A universal soil classification system from the perspective of the General Theory of Classification: a review

Aleksandra Aleksandrovna Nikiforova, Maria E. Fleis

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.2478/16091

Abstract


The paper addresses issues of the application of the General Theory of Classification in the development of a universal soil classification system. Requirements for such a system, the comparison of different approaches to its development, and obstacles on the way to it are outlined. Besides, the problem of the definition of soils and importance of distinguishing between differentiating and diagnostic criteria are discussed. It is shown that, from the perspective of the General Theory of Classification, a universal soil classification system should be natural, genetic, “fundamental-and-specific”, and hierarchical. It is concluded that the World Reference Base for Soil Resources (WRB) does not meet these requirements and therefore cannot be considered as universal. The ways of addressing the problems of a universal soil classification system are suggested.


Keywords


soil definition; essential character of soils; genetic classification; morphological classification; WRB

Full Text:

PDF

References


ABUSHENKO V.L., 1998, Classification, [in:] Gritsanov A.A. (ed.), The newest philosophical dictionary, V.M. Skakun Press, Minsk, 896 pp. (in Russian).

http://bookz.ru/authors/gricanov-aa/gricanov03/page-94-gricanov03.html

ARMAND D.L., 1975, Science on landscape: Foundations of the theory and logical-mathematical methods, Mysl, Moscow, 287 pp. (in Russian).

ARNOLD R.W., 2002, Soil classification principles, [in:] Micheli E., Nachtergaele F.O., Jones R.J.A., Montanarella L. (eds.), Soil Classification 2001. European Soil Bureau Research Report 7, EUR 20398 EN, Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg, 3-9.

AVERY B.W., 1965, Soil classification in Britain, Pedologie, Gand. numero spécial, 3, 75-90.

AVERY B.W., 1973, Soil classification in the soil survey of England and Wales, J. of Soil Sci., 24, 324-338.

BARUCK J., NESTROY O., SARTORI G., BAIZE D., TRAIDL R., VRŠČAJ B., BRÄM E., GRUBER F.E., HEINRICH K., GEITHER C., 2016, Soil classification and mapping in the Alps: The current state and future challenges, Geoderma, 264, B, 312-331.

BASHER L.R., 1997, Is pedology dead and buried? Aust. J. Soil Res., 35: 979-94.

BASINSKI J.J., 1959, The Russian approach to soil classification and its recent development, J. Soil Sci., 10, 14-26.

BEZUGLOVA O.S., 2009, Soil Classification, SFU Press, Rostov-on-Don, 128 pp. (in Russian).

BREVIK E.C., CALZOLARI C., MILLER B.A., PEREIRA , KABALA C., BAUMGARTEN A., JORDÁN A., 2016, Soil mapping, classification, and pedologic modeling: History and future directions, Geoderma, 264, B, 256-274.

CLINE M.G., 1949, Basic principles of soil classification, Soil Sci., 67, 81-91.

CLINE M.G., 1962, Logic of the new system of soil classification, Soil Sci., 96, 1, 17-22.

DE ВAKKER Н. 1970, Purposes of soil classification, Geoderma, 4, 195-208.

DOKUCHAEV V.V., 1879, Cartography of Russian soils, Typography of Kirshbaum, St. Petersburg. (in Russian).

DOKUCHAEV V.V., 1886, Key aspects in the history of land evaluation of the European Russia with classification of the Russian soils, Typography of E Evdokimov, St. Petersburg. (in Russian).

FRIDLAND V.M., 1979, Some key issues of soil classification, Pochvovedeniye, 7,112-123. (in Russian).

FRIDLAND V.M., 1986, Problems of geography, genesis and classification of soils, Nauka, Moscow, 243 pp. (in Russian).

GERASIMOVA M.I., KHITROV N.B., 2012, Comparison of the results of soil profiles diagnostics performed in three classification systems, Eurasian Soil Sci., 11, 1235-1243.

HARTEMINK A.E., 2015, The use of soil classification in journal papers between 1975 and 2014, Geoderma Reg, 5, 127–139.

HARRIS S.A., 1960, А new genetic classification of the major world soil groups, Trans. Intern. Congr. Soil Sci., Comm. V and VII, 7th, Madison, 4, 138-151.

HEMPEL J., MICHELI E., OWENS , MCBRATNEY A., 2013, Universal soil classification system report from the international union of soil sciences working group, Soil Horiz. 54 (2), 1-6.

HJØRLAND B., 2017, Classification. Encyclopedia of Knowledge Organization, ISKO. http://www.isko.org/cyclo/classification

IBÁÑEZ J.J., Boixadera J., 2002, The search for a new paradigm in pedology: A driving force for new approaches to soil classification, [in:] Micheli E., Nachtergaele F.O., Jones R.J.A., Montanarella L. (eds.), Soil Classification 2001. European Soil Bureau Research Report 7, EUR 20398 EN, Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg, 93-110.

IUSS Working Group WRB, 2015, World Reference Base for Soil Resources 2014, update 2015. International soil classification system for naming soils and creating legends for soil maps. World Soil Resources Reports No. 106. FAO, Rome, 192 pp.

JONES A., MONTANARELLA L., JONES R. (eds.), 2005, Soil Atlas of Europe, European Commission, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg.

KARPACHEVSKY L.O., 1981. Forest and forest soils, Lesnaya promyshlennost, Moscow, 264 pp. (in Russian).

KELLOGG С.Е., 1963, Why а new system of soil classification? Soil Sci., 96, 1-5.

KIRYUSHIN V.I., 2011, Soil classification and agroecological typology of lands, “Lan’” Press, St. Petersburg, 288 pp. (in Russian).

KOVDA V.A., LOBOVA Y.E., ROZANOV B.G., 1967, Problem of the classification of the world's soils: I, Pochvovedenie, 4, 427-441. (in Russian).

KRASILNIKOV , ARNOLD R., 2009, The United States Soil Taxonomy, [in:] Krasilnikov , Ibáñez J.J., Arnold R.W., Shoba S. (eds.), Soil Terminology, Correlation and Classification, Earthscan, London.

KRASILNIKOV , ARNOLD R.W., IBÁÑEZ J.J., 2010, Soil classifications: their origin, the state of the art and perspectives, 19th World Congress of Soil Science, Soil Solutions for a Changing World, 1–6 August 2010, Brisbane, Australia.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/255964346_Soil_classifications_Their_origin_the_state-of-the-art_and_perspectives

LEBEDEVA I.I., GERASIMOVA M.I., 2012, Diagnostic horizons in the Russian soil classification system, Eurasian Soil Sci., 45 (9), 823-833

MAMAY I.I., 2005, Dynamics and functioning of landscapes, MSU Press, Moscow (in Russian).

MANIL G., 1959, General considerations on the problem of soil classification, J. of Soil Sci., 10, 5-13.

MILLER B.A., Schaetzl R.J., 2016. History of soil geography in the context of scale, Geoderma, 264, B, 284-300.

MUIR J.W., 1962, The general principles of classification with reference to soils, J. Soil Sci. 13, 1, 22-30.

NACHTERGAELE F., BERDINK F.R., DECKERS J., 2002, Pondering hierarchical soil classification systems, [in:] Micheli E., Nachtergaele F.O., Jones R.J.A., Montanarella L. (eds.), Soil Classification 2001. European Soil Bureau Research Report 7, EUR 20398 EN, Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg, 71-79.

NIKIFOROVA A.A., FLEIS M.E., BORISOV M.M., 2014, Towards methodologies for global soil mapping, [in:] Arrouays D., McKenzie N., Hempel J., Richer de Forges A.C., McBratney A. (eds.), GlobalSoilMap: Basis of the global spatial soil information system, Proc. 1st GlobalSoilMap Conference, Orléans, France, 7-9 October 2013, CRC Press/Balkema, Leiden, 291-294.

POKROVSKY V., 2014, Introduction to classiology, Yekaterinburg, 484 pp. (in Russian).

ROZHKOV V.A., 2012, Classiology and soil classification, Eurasian Soil Sci., 45, 3, 221-230.

ROZOVA S.S., 1986, Problem of classification in modern science, Nauka, Siberian Branch, Novosibirsk, 194 pp. (in Russian).

SHISHOV L.L., TONKONOGOV V.D., LEBEDEVA I.I., GERASIMOVA, M.I., 2004, Classification and diagnostics of soils of Russia, Oykumena, Smolensk, 342 pp. (in Russian)

SCHELLING J., 1970, Soil genesis, soil classification and soil survey, Geoderma, 4, l65-193.

SMITH G.D., 1983, Historical development of Soil Taxonomy - background, [in:] Wilding L., Smeck N.E., Hall G.F. (eds.) Pedogenesis and Soil Taxonomy, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 23-49.

SOKAL R., 1974, Classification: purposes, principles, progress, prospects, Science, 185 (4157), 1115-1123.

SOKOLOV I.A., 1978, On a basic classification of soils, Pochvovedenie, 8, 113-123. (in Russian).

SOKOLOV I.A., 1991, Basic substantive-genetic soil classification, Pochvovedenie, 3, 107-121. (in Russian).

SUBBOTIN A.L., 2001, Classification, Inst. of Philosophy RAS, Moscow (in Russian). https://iphras.ru/uplfile/root/biblio/2001/Subbotin_1.pdf

VON BERTALANFFY L., 1968, General system theory: Foundations, development and applications, George Braziller, New York.








ISSN 2080-7686 (print)
ISSN 2300-8490 (online)

 

 

Partnerzy platformy czasopism