Causal Connectivity, Genidentity and the Ontology of Point-Eventism

Maciej Raźniak

doi:10.12775/LLP.2025.026

Authors

Maciej Raźniak Doctoral School of Humanities, University of Warsaw https://orcid.org/0009-0000-3412-1132

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.12775/LLP.2025.026

Keywords

philosophy of physics, philosophy of space-time, point-eventism, general theory of relativity, special theory of relativity, ontology, causation

Abstract

The concept of a causally connected set of point-events plays a crucial role in the point-eventistic definitions of a thing and a process formulated by Zdzisław Augustynek. Unfortunately, Augustynek’s approach to causal connectivity is open to a serious objection that has so far gone unnoticed, stemming from the way causal interactions are viewed in contemporary physics. This finding can hardly be considered favorable for an advocate of the ontology of point-eventism. The aim of this paper is, therefore, firstly, to discuss this objection in detail and, secondly, to share some ideas on how to deal with the problem.

References

Augustynek, Z., 1981, “Genidentity”, Dialectics and Humanism, 8 (1): 193–202. DOI: CrossRef

Augustynek, Z., 1991, “Point-Eventism. Appendix”, pages 120–127 in Time: Past, Present, Future, Dordrecht/Warszawa: Kluwer and Państwowe Wydawnictwo Naukowe. DOI: CrossRef

Augustynek, Z., 1993a, “Eventism and pointism”, Logic and Logical Philosophy, 1: 157–169. DOI: CrossRef

Augustynek, Z., 1993b, “Point Eventism. An Outline of a Certain Ontology”, pages 15–100 in Z. Augustynek and J. J. Jadacki (eds.), Possible Ontologies, Amsterdam/Atlanta: Rodopi.

Augustynek, Z., 1997, “Substancja  przyczynowość  przestrzeń  czas”, pages 99–111 in Czasoprzestrzeń. Eseje filozoficzne, Warszawa: Wydział Filozofii i Socjologii UW.

Davidson, D., 1980, “The Individuation of Events”, pages 163–180 in Essays on Action and Events, Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Earman, J., 1972, “Notes on the Causal Theory of Time”, Synthese, 24 (1–2): 74–86. DOI: CrossRef

Eddington, A., 1923, The Mathematical Theory of Relativity, London: Cambridge University Press.

Grygianiec, M., 2005, “Analiza krytyczna pojęcia rzeczy w ontologii ewentyzmu punktowego”, Przegląd Filozoficzny – Nowa Seria, 14 (1): 107–120.

Grygianiec, M., 2006, “Przeciw ewentyzmowi punktowemu. W hołdzie Profesorowi Zdzisławowi Augustynkowi”, Filozofia Nauki, 14 (4): 35–48.

Grygianiec, M., 2008, “Simultaneity, Transitivity, and the Punctual Nature of Events”, pages 73–83 in J. Odrowąż-Sypniewska (eds.), Logic, Methodology and Philosophy of Science at Warsaw University IV, Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Naukowe Semper.

Grygianiec, M., 2011, “Ewentystyczna definicja rzeczy w świetle argumentu Adriana Kuźniara”, Filozofia Nauki 19 (1): 53–56.

Grünbaum, A., 1973, Philosophical Problems of Space and Time, Dordrecht/Boston: Reidel Publishing Company. DOI: CrossRef

Hoy, R. C., 1975, “The Role of Genidentity in the Causal Theory of Time”, Philosophy of Science 42 (1): 11–19. DOI: CrossRef

Mehlberg, H., 1980, Time, Causality, and the Quantum Theory. Studies on the Philosophy of Science. Vol. I: Essay on the Causal Theory of Time, Dordrecht/Boston/London: Reidel Publishing Company. DOI: CrossRef

Lacey, H. M., 1968, “The Causal Theory of Time: A Critique of Grünbaum’s Version”, Philosophy of Science 35 (4): 332–354. DOI: CrossRef

Palter, R., 1955, “On the Significance of Space-Time”, The Review of Metaphysics 9 (1): 149–155.

Porwolik, M., 2017a, “Aksjomatyczne ujęcia genidentyczności według Zdzisława Augustynka. Część I. Porównanie systemów”, Filozofia Nauki 25(3): 5–40.

Porwolik, M., 2017b, “Aksjomatyczne ujęcia genidentyczności według Zdzisława Augustynka. Część II. Definicje warunkowe”, Filozofia Nauki 25(4): 87–114.

Quine, W. v. O., 1985, “Events and Reification”, pages 162–171 in E. LePore and B.P. McLaughlin (eds.), Actions and Events. Perspectives in the Philosophy of Donald Davidson, Oxford/New York: Basil Blackwell.

Raźniak, M., 2025, “Koincydensy”, Filozofia i Nauka. Studia filozoficzne i interdyscyplinarne 13: 55–80. DOI: CrossRef

Reichenbach, H., 1958, Philosophy of Space and Time, New York: Dover Publications.

Russell, B., 1903, Principles of Mathematics, London: G. Allen and Unwin.

Russell, B., 1912, “On the Notion of Cause”, Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 13: 1–26. DOI: CrossRef

Sklar, L., 1974, Space, Time, and Spacetime, Berkeley/Los Angeles/London: University of California Press.

Smart, J. J. C., 1969, “Causal Theories of Time”, The Monist 53 (3): 385–395. DOI: CrossRef

van Fraassen, B. C., 1970, An Introduction to the Philosophy of Time and Space, New York: Random House.

Wolniewicz, B., 2018, “Krótki komentarz do ewentyzmu punktowego”, pages 117–119 in Filozofia i wartości II, Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Warszawskiego.

Żabski, E., 2008, “Notka o paradoksie statku Tezeusza oraz identyczności genetycznej”, Filozofia Nauki 16 (1): 75–82.