A Real Brain Twister, or, How to Outline the Evolution of the Concept of Nation between the Enlightenment and the Year 1939?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12775/APH.2020.122.01Keywords
conceptual history, concept of nation, political nation, ethnic nation, historical nation, nationalityAbstract
Most historians studying the evolution of the concept of nation and national idea in East Central Europe, assume that through the nineteenth century the political meaning was gradually giving place to the ethnic understanding of ‘nation’. Without radically questioning this evolution of the meaning, I would like to stress that it is far from obvious. Starting with the Enlightenment, the term and concept of ‘nation’ were used so widely in the Polish public debates that it is relatively easy to find quotations to support any generalisation. Any decision about choosing some source materials and discarding some others is inevitably grounded in certain methodological and philosophical assumptions. Some assumptions have to be accepted (for otherwise, a historian would not be able to say anything), but we need to be conscious that their choice is, in the last resort, arbitrary.
References
Bujak Franciszek, Galicja, i: Kraj. Ludność. Społeczeństwo. Rolnictwo (Lwów–Warszawa, 1908), [reprinted:] Rzeszów, 2014).
Górka Olgierd, Naród a państwo jako zagadnienie Polski (Warszawa, 1937).
Grześkowiak-Krwawicz Anna, Dyskurs polityczny Rzeczypospolitej Obojga Narodów. Pojęcia i idee (Toruń 2018); English version: The Political Discourse of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth: Concepts and Ideas (New York, 2020).
Handelsman Marceli, Historyka, ed. by Piotr Węcowski (Warszawa, 2010).
Handelsman Marceli, Rozwój narodowości nowoczesnej (Warszawa, 1973).
Snitko I. [Herburt-Heybowicz Stanisław], Zarys pojęć o narodzie (Lwów, 1901).
Kizwalter Tomasz, O nowoczesności narodu. Przypadek Polski (Warszawa, 1999).
Konopczyński Władysław, Historyka, ed. by Maciej Janowski (Warszawa, 2015).
Serejski Marian Henryk, Naród a państwo w polskiej myśli historycznej (Warszawa, 1973).
Szczepanowski Stanisław, Idea polska. Wybór pism, ed. by Stanisław Borzym (Warszawa, 1988).
Szűcs Jenő, ‘Nationalität und Nationalbewusstsein im Mittelalter’, in id., Nation und Geschichte. Studien (Budapest, 1981).
Walicki Andrzej, Philosophy and Romantic Nationalism. The Case of Poland (Notre Dame, 1994).
Zientara Benedykt, ‘Korzenie nowoczesnego narodu’, Kwartalnik Historyczny, xc, 1 (1983), 184–98.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Title, logo and layout of journal are reserved trademarks of APH.Stats
Number of views and downloads: 388
Number of citations: 0