Formal aspects of reduplication

Roberto Poli



Aristotle’s presentation of ontology advanced at the beginning of the fourth book of Metaphysics is universally known: “there is a science which studies being qua being...”. Needless to say, this is a familiar sentence: unfortunately, it is also quite an odd one. Why Aristotle does not simply say that ontology is the theory of being? Is there any difference between ‘theory of being’ and ‘theory of being qua being’?

In brief, the problem is to decide whether the two expressions ‘the study of being’ and ‘the study of being qua being’ are equivalent. If they are, the ‘qua’ does not play any interesting role. On the contrary, if the two expressions are different, that is to say, if there is a difference between the study of being (simpliciter) and the study of being qua being, we should study the role played by the (operator) ‘qua’.

Full Text:



Angelelli, “On identity and interchangeability in Leibniz and Frege”, Notre Dame Journal of Symbolic Logic, 94–100.

J. E. Annas, Aristotle’s Metaphysics, Books M and N, translated with introduction and notes, Oxford, Oxford University Press.

J. E. Annas, “Die Gegenstände der Mathematik bei Aristoteles”, in Gräser 1986, 131–147.

K. Fine, “Acts, events, and things”, in Leinfellner Krämer Schank 1982, 97–105.

Gräser (ed.), Mathematics and Metaphysics in Aristotle. Mathematik und Metaphysik bei Aristoteles, Bern-Stuttgart.

S. Knuuttila and J. Hintikka (eds.), The logic of being, Dordrecht•Boston•Lankaster•Tokyo, Reidel.

W. Leinfellner, E. Krämer and J. Schank (eds.), Language and ontology, Wien, Hlder•Pichler•Tempsky.

W. Leszl, Aristotle’s conception of ontology, Antenore, Padova.

J. Maritain, An introduction to logic, London.

B. Mates, “Identity and predication in Plato”, in Knuuttila Hintikka 1986, 29–47.

J. Perzanowski, “The way of truth”, in Poli Simons 1995.

R. Poli, “Qua-theories”, unpublished.

R. Poli, “A first sight to Aristotle’s theory of reduplication”, in preparation.

R. Poli, P. Simons (eds.), Formal ontology, Dordrecht, Kluwer, 1995.

ISSN: 1425-3305 (print version)

ISSN: 2300-9802 (electronic version)

Partnerzy platformy czasopism