Comparative Analysis of Shooting Consistency Among Archers of Different Skill Levels
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12775/QS.2024.36.56935Keywords
Archery, Shooting Consistency, Kinematic, EMGAbstract
Purpose: This study aimed to investigate the biomechanical and electromyographic factors underlying shooting consistency among archers of different skill levels, providing insights into performance optimization and training strategies. Methods: The study analyzed 28 left-handed archers, including elite, mid-level, and novice athletes. Using an eight-camera infrared motion capture system and a wireless surface EMG system, kinematic and muscle activity data were collected for key upper limb muscles during two action phases: drawing and aiming. Coefficients of variation (CV) were calculated for both kinematic and EMG parameters, and statistical analysis was conducted to compare the groups. Results: Elite and mid-level archers exhibited significantly lower CVs in key kinematic parameters (e.g., shoulder abduction) and muscle activation consistency during the drawing phase compared to novices. Differences in muscle activation were most pronounced in the flexor muscle groups. These findings highlight the critical role of movement consistency in archery performance. Conclusion: Greater consistency in kinematic and muscle activation patterns distinguishes higher-skilled archers, particularly during the drawing phase. These results emphasize the importance of targeting movement consistency and coordination in training programs to enhance performance in precision sports like archery.
References
BAIFA Z, XINGLONG Z, DONGMEI L, 2023. Muscle coordination during archery shooting: A comparison of archers with different skill levels [J]. European Journal Of Sport Science, 23(1): 54-61.
BURGER B, WOLLNER C, 2021. The challenge of being slow: Effects of tempo, laterality, and experience on dance movement consistency [J]. Journal of Motor Behavior, 2021(8): 1-14.
ERTAN H, SOYLU A, KORKUSUZ F, 2005a. Quantification the relationship between FITA scores and EMG skill indexes in archery [J]. Journal Of Electromyography And Kinesiology, 15(2): 222-227.
ERTAN H, KNICKER A, SOYLU R, et al., 2011. Individual variation of bowstring release in high level archery: a comparative case study [J]. Human Movement, 12(3): 273-276.
GLANZER J A, DIFFENDAFFER A Z, SLOWIK J S, et al., 2019. The relationship between variability in baseball pitching kinematics and consistency in pitch location [J]. Sports Biomechanics, 20(7): 879-886.
LATASH M L, 2012. The bliss (not the problem) of motor abundance (not redundancy) [J]. Experimental Brain Research, 217(1): 1-5.
NISHIZONO H, SHIBAYAMA H, IZUTA T, et al., 1987. Analysis of archery shooting techniques by means of electromyography [C] //5 International Symposium on Biomechanics in Sports.364-372.
QUAN C-H, MOHY-UD-DIN Z, LEE S, 2017. Analysis of Shooting Consistency in Archers: A Dynamic Time Warping Algorithm‐Based Approach [J]. Journal of Sensors, 2017(1): 7471217.
RAB G, PETUSKEY K, BAGLEY A, 2002. A method for determination of upper extremity kinematics [J]. Gait & posture, 15(2): 113-119.
SOYLU A, ERTAN H, KORKUSUZ F, 2006a. Archery performance level and repeatability of event-related EMG [J]. Human Movement Science, 25(6): 767-774.
STUART J, ATHA J, 1990. Postural consistency in skilled archers [J]. Journal Of Sports Sciences, 8(3): 223-234.
WHITESIDE D, MARTINI D N, ZERNICKE R F, et al., 2016. BALL SPEED AND RELEASE CONSISTENCY PREDICT PITCHING SUCCESS IN MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL [J]. Journal Of Strength And Conditioning Research, 30(7): 1787-1795.
ZHANG X, SHAN G, 2014. Where do golf driver swings go wrong? Factors influencing driver swing consistency [J]. Scandinavian Journal Of Medicine & Science In Sports, 24(5): 749-757.
CLARYS J P, CABRI J, BOLLENS E, et al., 1990. Muscular activity of different shooting distances, different release techniques, and different performance levels, with and without stabilizers, in target archery [J]. Journal Of Sports Sciences, 8(3): 235-257.
ERTAN H, KENTEL B, TUMER S T, et al., 2003. Activation patterns in forearm muscles during archery shooting [J]. Human Movement Science, 22(1): 37-45.
ERTAN H, SOYLU A R, KORKUSUZ F, 2005b. Quantification the relationship between FITA scores and EMG skill indexes in archery [J]. Journal Of Electromyography And Kinesiology, 15(2): 222-227.
ERTAN H, 2009. Muscular activation patterns of the bow arm in recurve archery [J]. Journal Of Science And Medicine In Sport, 12(3): 357-360.
LEROYER P, VAN HOECKE J, HELAL J N, 1993. Biomechanical study of the final push-pull in archery [J]. Journal Of Sports Sciences, 11(1): 63-69.
NEWELL K M, RANGANATHAN R, 2009. Some Contemporary Issues in Motor Learning [M] //D. STERNAD, Progress in Motor Control: A Multidisciplinary Perspective. Springer; New York: 395-404.
PREATONI E, HAMILL J, HARRISON A J, et al., 2013. Movement variability and skills monitoring in sports [J]. Sports Biomechanics, 12(2): 69-92.
SHINOHARA H, URABE Y, 2018. Analysis of muscular activity in archery: a comparison of skill level [J]. Journal Of Sports Medicine And Physical Fitness, 58(12): 1752-1758.
SOYLU A R, ERTAN H, KORKUSUZ F, 2006b. Archery performance level and repeatability of event-related EMG [J]. Human Movement Science, 25(6): 767-774.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Baifa Zhang, Zhi-Cheng Lin
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Stats
Number of views and downloads: 79
Number of citations: 0