A Syntactical Analysis of Lewis’s Triviality Result

Claudio E. A. Pizzi

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.12775/LLP.2021.006

Abstract


The first part of the paper contains a probabilistic axiomatic extension of the conditional system WV, here named WVPr. This system is extended with the axiom (Pr4): PrA = 1 ⊃ □A. The resulting system, named WVPr∗, is proved to be consistent and non-trivial, in the sense that it does not contain the wff (Triv): A ≡□A. Extending WVPr∗ with the so-called Generalized Stalnaker’s Thesis (GST) yields the (first) Lewis’s Triviality Result (LTriv) in the form (◊(A ∧ B) ∧◊(A ∧ ¬B)) ⊃ PrB|A = PrB. In §4 it is shown that a consequence of this theorem is the thesis (CT1): ¬A ⊃ (A > B ⊃ A ⥽ B). It is then proven that (CT1) subjoined to the conditional system WVPr∗ yields the collapse formula (Triv). The final result is that WVPr∗+(GST) is equivalent to WVPr∗+(Triv). In the last section a discussion is opened about the intuitive and philosophical plausibility of axiom (Pr4) and its role in the derivation of (Triv).


Keywords


conditionals; conditional probability; Stalnaker’s Thesis; triviality; collapse of modalities

Full Text:

PDF

References


Bradley, R., and N. Swartz, 1979, Possible Worlds. An Introduction to Logic and its Philosophy, Blackwell.

Eagle, A., 2005, “Probability, modality and triviality”. Internet Resource: http://fitelson.org/few//few_05/eagle.pdf

Fattorosi-Barnaba, M., and G. Amati, 1987, “Modal operators with probabilistic interpretations”, Studia Logica 46 (4): 383–393. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00370648

Holliday,W., and T. Icard, 2014, “Modal probability logic”. Internet Resource: https://philosophy.berkeley.edu/file/922/lecture4part2.pdf and http://web.stanford.edu/~icard/esslli2014/lecture2.pdf

Kratzer, A., 2012, Modals and Conditionals, Oxford University Press.

Lewis, D.K., 1973, Counterfactuals, Blackwell.

Lewis, D.K., 1986, “Probabilities of conditionals and conditional probabilities”, The Philosophical Review 85 (3): 297–315. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/2184045

Maksimović, P., 1983, “Development and verification of probability logics and logical frameworks”, Université Nice Sophia Antipolis, 2013. https://tel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-00907854/file/2013NICE4074.pdf

Montanaro, A., and A. Bressan, 1981, “Contributions to foundations of Probability Calculus on the basis of the Modal Logical Calculus MCν or MCν∗, Rendiconti del Seminario Matematico della Università di Padova 64: 109–126.

Nute, D., 1981, Topics in Conditional Logic, Reidel.

Ognjanović, Z., M. Rašković and Z. Marković, 2009, Probability Logics, Mathematical Institute of the Serbian Academy of Sciences and Arts, Belgrade. Also: Probability Logics. Probability-Based Formalization of Uncertain Reasoning, Springer, 2016. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-47012-2

Pizzi, C.E., 1990, “Stalnaker-Lewis conditionals: Three grades of holistic involvment”, Logique et Analyse 33 (31): 311–329.

Pizzi, C.E., 2020, “Explicit conditionals in the framework of classical conditional logic”, Logic and Logical Philosophy 29 (2): 161–187. DOI: https://doi.org/10.12775/LLP.2019.030

Rescher, N., 1963, “A probabilistic approach to modal logic”, Acta Philosophica Fennica 16: 215–226.

Stalnaker, R.C., 1968, “A theory of conditionals”, pages 98–112 in N. Rescher (ed.), Studies in Logical Theory, Blackwell 1968.

Stalnaker, R.C., 1970, “Probability and conditionals”, Philosophy of Science 37 (1), 64-80. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/288280

Stalnaker, R.C., 1976, “Letter by Stalnaker to van Fraassen”, pages 302–306 in W.L. Harper and C.A. Hooker (eds.), Foundations of Probability Theory, Statistical Inference and Statistical Theories of Science, vol. I, Dordrecht: D. Reider Publishing Company.

Veltman, F., 1976, “Prejudices, presuppositions and the theory of conditionals”, pages 248–281 in J. Groenendijk and M. Stokhof (eds.), Amsterdam Papers in Formal Grammar, Vol. 1, Universiteit van Amsterdam: Centrale Interfaculteit.








ISSN: 1425-3305 (print version)

ISSN: 2300-9802 (electronic version)

Partnerzy platformy czasopism