The concept of causation in Newton’s mechanical and optical work

Steffen Ducheyne, Erik Weber



In this essay the authors explore the nature of efficient causal explanation in Newton’s "Principia and The Opticks". It is argued that: (1) In the dynamical explanations of the Principia, Newton treats the phenomena under study as cases of Hall’s second kind of atypical causation. The underlying concept of causation is therefore a purely interventionist one. (2) In the descriptions of his optical experiments, Newton treats the phenomena under study as cases of Hall’s typical causation. The underlying concept of causation is therefore a mixed interventionist/mechanicist one.


Newton, (efficient) causation; "Principia"; "The Opticks"

Full Text:



Cohen, I. Bernard, ([1958] 1978), Isaac Newton’s Papers & Letters On Natural Philosophy and related documents, 2 nd edition, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.

——– (1980), The Newtonian Revolution, with illustrations of the transformation of scientific ideas, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Dobbs, B.J.T., (1991), The Janus Faces of Genius, The role of alchemy in Newton’s thought, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Ducheyne, Steffen, (2005a), “Newton’s Training in the Aristotelian Textbook Tradition: From Effects to Causes and Back”, History of Science 43(3), 217–237.

———— (2005b), “Mathematical Models in Newton’s Principia: A New View of the “Newtonian Style””, International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 19(1), 1–19.

Glennan, Stuart, (2006), “Mechanisms and the Nature of Causation”, Erkenntnis 44, 49–71.

Hall, Ned, (2004), “Two Concepts of Causation”, in: J. Collins, N. Hall, & L.A. Paul, (eds.), Causation and Counterfactuals, Cambridge (Mass.), The MIT Press, pp. 225–276.

Hall, Rupert A., and Marie B. Hall, (eds.) (1978), Unpublished Scientific Papers of Isaac Newton, A selection from the Portsmouth Collection in the University Library, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Heimann, P.M., (1981), “Nature and Imponderables” in: G.N. Cantor and J.S. Hodge, (eds.), Conceptions of ether, Studies in the history of ether theories 1740-1900 (pp. 61-83), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Janiak, Andrew, (ed.), (2005), Newton, Philosophical Writings, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Janiak, Andrew, (2007), “Newton and the Reality of Force”, Journal for the History of Philosophy 45(1), 127–147.

Joy, Lynn S., (2006), “Scientific Explanation: From Formal Causes to Laws of Nature”, in: Katharine Park & Lorraine Daston, (eds.), The Cambridge History of Science, Volume 3: Early Modern Science, Cambridge University Press, 2006, pp. 70–105.

Laymon, R., (1978), “Newton’s Experimentum Crucis and the Logic of Idealization and Theory Refutation”, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 9, 51–77.

McGuire, James E., and Martin Tamny, (eds.), (1983), Certain Philosophical Questions: Newton’s Trinity Notebook. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

McMullin, Ernan, (1978), Newton on Matter and Activity, University of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame.

———— (1990), “Conceptions of science in the Scientific Revolution”, in: Robert S. Westmann and David C. Lindberg, (eds.), Reappraisals of the Scientific Revolution, Cambridge University Press, New York, pp. 27–92,

———— (2001), “The Impact of Newton’s Principia on the Philosophy of Science”, Philosophy of Science 68, 279–310.

Newton, Isaac, (1979), Opticks or A Treatise of Reflections, Refractions, Inflections and Colours of Light, Dover Publications, New York.

——— (1999), The Principia, Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy. Translated by Bernard I. Cohen and Anne Whitman, University of California Press; Berkeley, Los Angeles, & London.

Psillos, Stathis, (2004), “A Glimpse of the Secret Connexion: Harmonizing Mechanisms with Counterfactuals”, Perspectives on Science 12(3), 288–319.

Sabra, A.I., (1967), Theories of light: from Descartes to Newton, Oldbourne, London.

Schaffer, Simon, (1989), “Glass Works: Newton’s Prisms and the Uses of Experiment”, in: D. Gooding, T. Pinch, & S. Schaffer, (eds.), The Uses of Experiment, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 64–107.

Schliesser, Eric, (2007a), “Hume’s Newtonianism and Anti-Newtonianism”, in: The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (2007 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.),

———— (2007b), “Two Definitions of ‘Cause’, Newton, and The Significance of the Humean Distinction between Natural and Philosophical Relations”, Journal of Scottish Philosophy 5(1), 83–101.

Shapiro, Alan, (1993), Fits, passions, and paroxysms, physics, method, and chemistry and Newton’s theories of colored bodies and fits of easy reflection, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Smith, George E., (2002), “The methodology of the Principia”, in: I.B. Cohen and G.E. Smith, (eds.), The Cambridge Companion to Newton, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 138–173.

Stein, Howard, (1970), “On the Notion of Field in Newton, Maxwell, and Beyond”, in: R.H. Stuewer, (ed.), Historical and Philosophical Perspectives on Science (pp. 264–87), University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis.

Stein, Howard, (2004), “Newton’s Metaphysics, in: I.B. Cohen and G.E. Smith (eds.), The Cambridge Companion to Newton, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 256–307.

Westfall, Richard S., (1980), Never at Rest, A Biography of Isaac Newton, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Whewell, William, (1967 [1847]), The Philosophy of the Inductive Sciences, Frank Cass & Co, London.

Woodward, James, (2003), Making Things Happen, A Theory of Causal Explanation, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

————– (2002), “What is a Mechanism? A Counterfactual Account”, Philosophy of Science 69, S366–S377.

ISSN: 1425-3305 (print version)

ISSN: 2300-9802 (electronic version)

Partnerzy platformy czasopism