Debunking the Latest Scenario on the Rise of the Pork Taboo

Philippe Guillaume

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.12775/EtudTrav.31.008

Abstrakt


A number of studies from Tel Aviv date the rise of the pork taboo in Israel as early as the Iron Age I in order to salvage the notion that the taboo was a reaction to the pork-consuming habits of the hated Philistines. Though neither DNA analysis nor pig bone ratios support this scenario, these studies explain how the abhorrence of Iron Age Israelites for pork was eventually canonised in the Persian era. The present paper challenges the validity of each stage of the proposed scenario, arguing that the Hellenistic-era ethnic differentiation based on pork consumption cannot be pushed as far back as the Iron Age.

Słowa kluczowe


pigs; pork taboo; Sus; ethnicity; Iron Age Palestine; Neo-Assyrian Empire

Pełny tekst:

PDF

Bibliografia


Albarella, U. 2002: ‘Size matters’: how and why biometry is still important in zooarchaeology, [in:] Dobney, K., O’Connor, T. (Eds), Bones and the Man: Studies in Honour of Don Brothwell, Oxford, 51–62

Albarella, U. 2006: Pig Husbandry and Pork Consumption in Medieval England, [in:] Woolgar, C.M., Serjeantson, D., Waldron, T. (Eds), Food in Medieval England: Diet and Nutrition, Oxford, 72–87

Albarella, U., Manconi, F., Rowley-Conwy, P., Vigne, J.-D. 2006: Pigs of Corsica and Sardinia: a biometrical re-evaluation of their status and history, [in:] Tecchiati, U., Sala, B. (Eds), Archaeozoological Studies in Honour of Alfredo Riedel, Bolzano, 258–302

Albarella, U., Manconi, F., Trentacoste, A. 2011: A week on the plateau: Pig husbandry, mobility and resource exploitation in central Sardinia, [in:] Albarella, U., Trentacoste, A. (Eds), Ethnozooarchaeology. The Present and Past of Human-animal Relationships, Oxford, 143–159

Albarella, U., Manconi, F., Vigne, J.-D., Rowley-Conwy, P. 2007: The Ethnoarchaeology of pig husbandry in Sardinia and Corsica, [in:] Albarella, U., Dobney, K., Ervynck, A., Rowley-Conwy, P. (Eds), Pigs and Humans: 10,000 years of Interaction, Oxford, 285–307

Antonaccio, C.M. 2010: (Re)Defining Ethnicity: Culture, Material Culture and Identity, [in:] Hales, S., Hodos, T. (Eds), Material Culture and Social Identities in the Ancient World, Cambridge, 32–53

Bloch-Smith, E. 2003: Israelite Ethnicity in Iron I: Archaeology Preserves what is Remembered and what is Forgotten in Israel’s History, JBL 122, 401–425

Brown, B.A. 2014: Culture on Display: Representations of Ethnicity in the Art of the Late Assyrian State, [in:] Brown, B.A., Feldman, M.H. (Eds), Critical Approaches to Ancient Near Eastern Art, Berlin, 515–542

Callot, O. 1993: Les huileries et l’huile au Bronze récent : quelques exemples syriens etchypriotes, [in:] Amouretti, M.-C., Brun, J.-P. (Eds), La production du vin et de l’huile en Méditerranée, BCH Supp. XXVI, Paris, 55–64

Clarysse, W., Thompson, D.-J. 2006: Counting the People in Hellenistic Egypt. Volume 2: Historical Studies, Cambridge

Columella, Agriculture 1968: Columella, On Agriculture, vol. II, transl. E.S. Forster, E.H. Heff ner, LCL 407, Cambridge, Mass.-London 1968

Coote, R.B. 2006: Tribalism: Social Organization in the Biblical Israels, [in:] Esler, P.F. (Ed.), Ancient Israel: The Old Testament in Its Social Context, Minneapolis, 35–49

Crouch, C.L. 2014: The Making of Israel: Cultural Diversity in the Southern Levant and the Formation of Ethnic Identity in Deuteronomy, VetTest-Suppl. 162, Leiden

Diebner, P., Robkin, E.E. 1978: Ecology, Evolution and the Search for Cultural Origins: The Question of Islamic Pig Prohibition, CurrAnthr 19, 493–540

Douglas, M. 1975: Deciphering a Meal, [in:] Douglas, M., Implicit Meanings: Essays in Anthropology, London, 249–275

el-Huseny, A. el-H.M. 2006: Die inkonsequente Tabuisierung von Sus scrofa Linnaeus, 1758 im Alten Ägypten: seine ökonomische und religiöse Bedeutung, Berlin

Eriksen, T.H. 2010: Ethnicity and Nationalism: Anthropological Perspectives, London

Fales, F.M. 2013: Ethnicity in the Assyrian Empire: A View from the Nisbe, (I): Foreigners and ‘Special’ Inner Communities, [in:] Vanderhooft, D.S., Winitzer, A. (Eds), Literature as Politics, Politics as Literature. Essays on the Ancient Near East in Honor of Peter Machinist, Winona Lake, 47–74

Fantalkin, A. 2005: A Group of Iron Age Wineries from Ancient Jaffa (Joppa), [in:] Salvage Excavations Reports 2, Tel Aviv, 3–26

Faust, A. 2007: Israel’s Ethnogenesis: Settlement, Interaction, Expansion and Resistance, London

Faust, A. 2012: The Archaeology of Israelite Society in Iron Age II, Winona Lake

Faust, A. Bunimovitz, S. 2003: The Four-Room House: Embodying Israelite Society, NEA (ASOR) 66, 22–31

Faust, A., Lev-Tov, J. 2011: Constitution of Philistine Identity. Ethnic Dynamics in Twelfth to Tenth Century Philistia, OJA 30/1, 13–31

Finkelstein, I. 1988: Archaeology of the Israelite Settlement, Jerusalem

Finkelstein, I. 1997: Pots and People Revisited: Ethnic Boundaries in the Iron Age I, [in:] Silberman, N.A., Small, D. (Eds), The Archaeology of Israel: Constructing the Past, Interpreting the Present, JSOT-Suppl. 237, Sheffield, 216–237

Finkelstein, I. 2002: The Philistines in the Bible: A Late-Monarchic Perspective, JSOT 27/2, 131–167

Finkelstein, I. 2007: The Two Kingdoms: Israel and Judah, [in:] Schmidt, B. (Ed.), The Quest for the Historical Israel, Atlanta, 147–157

Finkelstein, I., Halpern, B., Lehmann, G., Niemann, H.M. 2006: The Megiddo Hinterland Project, [in:] Finkelstein, I., Ussishkin, D., Halpern, B. (Eds), Megiddo IV: the 1998–2002 Seasons, Institute of Archaeology of Tel Aviv University, Monograph Series 24, Tel Aviv, 705–776

Foster, B.R., Salgues, E. 2006: Everything except the Squeal. Pigs in Early Mesopotamia, [in:] Lion, B., Michel, C. (Eds), De la omestication au tabou : le cas des suidés dans le Proche-Orient ancien, Travaux de la Maison René-Ginouvès 1, Paris, 283–291

Grayson, A.K. 1991: Assyrian Rulers of the Early First Millennium BC I, Royal Inscriptions of Mesopotamia 1, Toronto

Gregg, S. 1988: Foragers and Farmers: Population Interaction and Agricultural Expansion in Prehistoric Europe, Prehistoric Archeology and Ecology 275, Chicago

Gruen, E. 2013: Did the Romans have an Ethnic Identity?, [in:] Burton, P.J. (Ed.), Culture, Identity and Politics in the Ancient Mediterranean World. Papers from a Conference in Honour of Erich Gruen, Antichthon 47, 1–17

Guillaume, P. 2016: Poor by Necessity or by Choice? Ancient Israelite Egalitarianism, [in:] Grabbe, L.L. (Ed.), The Land of Canaan in the Late Bronze Age, Library of Hebrew Bible/Old Testament Studies 636, London-New York, 102–111

Hadjikoumis, A. 2012: Traditional Pig Herding Practices in Southwest Iberia: Questions of Scale and Zooarchaeological Implications, JAA 31, 353–364

Halstead, P., Isaakidou, V. 2011: A Pig Fed by Hand is Worth Two in the Bush: Ethnoarchaeology of Pig Husbandry in Greece and its Archaeological Implications, [in:] Albarella, U., Trentacoste, A. (Eds), Ethnozooarchaeology: the Present and Past of Human-Animal Relationships, Oxford, 160–174

Hamilton-Dyer, S. 2001: The Faunal Remains, [in:] Maxfi eld, V.A., Peacock, D.P.S. (Eds), Mons Claudianus 1987–1993: Survey and Excavation, vol. 2: The Excavations, Cairo, 249–301

Harris, M. 1977: Cannibales et monarques. Essai sur l’origine des cultures, Paris

Harrison, S. 1999: Identity as a Scarce Resource, Social Anthropology 7/3, 239–251

Harrison, S. 2003: Cultural Difference as Denied Resemblance: Reconsidering Nationalism and Ethnicity, CSSH 45/2, 343–361

Henninger, J. 1982: Nouveaux débats sur l’interdiction du porc dans l’Islam, [in:] Digard, J.P. (Ed.), Le cuisinier et le philosophe. Hommage à Maxime Rodinson, Genève, 29–40

Hesse, B., Fulton, D.N., Wapnish, P. 2011: Animal Remains, [in:] Stager, L.E., Master, D.M., Schloen, J.D. (Eds), Ashkelon 3: the Seventh Century B.C., Winona Lake, 615–644

Hesse, B., Wapnish, P. 2002: An Archaeozoological Perspective on the Cultural Use of Mammals in the Levant, [in:] Collins, B.J. (Ed.), A History of the Animal World in the Ancient Near East, Handbook of Oriental Studies. Section 1. The Near and Middle East 64, Leiden-Boston, 457–491

Hocine Benkheira, M. 2006: Quelques interprétations anthropologiques du tabou du porc en Islâm, [in:] Lion, B., Michel, C. (Eds), De la domestication au tabou : le cas des suidés dans le Proche-Orient ancien, Travaux de la Maison René-Ginouvès 1, Paris, 233–244

Huehnergard, J. 1987: Ugaritic Vocabulary in Syllabic Transcription, Atlanta

Joffe, A.H. 1999: Ethnicity in the Iron I Southern Levant: Marginal Notes, Akkadica 112, 27–33

Köhler-Rollefson, I. 1995: The Animal Bones, [in:] Bennett, C.-M., Bienkowski, P. (Eds), Excavations at Tawilan in Southern Jordan, British Academy Monographs in Archaeology 8, Oxford, 97–100

Leibner, U. 2014: Determining the settlement history of Hellenistic, Roman, and Byzantine Sites in the Galilee, Israel: Comparing surface, subsurface, and stratified artifact assemblages, JFA 39/4, 387–400; DOI: 10.1179/0093469014Z.00000000088

Lemche, N.P. 2010: Avraham Faust, Israel’s Ethnogenesis, and Social Anthropology, [in:] Pfoh, E. (Ed.), Anthropology and the Bible: Cultural Perspectives, Piscataway, 93–104

Lev-Tov, J.S.E. 2012: A Preliminary Report on the Late Bronze and Iron Age Faunal Assemblage from Tell es-Safi /Gath, [in:] Maeir, A.M. (Ed.), Tell es-Safi /Gath I: The 1996–2005 Seasons, ÄAT 69, Wiesbaden, 589–612

Liphschitz, N. 2007: Timber in Ancient Israel: Dendroarchaeology and Dendrochronology, Monograph Series 26, Tel Aviv

Liphschitz, N. 2008: Reconstruction of the Arboreal Vegetation of the Judean and Samarian Mountains During Antiquity as Evident from Archaeological Wood Remains, [in:] Bar, S. (Ed.), In the Hill-Country, and in the Shephelah, and in the Arabah (Joshua 12, 8): Studies and Researches Presented to Adam Zertal in the Thirtieth Anniversary of the Manasseh Hill-Country Survey, Jerusalem, 48–55

Livingstone, A. 2013: Hemerologies of Assyrian and Babylonian Scholars, Cornell University studies in Assyriology and Sumerology 25, Bethesda, MD

Lobban, R.A. 1998: Pigs in Ancient Egypt, [in:] Nelson, S.M. (Ed.), Ancestors for the Pigs: Pigs in Prehistory, Philadelphia, 137–148

Lucy, S. 2005: Ethnic and Cultural Identities, [in:] Díaz-Andreu, M. et al., The Archaeology of Identity: Approaches to gender, age, status, ethnicity and religion, London, 86–109

MacKinnon, M. 2001: High on the Hog: Linking Zooarchaeological, Literary, and Artistic Data for Pig Breeds in Roman Italy, AJA 105, 649–673

Meiri, M., Huchon, D., Bar-Oz, G., Boaretto, E., Kolska Horwitz, L., Maeir, A.M., Sapir-Hen, L., Larson, G., Weiner, S., Finkelstein, I. 2013: Ancient DNA and Population Turnover in Southern Levantine: Pigs-Signature of the Sea Peoples Migration?, Scientific Reports 3035; DOI: 10.1038/srep03035

Mendelssohn, H., Yom-Tov, Y.A. 1999: Report of Birds and Mammals which have Increased their Distribution and Abundance in Israel due to Human Activity, Israel Journal of Zoology 45/1, 35–47

Na’aman, N. 2007: When and How did Jerusalem Become a Great City? The Rise of Jerusalem as Judah’s Premier City in the Eighth-Seventh Centuries B.C.E., BASOR 347, 21–56

Na’aman, N. 2013: The Kingdom of Judah in the 9th century bce: Text Analysis versus Archaeological Research, Tel Aviv 40, 247–276

Na’aman, N. 2014: Dismissing the Myth of a Flood of Israelite Refugees in the Late Eighth Century BCE, ZATW 126/1, 1–14

Niesiołowski-Spanò, Ł. 2013: The Philistines in Jerusalem? The Use of Archaeological Data as the Ethnic Marker: the Case of the Philistines, Other ‘Sea Peoples’, and Judah, [in:] Bombardieri, L. et al. (Eds), SOMA 2012. Identity and Connectivity: Proceedings of the 16th Symposium on Mediterranean Archaeology, Florence, Italy, 1–3 March 2012, vol. I, BAR-IS 2581, Oxford, 89–96

Niesiołowski-Spanò, Ł. 2014: The Philistines as Intermediaries between the Aegean and the Near East, [in:] Thompson, T.L., Wajdenbaum, P. (Eds), The Bible and Hellenism: Greek Influence on Jewish and Early Christian Literature, Sheffield, 89–101

Niesiołowski-Spanò, Ł. 2015: Food or Drink? Pork or Wine? The Philistines and Their ‘Ethnic’ Markers, Scandinavian Journal of the Old Testament 29, 110–116

Nowak, R.M. 1999: Walker’s Mammals of the World II, Baltimore, MD

Piątkowska-Małecka, J., Smogorzewska, A. 2010: Animal economy at Tell Arbid, northeast Syria, in the third millennium BC, BNE 4, 25–43

Poplin, F. 2006: Conclusion anthropozoologique. Le cochon, perle d’Orient : un tabou né de la domestication laitière, [in:] Lion, B., Michel, C. (Eds), De la domestication au tabou : le cas des suidés dans le Proche-Orient ancien, Travaux de la Maison René-Ginouvès 1, Paris, 325–331

Redding, R.W. 1991: The Role of the Pig in the Subsistence System of Ancient Egypt: A Parable on the Potential of Faunal Data, [in:] Crabtree, P.J., Ryan, K. (Eds), Animal Use and Culture Change, Philadelphia, 21–30

Rognon, X. 2006: Le porc domestique : biologie, zootechnie, diversité, [in:] Lion, B., Michel, C. (Eds), De la domestication au tabou : le cas des suidés dans le Proche-Orient ancien, Travaux de la Maison René-Ginouvès 1, Paris, 3–14

Ruane, N.J. 2015: Pigs, Purity, and Patrilineality: The Multiparity of Swine and Its Problems for Biblical Ritual and Gender Construction, JBL 134/3, 489–504

Sade, M. 1988: Domestic Mammals in the Iron Age Economy of the Northern Negev, unpublished MA thesis, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv

Sapir-Hen, L., Bar-Oz, G., Gadot, Y., Finkelstein, I. 2013: Pig Husbandry in Iron Age Israel and Judah. New Insights Regarding the Origin of the ‘Taboo’, ZDPV 129/1, 1–20

Sapir-Hen, L., Meiri, M., Finkelstein, I. 2015: Iron Age Pigs: New Evidence of their Origin and Role in Forming Identity Boundaries, Radiocarbon 57, 307–315

Sasson, A. 2010: Animal Husbandry in Ancient Israel: a zooarchaeological perspective on livestock exploitation, herd management and economic strategies, London

Sasson, A., Greenfi eld, H.J. 2014: The Second Revolution of Secondary Products: Do Mortality Profiles Reflect Herd Management or Specialized Production?, [in:] Greenfi eld, H.J. (Ed.), Animal Secondary Products: Archaeological Perspectives on Domestic Animal Exploitation in the Neolithic and Bronze Age, Oxford, 206–218

Shavit, A. 2008: Settlement Patterns of Philistine City-States, [in:] Fantalkin, A., Yasur-Landau, A. (Eds), Bene Israel, Studies in the Archaeology of Israel and the Levant during the Bronze and Iron Ages in Honour of Israel Finkelstein, Culture and History of the Ancient Near East 31, Leiden, 135–164

Shaw, I. 1986: Report on the 1983 Excavations. The Animal Pens (Building 400), [in:] Kemp, B. (Ed.), Amarna Reports I, EES Occasional Publications 1, London, 40–59

Sherratt, A. 1981: Plough and Pastoralism: Aspects of the Secondary Products Revolution, [in:] Hodder, I., Isaac, G., Hammond, N. (Eds), Pattern of the Past: Studies in Honour of David Clarke, Cambridge, 261–305

Stager, L.E. 1995: The Impact of the Sea Peoples in Canaan (1185–1050 BCE), [in:] Levy, T.E. (Ed.), The Archaeology of Society in the Holy Land, London, 332–348

Tsahar, E., Izhaki, I., Lev-Yadun, S., Bar-Oz, G. 2009: Distribution and Extinction of Ungulates during the Holocene of the Southern Levant, PLoS ONE 4(4): e5316; DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0005316

Veldhuis, N. 2006: How to Classify Pigs: Old Babylonian and Middle Babylonian Lexical Texts, [in:] Lion, B., Michel, C. (Eds), De la domestication au tabou : le cas des suidés dans le Proche-Orient ancien, Travaux de la Maison René-Ginouvès 1, Paris, 25–29

Vila, E. 2004: The Fauna of Early Bronze Sidon, Archaeology and History in Lebanon 19, 92–105

Viré, F. 2010: Khinzīr, [in:] EncIsl; DOI: 10.1163/9789004206106_eifo_SIM_4289 (accessed July 8, 2018)

Volokhine, Y. 2014: Le porc en Egypte ancienne : mythes et histoire à l’origine des interdits alimentaires, Liège

Wilson, K.A. 2005: The Campaign of Pharaoh Shoshenq I into Palestine, FAT 2/9, Tübingen

Wolinski, P. 2010: Will the Real Philistine Please Stand Up? A Case Study of Ethnic Identification in the Early Iron Age Southern Levant, [in:] Matthiae, P. et al. (Eds), Proceedings of the Sixth International Congress of the Archaeology of the Ancient Near East 5 May - 10 May 2008, Sapienza, Università di Roma, vol. 1, Wiesbaden, 591–601

Zeder, M.A. 1996: The Role of Pigs in Near Eastern Subsistence: a view from the southern Levant, [in:] Seger, J.D. (Ed.), Retrieving the Past: Essays on archaeological Research and in honor of Gus W. Van Beek, Winona Lake, 297–312


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Partnerzy platformy czasopism