Tors in Central European Mountains – are they indicators of past environments?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.2478/bgeo-2019-0005Keywords
Tors, deep weathering, periglacial, glacial erosion, rock control, surface degradation, Central Europe, Bohemian MassifAbstract
Tors represent one of the most characteristic landforms in the uplands and mountains of Central Europe, including the Sudetes, Czech-Moravian Highlands, Šumava/Bayerischer Wald, Fichtelgebirge or Harz. These features occur in a range of lithologies, although granites and gneisses are particularly prone to tor formation. Various models of tor formation and development have been presented, and for each model the tors were thought to have evolved under specific environmental conditions. The two most common theories emphasised their progressive emergence from pre-Quaternary weathering mantles in a two-stage scenario, and their development across slopes under periglacial conditions in a one-stage scenario. More recently, tors have been analysed in relation to ice sheet extent, the selectivity of glacial erosion, and the preservation of landforms under ice. In this paper we describe tor distribution across Central Europe along with hypotheses relating to their formation and development, arguing that specific evolutionary histories are not supported by unequivocal evidence and that the scenarios presented were invariably model-driven. Several examples from the Sudetes are presented to demonstrate that tor morphology is strongly controlled by lithology and structure. The juxtaposition of tors of different types is not necessarily evidence that they differ in their mode of origin or age. Pathways of tor remodelling and degradation under subaerial conditions are identified and it is argued that processes of tor formation and development are ongoing. Thus, tors are not reliable indicators of past environments, because they are considerably influenced by both geological factors, such as lithology and structure, and geomorphological factors such as hillslope setting.References
ADAMOVIČ J., MIKULÁŠ R., CÍLEK V., 2010, Atlas pískovcových skalnych měst České a Slovenské republiky: Geologie a geomorfologie. Academia, Praha: 460.
ANDRÉ M.-F., 2004, The geomorphic impact of glaciers as indicated by tors in North Sweden (Aurivaara, 68° N). Geomorphology, 57: 403–421.
BADURA J., PRZYBYLSKI B., 1998, Zasięg lądolodów plejstoceńskich i deglacjacja obszaru między Sudetami a Wałem Śląskim. Biuletyn PIG, 385: 9–28.
BARTOŠÍKOVÁ H., 1973, Morfologicky výrazné výchozy Krkonošského žulového masívu. Opera Corcontica, 10: 71–91.
BAJER A., HLAVÁČ V., KIRCHNER K., KUBALÍKOVÁ L., 2014, Za skalními útvary CHKO Žďárské vrchy. Mendelova univerzita v Brně, Brno: 88.
BERG G., 1927, Zur Morphologie des Riesengebirges. Zeitschrift für Geomorphologie, 2: 1–20.
ČERNÁ B., 2011, Reconstruction of the continental glaciation in the northern slope of the Jizera Mts. Sborník geologických Věd, Antropozoikum, 27: 23–38.
CHÁBERA S., HUBER K. H., 1999, Beispiele kryogener Verwitterungs- und Abtragungsformen im Eisgarner Granit. Sborník Jihočeského muzea v Českých Budějovicích. Přírodní Vědy, 39: 5–17.
CÍLEK V., WILLIAMS R., OSBORNE A., MIGOŃ P., MIKULÁŠ R., 2007, The origin and development of sandstone landforms. [in:] Härtel H., Cílek V., Herben T., Jackson A., Williams R. (eds), Sandstone Landscapes. Academia, Praha: 34–43.
CUNNINGHAM F. F., 1965. Tor theories in the light of South Pennine evidence. East Midlands Geographer, 3: 423–433.
CZUDEK T., 1964, Periglacial slope development in the area of the Bohemian Massif in Northern Moravia, Biuletyn Peryglacjalny, 14: 169–193.
CZUDEK T., 2005, Vývoj reliéfu krajiny České republiky v kvartéru. Moravské zemské muzeum, Brno: 240.
CZUDEK T., DEMEK J., MARVAN P., PANOŠ V., RAUŠER J., 1964, Verwitterungs- und Abtragungsformen des Granits in der Böhmischen Masse. Petermanns Geographische Mitteilungen, 108: 182–192.
CZUDEK T., DEMEK J., 1970, Pleistocene cryopediments in Czechoslovakia. Acta Geographica Lodziensia, 24: 101–108.
CZUDEK T., DEMEK J., 1972, Present-day cryogenic processes in the mountains of eastern Siberia. Geogr. Polonica, 23: 5–20.
DARMODY R.G., THORN C.E., SEPPÄLÄ M., CAMPBELL S.W., LI Y.K, HARBOR J., 2008, Age and weathering status of granite tors in Arctic Finland (~68° N). Geomorphology, 94: 10–23.
DEMEK J., 1964a, Castle koppies and tors in the Bohemian Highland (Czechoslovakia). Biuletyn Peryglacjalny, 14: 195–216.
DEMEK J., 1964b, Slope development in granite areas of Bohemian Massif (Czechoslovakia). Zeitschrift für Geomorphologie NF, Supplement-Band, 5: 83–106.
DEMEK J., 1976, Peistocene continental glaciation and its effects on the relief of the northeastern part of the Bohemian Highlands. Studia Societatis Scientiarum Torunensis, Sect. C, 4–6: 63–74.
FRANZ H.-J., 1969, Die geomorphologische Bedeutung der Granitverwitterung in der Oberlausitz. Petermanns Geographische Mitteilungen, 113: 249–254.
GERRARD A.J., 1988, Rocks and Landforms. Unwin Hyman, London.
HALL A., 1986, Deep weathering patterns in north-east Scotland and their geomorphological significance. Zeitschrift für Geomorphologie, 30: 407–422.
HALL A.M., MIGOŃ P., 2010, The first stages of erosion by ice sheets: evidence from central Europe. Geomorphology, 123: 349–363.
HALL A.M, GILLESPIE M. R., THOMAS C. W., EBERT K., 2012, Scottish Landform Examples: The Cairngorms – A Pre-glacial Upland Granite Landscape. Scottish Geographical Journal, 129, 1: 2-14.
LAGALLY U., ROHRMÜLLER J., GLASER S., LOTH G., PÜRNER T., 2012, Hundert Meisterwerke. Die schönsten Geotope Bayerns. Bayerisches Landesamt für Umwelt, Augsburg: 288.
HUBER K.H., 1999, Zum Formenschatz der Granitverwitterung und Abtragung im nordwestlichen Waldviertel. [in:] Steininger F. F. (eds), Erdgeschichte des Waldviertels (2nd ed.), Waldviertler Heimatbund, Horn–Waidhofen/Thaya: 113–132.
IVAN A., 1983, Geomorfologické poměry Žulovské pahorkatiny. Zprávy GgÚ ČSAV, 20, 4: 49–69.
JAHN A., 1952, W sprawie wygładów lodowcowych w Sudetach. Czasopismo Geograficzne, 21/22: 360–366.
JAHN A., 1962, Geneza skałek granitowych. Czasopismo Geograficzne, 33: 19–40.
JAHN A., 1974, Granite tors in the Sudeten Mountains. [in:] Brown E.H., Waters R.S. (eds), Progress in Geomorphology. Institute British Geographers, Special Publication 7, London: 53–61.
KAJDAS B., MICHALIK M.J., MIGOŃ P., 2017, Mechanisms of granite alteration into grus, Karkonosze granite, SW Poland. Catena, 150: 230–245.
KASPRZAK M., DUSZYŃSKI F., JANCEWICZ K., MICHNIEWICZ A., RÓŻYCKA M., MIGOŃ P., 2016, The Rogowiec Landslide Complex (Central Sudetes, SW Poland) – a case of a collapsed mountain. Geological Quarterly, 60: 695–713.
KASPRZAK M., JANCEWICZ K., MICHNIEWICZ A., 2017, UAV and SfM in detailed geomorphological mapping of granite tors: an example of Starościńskie Skały (Sudetes, SW Poland). Pure and Applied Geophysics. DOI: doi.org/10.1007/s00024-017-1730-8
KING L.C., 1958, Correspondence. The problem of tors. Geographical Journal 124: 289–292.
KIRCHNER K., 2016a, The Dyje canyon-like valley: Geomorphological landscape of deep valley at the eastern part of the marginal slope of Bohemian Massif. [in:] Pánek T., Hradecký J. (eds), Landscapes and Landforms of the Czech Republic. Springer, Switzerland: 233–247.
KIRCHNER K., 2016b, Žd’árské Vrchy highland – Geomorphological landscape in the top part of the Bohemian-Moravian Highland with the unique crystalline rock forms. [in:] Pánek T., Hradecký J. (eds), Landscapes and Landforms of the Czech Republic. Springer, Switzerland: 221–231.
KŘÍŽEK M., TREML V., ENGEL Z., 2010, Czy najwyższe partie Sudetów powyżej górnej granicy lasu są domeną peryglacjalną? Czasopismo Geograficzne, 81: 75–102.
LAGEAT Y., LAGASQUIE J.-J., SIMON-COINCON R., 2001, Structural landforms in basement terrains. [in:] Godard A., Lagasquie J.-J., Lageat Y. (eds), Basement Regions. Springer, Heidelberg: 65–89.
LINTON D., 1955, The problems of tors. Geographical Journal, 121: 470–487.
MARTINI A., 1967, Preliminary experimental studies on frost weathering of certain types of rocks from the West Sudetes. Biuletyn Peryglacjalny, 16: 147–194.
MARTINI A., 1969, Sudetic tors formed under periglacial conditions. Biuletyn Peryglacjalny, 19: 351–369.
MARTINI A., 1979, Peryglacjalny charakter wierzchowiny Masywu Śnieżnika Kłodzkiego. Problemy Zagospodarowania Ziem Górskich, 20: 203–217.
MEINECKE F., 1957, Granitverwitterung, Entstehung und Alter der Granitklippen. Zeitschrift der Deutschen Geologischen Gesellschaft Band, 109: 483–498.
MENTLIK P., 2016. Bohemian Forest: landscape and people on the frontier. [in:] Pánek T., Hradecký J. (eds), Landscapes and Landforms of the of the Czech Republic. Springer, Switzerland: 87–100.
MICHNIEWICZ A., 2016, Skałki zieleńcowe grzbietu Okola w Górach Kaczawskich (Sudety Zachodnie). Chrońmy Przyrodę Ojczystą, 72: 206–218.
MICHNIEWICZ A., RÓŻYCKA M., MIGOŃ P., 2015, Granite tors of Waldviertel (Lower Austria) as sites of geotourist interest. Geoturystyka/Geotourism, 40–41: 19–36.
MICHNIEWICZ A., JANCEWICZ K., RÓŻYCKA M., MIGOŃ P., 2016, Rzeźba granitowego skalnego miasta Starościńskich Skał w Rudawach Janowickich (Sudety Zachodnie). Landform Analysis, 31: 17–33.
MIGOŃ P., 1993. Kopułowe wzgórza granitowe w Kotlinie Jeleniogórskiej. Czasopismo Geograficzne, 64: 3–23.
MIGOŃ P., 1996, Granite landscapes of the Sudetes Mountains – some problems of interpretation: a review. Proceedings of the Geologists’ Association, 107: 25–38.
MIGOŃ P., 1999, Residual weathering mantles and their bearing on long-term landscape evolution of the Sudetes. Zeitschrift für Geomorphologie N.F., Supplement-Band, 119: 71–90.
MIGOŃ P., 2006, Granite Landscapes of the World. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
MIGOŃ P., 2011, Geomorphic diversity of the Sudetes – Effects of global change and structure superimposed. Geographia Polonica, 84, Special Issue Part 2: 93–105.
MIGOŃ, P., 2013, Weathering mantles and long-term landform evolution. [in:] Shroder J. F. (eds), Treatise on Geomorphology, Volume 4, Weathering and Soils Geomorphology. Academic Press, San Diego, CA: 127–144.
MIGOŃ P., 2016, Jizerské hory – an interplay of rock control, faulting and inland glaciation in the evolution of a granite terrain. [in:] Pánek T., Hradecký J. (eds), Landscapes and Landforms of the of the Czech Republic. Springer, Switzerland: 165–175.
MIGOŃ P., PACZOS A., 2007, Rzeźba granitowa Königshainer Berge (Górne Łużyce). Przyroda Sudetów, 10: 205–228.
MIGOŃ P., PLACEK A., 2007, Rock control and geomorphology of a rocky sandstone scarp, Middle Sudetes Mountains, SW Poland. Zeitschrift für Geomorphologie N.F. 51, Supplement-Band, 1: 41–55.
MIGOŃ P., THOMAS M. F., 2002, Grus weathering mantles – problems of interpretation. Catena, 49: 5–24.
MIGOŃ P., MACIEJAK K., ZYGMUNT, M., 2002, Peryglacjalna rzeźba wzgórz bazaltowych Pogórza Kaczawskiego (Sudety Zachodnie) i jej znaczenie dla paleogeografii plejstocenu. Przegląd Geograficzny, 74: 491–508.
MIGOŃ P., RÓŻYCKA M., MICHNIEWICZ A., 2018, Conservation and geotourism perspectives at granite geoheritage Sites of Waldviertel, Austria. Geoheritage, 10, 1: 11–21.
MOSBRUGGER V., UTESCHER T., DILCHER D.L., 2005, Cenozoic continental climatic evolution of Central Europe. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 102: 14964–14969.
MOTYČKOVÁ H., MOTYČKOVÁ ŠÍROVÁ K., MOTYČKA V., ŠÍR J., 2012, Geologické zajímavosti České republiky. Academia, Praha: 363.
MUNROE J. S., FARRUGIA G., RYAN P.C., 2007, Parent material and chemical weathering in alpine soils on Mt. Mansfield, Vermont, USA. Catena, 70: 39–48.
NÝVLT D., 2003, Geomorphological aspects of glaciation in the Oldřichov Highland, Northern Bohemia, Czechia. Acta Universitatis Carolinae, Geographica, 35: 171–183.
OLLIER C. D., 2010, Very deep weathering and related landslides. [in:] Calcaterra D., Parise M. (eds), Geological Society, London, Engineering Geology Special Publications, 23: 5–14.
PALMER J. B. A., RADLEY J. M. A., 1961, Gritstone tors of the English Pennines. Zeitschrift für Geomorphologie N.F., 5: 37–52.
PILOUS V., 1992, Tvary zvětrávání a odnosu Vlčických a Zámeckých skal u Trutnova. Opera Corcontica, 27: 5–46.
PLACEK A., 2007, Rola zróżnicowania wytrzymałości skał w genezie rzeźby Masywu Ślęży (Przedgórze Sudeckie). Przegląd Geologiczny, 55: 861–869.
POPE G. A., 2013, Overview of Weathering and Soils Geomorphology. [in:] Shroder J. F. (eds), Treatise on Geomorphology, Volume 4, Weathering and Soils Geomorphology. Academic Press, San Diego, CA: 1–11.
PRÄGER F., 1987, Zum Alter der Gipfelklippen und Blockmeere im Lausitzer Bergland. Petermanns Geographische Mitteilungen, 131: 133–135.
PULLAN R.A., 1959, Tors. Scottish Geographical Magazine, 75: 51–55.
REA B. R., WHALLEY W. B., PORTER E. M., 1996, Rock weathering and the formation of summit blockfield slopes in Norway: Examples and implications. [in:] Anderson M. G., Brooks S. M. (eds), Advances in Hillslope Processes, Wiley, Chichester: 1257–1275.
REICHERTER K., FROITZHEIM N., JAROSIŃSKI M., BADURA J., FRANZKE H.-J., HANSEN M., HÜBSCHER C., MÜLLER R., POPRAWA P., REINECKER J., STACKENBRANDT W., VOIGT T., VON EYNATTEN H., ZUCHIEWICZ W., 2008, Alpine tectonics north of the Alps. [in:] McCann T. (eds), The Geology of Central Europe, Volume 2: Mesozoic and Cenozoic, Geological Society, London: 1233–1285.
RYPL J., KIRCHNER K., DVOŘÁČKOVÁ S., 2014, Geomorphological Inventory of Rock Landforms on Mt. Kamenec in the Novohradské Hory Mts. (The Czech Republic). Carpathian Journal of Earth and Environmental Sciences, 9: 253–260.
SELBY M.J., 1972, Antarctic tors. Zeitschrift für Geomorphologie N.F., Supplement-Band, 13, 73–86.
SOBCZYK A., 2005, Rzeźba skałkowa środkowej części Gór Złotych. Przyroda Sudetów 8, 147–162 (in Polish, with English summary).
ŠTĚPANČÍKOVÁ P., ROWBERRY M., 2008, Rock landforms that reflect differential relief development in the north-eastern sector of the Rychlebské hory and the adjacent area of Žulovská pahorkatina (SE Sudeten Mts, Czech Republic). Acta Geodynamica et Geomaterialia, 5, 151: 297–321.
SZCZEPANKIEWICZ S., 1958, Peryglacjalny rozwój stoków Masywu Ślęży. Biuletyn Peryglacjalny, 6: 81–92.
TAYLOR G., EGGLETON R. A., 2001, Regolith Geology and Geomorphology. John Wiley and Sons: 375.
THOMAS M. F., 1965, Some aspects of the geomorphology of domes and tors in Nigeria. Zeitschrift für Geomorphologie N.F., 9: 63–81.
THOMAS M. F., 1966, Some geomorphological implications of deep weathering patterns in crystalline rocks in Nigeria. Transactions Institute of British Geographers, 40: 173–193.
TRACZYK A., ENGEL Z., 2006, Maximální dosah kontinentálního zalednění na úpatí Ořešníku a Poledníku v severním svahu Jizerských hor. Geografie – Sbornik ČGS, 111: 141–151.
VĚŽNÍK A., 1982, Některé mezo- a mikroformy zvětrávání a odnosu žuly v Novobystřické vrchovině. Sborník Československé Společnosti Zeměpisné, 87: 13–22.
VÍTEK J., 1975, Kryogenní tvary v Orlických horách. Sborník Československé Společnosti Zeměpisné, 80: 184–192.
VÍTEK J., 1981a, Morfogenetická typizace pseudokrasu v Československu. Sborník Československé Společnosti Zeměpisné, 81: 153–165.
VÍTEK J., 1981b, Skalní hřiby v pískovcích Broumovské vrchoviny. Sborník Československé Společnosti Zeměpisné, 86: 8–18.
VÍTEK J., 2000, Tvary zvětrávání a odnosu fylonitu v Hrubém Jeseníku. Geografie – Sbornik ČGS, 105: 266–275.
VILÍMEK V., RAŠKA P., 2016, The Krušné Hory Mts. - the longest mountain range of the Czech Republic. [in:] Pánek T., Hradecký J. (eds), Landscapes and Landforms of the Czech Republic. Springer, Switzerland: 113–122.
VOTÝPKA J., 1964, Tvary zvětrávání a odnosu žuly v severní částí Novobystřické vrchoviny. Sborník Československé Společnosti Zeměpisné, 69: 243–258.
VOTÝPKA J., 1971, Ukazky zvětrávání žul Ceskeho masivu. Acta Universitatis Carolinae, Geographica, 2: 75–91.
VOTÝPKA J., 1974, Vznik a vývoj mezoreliéfu a mikroreliéfu Sedmioří. Acta Universitatis Carolinae, Geographica, 2: 17–34.
VOTÝPKA J., 1975, Kvartérní modelace zarovnaných povrchů masívu Plechého na Šumavě. Acta Universitatis Carolinae, Geographica, 1–2: 43–59.
VOTÝPKA J., 1976, Charakter udolni a erozni site severni casti Trojmezenské hornatiny. Acta Universitatis Carolinae, Geographica, 11, 2: 27–49.
VOTÝPKA J., 1979, Geomorfologie granitové oblasti masívu Plechého. Acta Universitatis Carolinae, Geographica, 16, 2: 55–83.
WALCZAK W., 1963, Geneza form skalnych na północno-wschodniej krawędzi Gór Stołowych. Acta Univ. Wratisl. 9, Stud. Geogr. 1: 191–200.
WILHELMY H., 1958, Klimamorphologie der Massengesteine. Westermann, Braunschweig: 238.
ŽÁK K., 2016. A landscape shaped in the periglacial zone of Quaternary glacials. [in:] Pánek T., Hradecký J. (eds), Landscapes and Landforms of the Czech Republic. Springer, Switzerland: 73–86.
ŻURAWEK R., MIGOŃ P., 1999, Peryglacjalna morfogeneza Ślęży w kontekście długotrwałej ewolucji rzeźby. Acta Geographica Lodziensia, 76: 133–155.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2019 Bulletin of Geography. Physical Geography Series
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Stats
Number of views and downloads: 530
Number of citations: 8
