Black Mirror: A Comparative History of Polish and American Failures
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12775/APH.2021.123.05Keywords
January Uprising, Poland, American Civil War, memory, gender stereotypes, nationalism, guerrilla warfareAbstract
Even though they occurred around the same time, the Polish January Uprising of 1863/64 and the American Civil War (1861–5) have seldom been considered in the same context by historians, while comparative historical studies of the events are scarce. The present article explores the historiography relating to both countries to, firstly, outline the most interesting attempts in existing Polish and US-American research to find shared aspects in the two events. Secondly, my study establishes and analyses phenomena and themes in these parallel histories that could prove most fruitful for comparative investigation. In conclusion, I assess the potential that comparative approaches could generate for the historiography of the American Civil War and the January Uprising.
References
Blight David W., Race and Reunion: The Civil War in American Memory (Cambridge MA, 2001).
Connelly Thomas L., The Marble Man: Robert E. Lee and His Image in American Society (New York, 1977).
Copson-Niećko Maria J.E., ‘The Poles in America from the 1830s to 1870s. Some Reflections on the Possibilities of Research’, in Frank Mocha (ed.), Poles in America: Bicentennial Essays (Stevens Point, 1978), 45–301.
Derengowski Piotr, Polacy w wojnie secesyjnej 1861–1865 (Oświęcim, 2015).
Fox-Genovese Elizabeth and Eugene D. Genovese, The Mind of the Master Class: History and Faith in the Southern Slaveholders’ Worldview (Cambridge–New York, 2005).
Schievelbusch Wolfgang, Die Kultur der Niederlage. Der amerikanische Süden 1865, Frankreich 1871, Deutschland 1918 (Berlin, 2001).
Michalska-Bracha Lidia, Powstanie styczniowe w pamięci zbiorowej społeczeństwa polskiego w okresie zaborów (Kielce, 2003).
Michalska-Bracha Lidia, Między pamięcią a historiografią. Lwowskie debaty o powstaniu styczniowym (1864–1939) (Kielce, 2011).
Silber Nina, Gender and the Sectional Conflict (Chapel Hill, 2008).
Stasik Florian, Polish Political Émigrés in the United States of America, 1831–1864, transl. Eugene Podraza, ed. by James S. Pula (Boulder, 2002).
Szygowski Juliusz, Powstanie polskie w r. 1863 i Stany Zjednoczone (Paris, 1961).
Wieczerzak Joseph W., A Polish Chapter in Civil War America: The Effects of the January Insurrection on American Opinion and Diplomacy (New York, 1967).
Wolniewicz Marcin, Moskwa ante portas. Rosja w polskiej propagandzie powstańczej (1863–1864) (Poznań, 2014).
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Title, logo and layout of journal are reserved trademarks of APH.Stats
Number of views and downloads: 527
Number of citations: 0
