy logicznej. Krytyka nienormalnych światów i propozycja nowego rozwiązania” (“The problem of logical omniscience. The critique of non-normal worlds and the proposition of new solution”). Filozofia Nauki 27, 1: 27–48.
Lasonen-Aarnio Maria. 2017. “Contextualism and closure”. In: The Routledge Handbook of Epistemic Contextualism, eds. Jonathan Jenkins Ichikawa, 156–167. London and New York: Routledge.
Lewis David. 1996. “Elusive knowledge”. Australasian Journal of Philosophy 74, 4: 549–567.
Lechniak Marek. 1988. “Logika epistemiczna Jerzego Łosia a teoria racjonalnego zachowania” (“Epistemic logic of Jerzy Łoś and the Theory of rational behaviour”). Roczniki Filozoficzne 26, 1: 79–91.
Lihoreau Franck, Manuel Rebuschi. 2014. “Reasoning about knowledge in context”. In: Interdisciplinary Works in Logic, Epistemology, Psychology and Linguistics. Dialogue, Rationality, and Formalism, eds. Manuel Rebuschi, Martine Batt, Gerhard Heinzmann, Franck Lihoreau, Michel Musiol, Alain Trognon, 155–179. Cham, Heidelberg, New York, Dordrecht, London: Springer.
Łoś Jerzy. 1947. “Podstawy analizy metodologicznej kanonów Milla” (“Basics of methodological analysis of Mill’s canons”). Annales Universitatis Mariae Curie-Skłodowska, 2.5. F: 269–301.
Łoś Jerzy. 1948. “Logiki wielowartościowe a formalizacja funkcji intensjonalnych” (“Multivalued logics and formalisation of intensional functions”). Kwartalnik Filozoficzny XVII, 1–2: 59–78.
MacFarlane John. 2005. “The assessment sensitivity of knowledge attributions”. In: Oxford Studies in Epistemology. Vol. 1, eds. Tamar Szabo Gendler, John Hawthorne, 197–233. Oxford: OUP.
MacFarlane John. 2014. Assessment Sensitivity: Relative Truth and its Applications. Oxford: OUP.
Malinowski Jacek, Krzysztof Pietrowicz, Joanna Szalacha-Jarmużek. 2020. “Logic of social ontology and Łoś’s operator”. Logic and Logical Philosophy 29: 239–258.
Palczewski Rafał. 2014. Wiedza w kontekstach. T. I: Między pragmatyką a semantyką. Toruń: Wydawnictwo Naukowe UMK.
Palczewski Rafał. 2015. “O aletycznej naturze wiedzy” (“On the Alethic Nature of Knowledge”). Filozofia Nauki 23, 1: 99–145.
Priest Graham. 2008. An Introduction to Non-Classical Logic. From If to Is. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Rebuschi Manuel, Franck Lihoreau. 2008. “Contextual epistemic logic”. In: Dialogues, Logics and Other Strange Things, eds. Cedric Degremont, Laurent Keiff, Helge Rueckert, 305–335. London: College Publications.
Rescher Nicholas. 1968. “Topological logic”. In: Nicolas Rescher, Topics in philosophical logic, Dordrecht: D. Reidel Publishing Company, 229–249.
Rescher Nicholas, Alasdair Urquhart. 1971. Temporal Logic. Vienna: Springer.
Schaffer Jonathan. 2004. “From contextualism to contrastivism”. Philosophical Studies 119, 1–2: 73–103.
Schaffer Jonathan. 2005. “Contrastive knowledge”. In: Oxford Studies in Epistemology. Vol. 1, eds. Tamar Szabo Gendler, John Hawthorne, 236–271. Oxford: OUP.
Scott Dana. 1970. “Advice on modal logic”. In: Philosophical Problems in Logic, ed. K. Lambert, 143–173. Dordrecht: Reidel.
Stanley Jason. 2005. Knowledge and Practical Interests. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Suszko Roman. 1949. “Review: Jerzy Łoś, Many-valued logics and formalisation of intensional functions”. Journal of Symbolic Logic 14: 64–65.
Tkaczyk Marcin. 2009. Logika czasu empirycznego (Logic of Physical Time). Lublin, Wydawnictwo KUL.
Tkaczyk Marcin, Tomasz Jarmużek. 2019. “Jerzy Łoś positional calculus and the origin of temporal logic”. Logic and Logical Philosophy 28: 259–276.
Tkaczyk Marcin. 2013. “Negation in weak positional calculi”. Logic and Logical Philosophy 22: 3–19.
Wright Georg von. 1951. An Essay in Modal Logic. Amsterdam, North-Holland Publishing Company.
Pobrania
Opublikowane
Jak cytować
Numer
Dział
Statystyki
Liczba wyświetleń i pobrań: 522
Liczba cytowań: 0