The impact assessment of thermal pollution on subtidal sessile assemblages: a case study from Mediterranean rocky reefs

Stanislao Bevilacqua, Samsa Clara, Antonio Terlizzi



Coastal power plants generally use seawater as cooling fluid, discharging heated waters into the sea after the cooling process. The ensuing increase in seawater temperature could affect the marine biota in the nearby areas, causing alterations at different level of biological organization, from individuals to populations and assemblages. In the Mediterranean Sea, few attempts have been made to assess the effects of this point sources of thermal pollution, especially on rocky habitats. Here, we investigated the putative impact of a thermal effluent from one of the largest European coal-fired coastal power plants on sessile assemblages of subtidal rocky reefs. Sessile assemblages on rocky substrates were photographically sampled at one location near the effluent (I), and at two control locations (Cs) virtually unaffected by thermal discharge. An asymmetrical after-control impact experimental design was employed to test the hypothesis that the thermal discharge significantly modified sessile assemblages at I if compared to Cs. We detected significant differences in assemblages at I versus Cs, indicating a clear effect of the effluent on assemblage structure. Such differences were mostly due to shift in dominance among macroalgae between I and Cs, which likely depended on different tolerance limits of species to increased seawater temperature and other sources of disturbance associated to the effluent, such as increased sedimentation rates and water turbidity. Our findings stressed the need for further investigations of the impact of thermal effluents on marine communities, considering the potential synergistic effects of climate change especially in the Mediterranean Sea.


Asymmetrical design; climate change; coal-fired power plants; macrobenthos; thermal effluents

Full Text:



Airoldi L., 1998, Roles of disturbance, sediment stress, and substratum retention on spatial dominance in algal turf, Ecology 79: 2759–2770.

Anderson M.J., 2001, A new method for non-parametric multivariate analysis of variance, Austral Ecology 26: 32–46.

Anderson M.J., Gorley R.N., Clarke K.R., 2008, PERMANOVA+ for PRIMER: guide to software and statistical methods. PRIMER-E, Plymouth, UK.

Arieli R.N., Almogi-Labin A., Abramovich S., Herut B., 2011, The effect of thermal pollution on benthic foraminiferal assemblages in the Mediterranean shoreface adjacent to Hadera power plant (Israel), Marine Pollution Bulletin 62: 1002–1012.

Baker P., Fajans J.S., Arnold W.S., Ingrao D.A., Marell D.C., Baker S.M., 2007, Range and dispersal of a tropical marine invader, the asian green mussel, Perna viridis, in subtropical waters of the southeastern United States, Journal of Shellifish Research 26: 345–355.

Bamber R.N., 1990, Power station thermal effluents and marine crustaceans, Journal of Thermal Biology 15: 91–96.

Barnett P.R.O., 1972, Effects of Warm Water Effluents from Power Stations on Marine Life, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences 180: 497–509.

Bevilacqua S., Katsanevakis S., Micheli F., Sala E., Rilov G., Sarà G., Malak D.A., Abdulla A., Gerovasileiou V., Gissi E., Mazaris A.D., Pipitone C., Sini M., Stelzenmüller V., Terlizzi A., Todorova V., Fraschetti S., 2020, The status of coastal benthic ecosystems in the Mediterranean Sea: Evidence from ecological indicators. Frontiers in Marine Science 7: 475.

Bevilacqua S., Savonitto G., Lipizer M., Mancuso P., Ciriaco S., Srijemsi M., Falace A., 2019, Climatic anomalies may create a long‐lasting ecological phase shift by altering the reproduction of a foundation species, Ecology 100: e02838.

Bray J.R., Curtis J.T., 1957, An ordination of the upland forest communities of Southern Wisconsin, Ecological Monographs 27: 325–349.

Bush R.M., Welch E.B., Mar B.W., 1974, Potential effects of thermal discharges on aquatic systems, Environmental Science and Technology 6: 561–568.

Choi D.H., Park J.S., Hwang C.Y., Huh S.H., Cho B.C., 2002, Effects of thermal effluents from a power station on bacteria and heterotrophic nanoflagellates in coastal waters, Marine Ecology Progress Series 229: 1–10.

Choi H.-G., 2008, Effects of thermal effluents from Wolseong nuclear power plant on macroalgal composition and community structure, Algae 23: 151–162.

Clarke K.R., 1993, Nonparametric multivariate analyses of changes in community structure, Australian Journal of Ecology 18: 117–143.

Clarke K.R., Gorley R.N., 2015, PRIMER version 7: User manual/tutorial, PRIMER-E, Plymouth, UK.

Crema R., Bonvicini Pagliai A.M., 1980, The structure of benthic communities in an area of thermal discharge from a coastal power station, Marine Pollution Bulletin 11: 221–224.

Deabes E.A.M., 2020, The impact of thermal power stations on coastline and benthic fauna: Case study of El-Burullus power plant in Egypt, Results in Engineering 7: 100128.

Dethier M.N., Graham E.S., Cohen S., Tear L.M., 1993, Visual versus random-point percent cover estimation: ‘objective’ is not always better, Marine Ecology Progress Series 96: 93–100.

Dijkstra J.A., Litterer A., Mello K., O'Brien B.S., Rzhanov Y., 2019, Temperature, phenology, and turf macroalgae drive seascape change: Connections to mid‐trophic level species. Ecosphere 10: e02923.

Fairweather P.G., 1991, Statistical power and design requirements for environmental monitoring, Australian Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 42: 555–568.

Flagella M.M, Lorenti M., Buia M.C., 2008, Temperature response in a shallow-water Mediterranean population of Caulerpa racemosa var. cylindracea (Caulerpales, Chlorophyta), and a possible strategy of season anticipation, Botanica Marina 51: 278–284.

Gaeta M.G., Samaras A.G., Archetti R., 2020, Numerical investigation of thermal discharge to coastal areas: A case study in South Italy. Environmental Modelling & Software 124: 104596.

Givan O., Edelist D., Sonin O., Belmaker J., 2018, Thermal affinity as the dominant factor changing Mediterranean fish abundances, Global Change Biology 24: 80–89.

Gray J.S., 1990, Statistics and the precautionary principle, Marine Pollution Bulletin 21:174–176.

Guarnieri G., Fraschetti S., Bogi C., Galil B.S., 2017, A hazardous place to live: spatial and temporal patterns of species introduction in a hot spot of biological invasions, Biological Invasion 19: 2277–2290.

Harvey B.P., Gwynn‐Jones D., Moore P.J., 2013, Meta‐analysis reveals complex marine biological responses to the interactive effects of ocean acidification and warming, Ecology and Evolution 3: 1016–1030.

Jiang Z., Zeng J., Chen Q., Huang Y., Xu X., Liao Y., Shou L., Liu J., 2009, Tolerance of copepods to short-term thermal stress caused by coastal power stations, Journal of Thermal Biology 33: 419–423.

Johnson M.D., Comeau S., Lantz C.A., Smith J.E., 2017, Complex and interactive effects of ocean acidification and temperature on epilithic and endolithic coral-reef turf algal assemblages. Coral Reefs 36: 1059–1070.

Katsanevakis S., Coll M., Piroddi C., Steenbeek J., Ben Rais Lasram F., Zenetos A., Cardoso A.C., 2014, Invading the Mediterranean Sea: biodiversity patterns shaped by human activities, Frontiers in Marine Science 1: 1–11.

Kim H.-G., Rho H.-S., Oh C.-W., 2013, Seasonal and spatial variations in nematode assemblages affected by thermal influence of nuclear power plant in Korea (East Sea, Pacific Ocean), Marine Biology Research 9: 725–738.

Langford T.E., 1990, Ecological Effects of Thermal Discharges, Elsevier, pp. 468.

Lejeusne C., Chevaldonné P., Pergent-Martini C., Boudouresque C.F., Pérez T., 2010, Climate change effects on a miniature ocean: the highly diverse, highly impacted Mediterranean Sea. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 25: 250–260.

Lin J., Zou X., Huang F., 2017, Effects of the thermal discharge from an offshore power plant on plankton and macrobenthic communities in subtropical China, Marine Pollution Bulletin 131: 106–114.

Lukšienė D., Sandström O., Lounasheimo L., Andersson J., 2000, The effects of thermal effluent exposure on the gametogenesis of female fish, Journal of Fish Biology 56: 37–50.

Mannino A., Balistreri P., Deidun A., 2017, The Marine Biodiversity of the Mediterranean Sea in a Changing Climate: The Impact of Biological Invasions, [in:] Mediterranean Identities - Environment, Society, Culture, F.-B. Borna (ed.), Intech Open, London.

Marano G., De Zio V., Pastorelli A.M., Rizzi E., Rositani L., Ungaro N., 2000, Effects of thermal discharge on marine ecosystems. A case study from a coastal power station in Southern Italy, Oebalia 26: 15–36.

Micheli F., Halpern B.S., Walbridge S., Ciriaco S., Ferretti F., Fraschetti S., Lewison R., Nykjaer L., Rosenberg A.A., 2013, Cumulative human impacts on Mediterranean and Black Sea, marine ecosystems: Assessing current pressures and opportunities. PLoS ONE 8: e79889.

Rilov G., Galil B., 2009, Marine bioinvasions in the Mediterranean Sea–history, distribution and ecology, [in:] Biological Invasions in Marine Ecosystems, G. Rilov & A.C. Crooks (eds), Springer, Berlin: 549–575.

Rivetti I., Fraschetti S., Lionello P., Zambianchi E., Boero F., 2014, Global warming and mass mortalities of benthic invertebrates in the Mediterranean Sea, PLoS ONE 9: e115655.

Roberts D.E., Fitzhenry S.R., Kennelly S.J., 1994, Quantifying subtidal macrobenthic assemblages on hard substrata using a jump camera method, Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 177: 157–170.

Sala E., Kizilkaya Z., Yildirim D., Ballesteros E., 2011, Alien marine fishes deplete algal biomass in the eastern Mediterranean. PLoS ONE 6: e17356.

Samperio-Ramos G., Olsen Y.S., Tomas F., Marbà N., 2015, Ecophysiological responses of three Mediterranean invasive seaweeds (Acrothamnion preissii, Lophocladia lallemandii and Caulerpa cylindracea) to experimental warming, Marine Pollution Bulletin 96: 418–423.

Sanford E., 1999, Regulation of keystone predation by small changes in ocean temperature, Science 283: 2095–2097.

Savva I., Bennett S., Roca G., Jordà G., Marbà N., 2018, Thermal tolerance of Mediterranean marine macrophytes: Vulnerability to global warming, Ecology and Evolution 8: 12032–12043.

Strain E.M.A., Thomson R.J., Micheli F., Mancuso F.P., Airoldi L., 2014, Identifying the interacting roles of stressors in driving the global loss of canopy forming to mat-forming algae in marine ecosystems. Global Change Biology 20: 3300–3312.

Sylvester J.R., 1970, Possible effects of thermal effluents on fish: A review, Environmental Pollution 3: 205–215.

Teixeira T.P., Neves L.M., Araújo F.G., 2009, Effects of a nuclear power plant thermal discharge on habitat complexity and fish community structure in Ilha Grande Bay, Brazil, Marine Environmental Research 68: 188–195.

Teixeira T.P., Neves L.M., Araújo F.G., 2012, Thermal impact of a nuclear power plant in a coastal area in Southeastern Brazil: effects of heating and physical structure on benthic cover and fish communities, Hydrobiologia 684: 161–175.

Terlizzi A., Benedetti-Cecchi L., Bevilacqua S., Fraschetti S., Guidetti P., Anderson M.J., 2005, Multivariate and univariate asymmetrical analyses in environmental impact assessment: a case study of Mediterranean subtidal sessile assemblages, Marine Ecology Progress Series 289: 27–42.

Underwood A.J., 1994, On beyond BACI: sampling designs that might reliably detect environmental disturbances, Ecological Applications 4: 3–15.

Underwood A.J., 1997, Experiments in ecology: their logical design and interpretation using analysis of variances. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Walther G.-R., Roques A., Hulme P.E., Sykes M.T., Pyšek P., Kühn I., Zobel M., Bacher S., Botta-Dukát Z., Bugmann H., Czúcz B., Dauber J., Hickler T., Jarošík V., Kenis M., Klotz S., Minchin D., Moora M., Nentwig W., Ott J., Panov V.E., Reineking B., Robinet C., Semenchenko V., Solarz W., Thuiller W., Vilà M., Vohland K., Settele J., 2009, Alien species in a warmer world: risks and opportunities, Trends in Ecology and Evolution 24: 686–693.

White D.P., Wahl D.H., 2020, Growth and physiological responses in largemouth bass populations to environmental warming: Effects of inhabiting chronically heated environments, Journal of Thermal Biology 88: 102467.

Wolf M.A., Sfriso A., Moro I., 2014, Thermal pollution and settlement of new tropical alien species: The case of Grateloupia yinggehaiensis (Rhodophyta) in the Venice Lagoon, Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science 147: 11–16.

World Power Plant Database, 2020, Accessed Septembe, 20, 2020.

Yeruham E., Shpigel M., Abelson A., Rilov G., 2020, Ocean warming and tropical invaders erode the performance of a key herbivore, Ecology 101: e02925.

Partnerzy platformy czasopism