Quine’s criticism of the “First dogma of empiricism”

Pavel Materna

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.12775/LLP.2004.001


Quine’s argumentation is shown to be invalid since its conclusion would need one premise more; such a premise is shown to be false.

Full Text:



[Bolzano 1837] Bolzano, B.: Wissenschaftslehre I, Sulzbach.

[Carnap 1947] Carnap, R.: Meaning and Necessity, Chicago UP.

[Church 1956] Church, A.: Introduction to Mathematical Logic I, Princeton.

[Cresswell 1975] Cresswell, M.J.: “Hyperintensional Logic”, Studia Logica XXXIV, 1, pp. 25–38.

[Cresswell 1985] Cresswell, M.J.: Structured Meanings, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.

[Duží 2002] Duží, M.: Intensional Logic and the Irreducible Contrast between de dicto and de re. http://www.cs.vsb.cz/tech_reports/tr-2002-01.pdf

[Fletcher 1998] Fletcher, P.: Truth, Proof and Infinity, Kluwer AP, Dordrecht–Boston–London.

[Frege 1884] Frege, G.: Die Grundlagen der Arithmetik, W. Koebner, Jena.

[Materna 1998] Materna, P.: Concepts and Objects, Acta Philosophica Fennica 63, Helsinki.

[Materna, Duží 2003] Materna, P. and Duží, M.: “Parmenides Principle”. In: T. Childers, O. Majer, eds., The Logica Yearbook 2002, pp. 159–178.

[Moschovakis 1994] Moschovakis, Y.: “Sense and denotation as algorithm and value”. Postscript file, 39 pages. Published in Lecture Notes in Logic, 2 (1994), Springer J. Oikkonen and J. Vaananen (eds.), pp. 210–249.

[Quine 1953] Quine, W.V.O.: “Two Dogmas of Empiricism”. In: From a Logical Point of View, Harvard UP, Cambridge, Mass.

[Quine 1960] Quine, W.V.O.: Word and Object, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.

[Quine 1992] Quine, W.V.O.: Pursuit of Truth, Harvard UP, Cambridge, Mass., London.

[Tichý 1980]Tichý, P.: “The Logic of Temporal Discourse”, Linguistics and Philosophy3, pp. 343–369.

[Tichý 1988] Tichý, P.: The Foundations of Frege’s Logic, de Gruyter, Berlin, New York.

[Tichý 1996] Tichý, P.: “The Analysis of Natural Language”, From the Logical Point of View 2/94, pp. 42–80.

[Zalta 1988] Zalta, E.N.: Intensional Logic and the Metaphysics of Intentionality, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass., London.

[Zlatuška 1986] Zlatuška, J: “Data Bases and Lambda Calculus”. In: Proc. IFIP’86 World Computer Congress, Dublin, pp. 97–104.

ISSN: 1425-3305 (print version)

ISSN: 2300-9802 (electronic version)

Partnerzy platformy czasopism